d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > General Help > Site Suggestions >
Poll > ** Guild Alliances! Renewed! ** > With A Guest Appearence From: Titan !
Prev1133134135136137142Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 38,178
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 401.80
Mar 7 2021 02:37pm
Quote (Josha @ Dec 20 2020 01:21am)
Remake with a working image pls


New images are up, in case you were curious. ;)
Member
Posts: 16,604
Joined: Jul 29 2010
Gold: 10,687.34
Warn: 90%
Mar 7 2021 09:11pm
Quote (Epiphany @ 7 Mar 2021 12:37)
New images are up, in case you were curious. ;)


He is your Guildmate. I think he would know. :)

So Seriously though why not multiple Alliances? Ladder Slasher mentions Pvp.

https://ladderslasher.d2jsp.org/index.php?g=1

Multiple Alliances are a common thing in history.

So why not allow the Best of the Titans enjoy the Best of it.

Member
Posts: 27,804
Joined: Mar 13 2006
Gold: 950.69
Trader: Trusted
Mar 8 2021 12:29am
Quote (Archive @ Mar 1 2021 10:09am)
The idea is good but concretely, I think that it would create a huge gap between the current large guilds (which will ally themselves) and the smaller ones.

I'm afraid this will only further strengthen the larger guilds.

So i don't know. There is an aspect of balance and fairness missing for all guilds in my opinion.



I’m confused. Are you saying that if Enhanced Effect and Unfair Advantage have an alliance no one will be able to catch them in guild points? Because I think that’s a true statement regardless of alliances.


I vote yes, would be cool to share guild chats with allied guilds. I don’t think it needs to be limited to 1. All you’re sharing is LS items and guild chats.

I could see this being really cool if you wanted to have a private topic with your allied guilds to have events and play games together.

Thanks for fixing your image Sam. Pretty sure I voted 10 years ago, but my vote is a renew yes
Member
Posts: 38,178
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 401.80
Mar 12 2021 08:08pm
ty buddy :)

Bump!
Member
Posts: 78,204
Joined: Jun 24 2007
Gold: 31,213.56
Mar 13 2021 04:01am
We’re not at war, so no, doesn’t make any sense to me

This post was edited by Stefbef on Mar 13 2021 04:01am
Member
Posts: 16,604
Joined: Jul 29 2010
Gold: 10,687.34
Warn: 90%
Mar 13 2021 06:18am
Quote (Josha @ 7 Mar 2021 22:29)
I’m confused. Are you saying that if Enhanced Effect and Unfair Advantage have an alliance no one will be able to catch them in guild points? Because I think that’s a true statement regardless of alliances.


I vote yes, would be cool to share guild chats with allied guilds. I don’t think it needs to be limited to 1. All you’re sharing is LS items and guild chats.

I could see this being really cool if you wanted to have a private topic with your allied guilds to have events and play games together.

Thanks for fixing your image Sam. Pretty sure I voted 10 years ago, but my vote is a renew yes


Why did you decide limiting to 1 Guild is not needed?

Quote (Stefbef @ 13 Mar 2021 02:01)
We’re not at war, so no, doesn’t make any sense to me


Do you think adding Alliances would cause jsp wars?
Member
Posts: 78,204
Joined: Jun 24 2007
Gold: 31,213.56
Mar 13 2021 07:14am
Quote (Sempervirens @ 13 Mar 2021 13:18)
Why did you decide limiting to 1 Guild is not needed?



Do you think adding Alliances would cause jsp wars?



No i just don’t see the point of alliances
Member
Posts: 16,604
Joined: Jul 29 2010
Gold: 10,687.34
Warn: 90%
Mar 13 2021 07:20am
Quote (Stefbef @ 13 Mar 2021 05:14)
No i just don’t see the point of alliances


I think the very word and definition of Alliance can be seen thousands of different ways.

For example you mentioned war. That is a major con not mentioned in the OP.

Now I am not saying people here are going to start Guild wars and regularly because of an official Alliance feature. It is bond to happen though. I know negativity can get dragged out on users for years after such events.

In addition some people in an Alliance may not hold their own ground and may try to request or influence the assistant of others. This could result in spam, unnecessary drama, and more. These are already some things that exist here without official site Alliances. An Official Site Alliance Feature will lead to these problems and more unless mitigated or managed otherwise. Who, what, when, how, why, etc is not properly in place here on this site to do that. As Ladder Slasher has a section set aside for PvP I cannot Rule out Alliances being a real thing but I don't see it happening right now. I cannot speak for the near future but if so then having open discussions about the future of Alliances (realistic or not) should be embraced not avoided.

This post was edited by Sempervirens on Mar 13 2021 07:53am
Member
Posts: 51,666
Joined: Apr 8 2007
Gold: 10,683.52
Mar 13 2021 08:08am
Quote (Stefbef @ Mar 13 2021 08:14am)
No i just don’t see the point of alliances



It’s 100% a ladder slasher suggestion

When you are in a guild you can send your gear to guild maxes via guild vault transfer

This is asking to allow me to say lend gear to mooj the leader of ua

If he was in a climb and was needing a certain part of gear to make climb faster
Member
Posts: 16,604
Joined: Jul 29 2010
Gold: 10,687.34
Warn: 90%
Mar 13 2021 08:37am
Quote (slushslush @ 13 Mar 2021 06:08)
It’s 100% a ladder slasher suggestion

When you are in a guild you can send your gear to guild maxes via guild vault transfer

This is asking to allow me to say lend gear to mooj the leader of ua

If he was in a climb and was needing a certain part of gear to make climb faster


Guilds are site wide and can be used for whatever a Guild Owner can officially use them for. A Guild Alliance woupd be seen as site wide. If it was just a Ladder Slasher suggestion then it should be presented as so and without the confusion of what an Alliance is or what that could cause.



This post was edited by Sempervirens on Mar 13 2021 08:42am
Go Back To Site Suggestions Topic List
Prev1133134135136137142Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll