I'm not ignoring what you are claiming.
I just don't see everything as facts that you are posting.
Please don't take not agreeing as ignoring.
Quote (ferdia @ Mar 28 2024 05:19pm)
it seems to me that:
1. you have ignored all the evidence posted over the last 2 years related to America's involvement in the coup in 2014 (and critically the appointment of government officials post the coup).
I will not deny that there was no involvement of the USA in the Ukraine in the last 10-20 years.
That said they were not nearly as involved as Putin who tried several times to implement a head of state of his own mercy
Claiming that Maidan protests were an American coup is false, by definition a coup is “typically an illegal and overt attempt by a military organization or other government elites to unseat an incumbent leadership.”
Also please keep in mind that:
• Euromaidan started not for Yanukovych’s resignation
• The parliament, where his party had a majority, removed Yanukovych, he was unbearable by his own party at a certain point.
• The parliament started new elections
In this thread the wish for an alignment with both Europe and Russia by the Ukranian population is never mentioned and thus vastly underestimated.
Quote (ferdia @ Mar 28 2024 05:19pm)
2. you are ignoring US official documents and comments related to the loans provided to Ukraine, in congress, from the oval office, in distinguished publications, all posted in this topic over the last 2 years.
I’m not ignoring them, I say that not everything that has been given to Ukraine is a traditional loan which has to be paid back.
In view of the Russian invasion, considerable financial efforts have to be made to keep the Ukrainian state running, making it less productive for various reasons.
Quote (ferdia @ Mar 28 2024 05:19pm)
3. you are ignoring the declassified documents, again, posted in this thread, related to russia's red lines and US political and military establishments understandings of them.
I’m not ignoring them, I’m saying that no formal application has been made by Ukraine to join NATO until after the war began and that there was strong opposition 2008 in Bucharest in consideration of Russia’s interests by major NATO members, ruling out the possibility of Ukraine joining NATO.
Again I would like to remind you that while US is a major NATO member, any NATO member can veto an application of a candidate.
Quote (ferdia @ Mar 28 2024 05:19pm)
I don’t know about you but I have little faith in the UN at this point, given how little they were able to lead to appeasement in the most recent conflicts.
Apart from this there has been various investigations going on led by different countries.
Quote (ferdia @ Mar 28 2024 05:19pm)
5. your version of Chatgpt is not up to date. It was widely reported recently (and supporting documents posted in this thread) that the US continues to ensure there will be no negotiation with Russia.
For the answers, chatgpt 3.5 was used. As it stated it does entail information leading up to 2022. Below I posted a result from gemini.
Then again I don’t see why we should use AI to try and prove a point.
This post was edited by Gala on Mar 28 2024 11:11am