Quote (ozzyarmy3 @ Jan 15 2023 06:22pm)
Adding lean mass is directly correlated with an improvement of your overall health. Excess adipose tissue is directly related to a shorter lifespan with significant morbidities such as heart disease and kidney disease.
This is mostly from studies about correlations, not cause and effects. How it really works by an example: say, you're 180cm. Max acceptable weight would be around 80kg. Some people have got thinner frame so theirs would be 77-78kg, big boned people would lean towards 81-83kg. Your genetical makeup usually prevents you to become heavier than that if you live an active life style and don't eat like a pig.
The process of aging is directly related to the amount of oxygen you consume throughout your life and wear and tear on your heart/organs. If you weigh 80kg you need to eat enough calories to sustain that mass. By burning energy, you free free radicals which cause you to age. The more you breathe, use up energy, the faster you age. Muscles are metabolically more active than fat. If your fat percentage is 12-15% (healthy male) you need less energy to sustain that mass than when you've got more muscles. Yes, with more muscles you're less likely to get fat because your daily consumption is higher but why no just eat less

See, the argumentation is backwards, you don't need more muscles to compensate for your overeating, you need to eat less.
The other part is the heart and the organs. You need a minimum level of activity to ensure they all function properly. It's called cardiovascular activity or short cardio. A weak heart has to beat more often to sustain the 80kg than a strong one. The heart ages faster, so do you with your main motor. You have to have cardio in your training to keep your heart+organs in balance for that reason however there's no need to run marathons or jog every morning. That's also bullshit propagated by the fitness and mode industry in order to sell more shoes, fix broken knees, hips etc. It's enough to do just 2x 30min equivalent of running per week. It's like walking 2 hours fast or riding a bicycle for an hour or choose an activity of your choice. Then, two or three times per month you need strength training (not bulking up training with sets etc. which actually trains endurance and some strength) to keep your bone density high, muscle activation acute (neuronal paths) and to stimulate keeping/increasing your muscle mass (depends 95% on genetics). Most effective activators are front squats, pullups, military press and deadlifts. You do them 3 x 3-5 reps with as heavy as possible.
That's it actually.
Quote (ozzyarmy3 @ Jan 15 2023 06:22pm)
Excessive adipose tissue protecting vital organs is such a weird argument, I’m not even sure how to discuss that…. How oddly specific of an instance do you need to be in where excessive fat will likely protect your vital organs against an outside stimuli? More likely than dying of heart disease from being overweight?
We've got a misunderstanding here. I didn't say it's okay to be overweight or fat to have organ stability. I said having a six pack is unhealthy. Why? You get bellow 12% body fat. I'm not going to google for you everything. You need minimum amount of fat for organ and heart stability (heart is surrounded by fat tissue). By having 15% body fat at 80kg, you're neither fat or overweight, you just don't see your sixpack. 8% bodyfat is so hard to achieve for a healthy human body, for it's very unhealthy and unnatural state for the body. Most influencers or bodybuilders use roids and other stuff to achieve that "feat".
Quote (ozzyarmy3 @ Jan 15 2023 06:22pm)
Nobody is saying that peak health is being exotically lean and muscular, even pros know that, but to say that they’re in the same position as an obese person is silly.
Again, in no way is muscular person comparable to a fat person. But exceedingly overweight people (muscles included) who train a lot, specially cardiovascular activities (cardio is actually harder than strength training on the body) die/age faster. I'd never recommend an adipose person to do cardio training to lose weight (commonly recommended by trainers). Overweight people shouldn't train at all until their weight is brought down to accepatable levels by diet alone. They shouldn't do any exercise besides walking.
This post was edited by babun1024 on Jan 15 2023 02:48pm