does this one count as best?

Mythical mithril chain mail
Level Req: 25
Physical Defense: 35 to 88
Magical Defense: 0 to 35

+134% Enhanced Effect
+30 Vitality
+20 Intelligence
+2 Extra Equipment Slots
+1% Magical Damage Reduction
ID 248656

no

At current rating, yes

Mystical shell scale armor
Level Req: 10
Physical Defense: 12 to 48
Magical Defense: 12 to 36

+154% Enhanced Effect
+30 Dexterity
+2 Mana Regen

https://ladderslasher.d2jsp.org/itemHistory.php?i=266466&c=0

348329

dunno if it fits both ee and dex sections or ^^

didn't see lvl 10 spear on there so here's mine.. I know it's not that special but there it is kek

Magical steel spear
Level Req: 10
Damage: 124 to 218

+100% Enhanced Effect

(no history but here's link anyways for ID)
https://ladderslasher.d2jsp.org/itemHistory.php?i=1218060533&c=0

348329

This post was edited by Lpot on Jan 1 2019 01:29am

Was just looking at this and it looks like the charm I found went into 3rd place instead of 2nd place. Both charms are 45 total str/dex, but I had guessed that 3 QD and usable on all classes would trump 1% experience and usable on all classes except guardian. Am I missing something?

I would also say yours definitely has a leg up on the other one.

3% QD and 4% glancing > 1% xp gain

This post was edited by Cheeya on Jan 8 2019 02:14pm

This is the other charm

Mythical lightning VIII
Level Req: 25
Spell Damage: 21 to 215
Mana Cost: 61

+90% Enhanced Effect
+29 Strength
+16 Dexterity
+1% Experience Gained
+3% Armor Pierce

Here is your charm

Angelic wild heal VIII
Level Req: 25
Heals: 9 to 92
Mana Cost: 61

+34 Strength
+11 Dexterity
+3% Quick Draw
+4% Glancing Blow


You mean that 90 ee is worth less than 4% glancing blow?

Nice itams much wows

I missed this but wow



Personally would prefer the lower charm due to distribution of Str/Dex and the side mods (although AP is sexy af).

That the EE on the top charm is a very niche mod. If that same charm had spawned on a wild there would be no question its superior as then it would have the hybrid potential for salvation or something on the side. Just dont see many melee using the casting portion of it besides the rare person that might kill sneaky with it just for fun?

Salvation is with a heal charm in the accessory. Why would anyone use salvation at this level or use a 0 ee heal charm for salvation?

EE can take out immunes which is very useful for solo. Using up that mana pool in the low/mid levels for something useful. If you're healing yourself in the low/ mid levels on melee you should either play a caster or get better gear.

This isn't a question of preference. 90ee and 1% experience gain is obviously better than 4% glancing blow. Armor pierce is debatably better than quick draw, at least in lower%. EE on charm scales with int, glancing blow doesn't.

If the distribution was 40 str or 40 dex 5 of the other stat then I would agree with you but both are pretty much mainly good for axes. THen you may argue, oh I can use the wild heal with swords or clubs. First of all, if you're using axes you're not using swords or clubs and second of all, you can find a 38-40 str lvl 25 charm no problem and that would be more effective for these other weapons.