Compiled Melee Crit Chance Stats To Date (28Feb2019)


Compiled Club Crit Chance:
128str 121dex 12cs - 21% (n=8)
79str 90dex 6cs - 15% (n=2)
79str 91dex 0cs - 10.5% (n=4)
119str 125dex 1cs - 10.3% (n=3)
119str 52dex 1cs - 5% (n=3)
98str 69dex 0cs - 4.5% (n=2)
221str 34dex 1cs - 4% (n=3)
98str 34dex 0cs - 1% (n=2)


Compiled Warhammer Crit Chance:
Nothing yet


Compiled Sword Crit Chance:
117str 83dex 13cs - 29.3% (n=3)
124str 76dex 13cs - 24% (n=3)
119str 125dex 0cs - 20% (n=2)
147str 53dex 13cs - 19% (n=3)
159str 41dex 13cs - 16% (n=3)
119str 52dex 0cs - 9.5% (n=2)
221str 34dex 0cs - 6.5% (n=2)


Compiled Longsword Crit Chance:
90str 34dex 5cs - 15.8% (n=4)
90str 34dex 8cs - 15.7% (n=3)
80str 40dex 2cs - 12% (n=3)
67str 53dex 0cs - 11.4% (n=5)
95str 53dex 0cs - 11.2% (n=10)
92str 53dex 0cs - 11.1% (n=14)
64str 41dex 1cs - 10% (n=3)
95str 32dex 0cs - 8% (n=12)
77str 32dex 0cs - 7.6% (n=8)
55str 32dex 0cs - 7.5% (n=2)
114str 32dex 0cs - 7.3% (n=25)
114str 32dex 0cs - 6.4% (n=5)
63str 13dex 0cs - 2.1% (n=19)


Compiled Axe Crit Chance:
70str 98dex 11cs - 20.5% (n=4)
70str 133dex 0cs - 18.25% (n=4)
133str 70dex 0cs - 17.75% (n=4)
70str 70dex 0cs - 14% (n=4)
95str 39dex 0cs - 7.7% (n=12)


Compiled Battleaxe Crit Chance:
132str 39dex 0cs - 14.3% (n=18)
90str 36dex 5cs - 13.7% (n=7)
55str 41dex 6cs - 13.3% (n=16)
114str 34dex 0cs - 12% (n=5)
102str 34dex 0cs - 11.3% (n=18)
77str 34dex 0cs - 9.8% (n=6)
95str 34dex 0cs - 9.3% (n=12)


Compiled Staff Crit Chance:
No data yet


Compiled Polearm Crit Chance:
55str 58dex 1cs - 11.3% (n=9)
55str 72dex 0cs - 11% (n=5)
55str 78dex 0cs - 10.4% (n=5)


Compiled Dagger Crit Chance:
45str 118dex 11cs - 13.2% (n=5)
103str 114dex 0cs - 9% (n=9)
45str 116dex 0cs - 3.9% (n=10)


Compiled Spear Crit Chance:
No data yet


Thank you to our testers!
izParagonzi (90% of all the test data!!!)
Jedimagi (Our only dagger tester so far!!)
Meridius (The most amount of crit strike at lvl 1!)

Posted following in other thread, sure you have read it. Damn, it may sound nice to some, sleeping around 18 hours a day is nice, but, hell no.

These are the ones that interested me more:

128str 121dex 12cs - 21% (n=8) - Hypothesis: Stat ratio equivalent / 12 CS = 10% (based on next one down)
79str 90dex 6cs - 15% (n=2) - Hypothesis: 11 point difference / 6 CS = 5%(based on next one down)
79str 91dex 0cs - 10.5% (n=4) - Hypothesis: 12 point difference / 0 CS = 10% Critical Hit Chance
119str 125dex 1cs - 10.3% (n=3) - Hypothesis: Compare top CS / % Critical Hit chance. It seems compatible.

How to balance out more damage and keeping a range of 10% Critical Hit chance. Guessing this would also
be the same with Warhammers. The low end and high end damage of this weapon having 10% Crit Hit chance
makes it more appealing.
____________________

Have the dog over for the weekend hopefully, since she sits on the bed, I should be able to get in more testing.

Ignore my PM, I just realised I made an idiotic request.

I know Daggers have been tested, this is basically testing Critical Strike.

Samurai [Base strength 45 / dexterity 50]
Dagger
Explore
8 crit strike
1% armor pierce
0% powershot

Lvl 01.00 - 02.76 Str 45 Dex 50 1/020___3/020___1/020___2/020___3/020 --- Crits/Hits: 10/100 Crit rate: 10% [.76 gain / 1 hit kill]
Lvl 02.76 - 03.85 Str 45 Dex 50 2/020___1/020___3/020___4/020___1/020 --- Crits/Hits: 11/100 Crit rate: 11% [.09 gain / 1 hit kill]
Lvl 03.85 - 04.82 Str 45 Dex 50 2/020___1/020___3/020___1/020___3/020 --- Crits/Hits: 10/000 Crit rate: 10% [-.03 no gain / 1-4 hit kill]
Lvl 04.82 - 05.47 Str 45 Dex 50 3/020___2/020___2/020___3/020___4/020 --- Crits/Hits: 14/100 Crit rate: 14% [-.35 no gain / 1-4 hit kill]
Lvl 05.47 - 05.90 Str 45 Dex 50 1/020___1/020___0/020___2/020___3/020 --- Crits/Hits: 07/100 Crit rate: 07% [59 actions vs 3 EPs]
Lvl 05.90 - 06.36 Str 45 Dex 50 2/020___1/020___1/020___1/020___2/020 --- Crits/Hits: 08/100 Crit rate: 08% [38 actions vs 2 EPs]
Lvl 06.36 - 06.93 Str 45 Dex 50 3/020___3/020___2/020___2/020___4/020 --- Crits/Hits: 14/100 Crit rate: 14% [2-5 hit kills]
Lvl 06.93 - 07.48 Str 45 Dex 50 0/020___1/020___1/020___4/020___2/020 --- Crits/Hits: 08/100 Crit rate: 08% [2-6 hit kills]
Lvl 07.48 - 07.93 Str 45 Dex 50 0/020___1/020___2/020___1/020___1/020 --- Crits/Hits: 05/100 Crit rate: 05% [3-6 hit kills]

Lvl 07.93 - 00.00 Str 45 Dex 50 0/000___0/000___0/000___0/000___0/000 --- Crits/Hits: 00/000 Crit rate: 00%

Lvl 00.00 - 00.00 Str 45 Dex 50 0/000___0/000___0/000___0/000___0/000 --- Crits/Hits: 00/000 Crit rate: 00%

I like reading these test reports. the only thing i think you should add is total damage. It should be easy to show this and could help to figure out how much average damage you lose by getting more crits, if any
It seems like you are putting more points in the opposite stat in order to crit, but this will lower your normal damage output
you could easily show the average damage

Well I'd need to change my testing for that

When I test I do start from level 1 and just do 100 actions count crits, the do another 100, etc
up to level 5 and then I reroll and change stats/gear

I was actually thinking that when they posted the thread on crits with clubs. Like sure we see a way higher crit rate but the ratios are meant to give the weapon the most average damage for the range of damage. Super focused ranges should have high crits to boost dmg where as weapons with large ranges should boost the base damage because crits are unreliable.

Adding either an average damage or total damage section would help alot assuming you arent changing the weapon itself.

You dont need to chsnge anything just record average damage after 100 actions

These sound like good ideas, but you can only control so many things at once... As Meridius said, we'd have to change things a lot to test damage... for now we're only interested in crit chance in this thread. Another thread for optimizing damage dealt using some of the information we discover here could be in order though. Feel free to make such a thread and we can post in there different kinds of tests

Im not saying i want you to optimize or change anything....
Just list total or average damage in the tests you are doing already
. You are adjusting stats in your tests as already, just list damage comparisons