d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Computers & IT > Upgrade From Intel To Amd
Prev123456Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 4,599
Joined: Jun 12 2017
Gold: 30,002.70
Aug 7 2019 01:30am
Quote (NatureNames @ Aug 6 2019 10:26pm)
Your story reminds me of my friend who just switched from AMD to Intel. One of their big reasons was their AMD system would get random blue screens all the time. They tried reinstalling windows, getting all updates, etc. But it kept happening. They convinced themselves it was AMD to blame without any solid proof. System hangs or blue screens could be caused by many different things. Unless you do investigate troubleshooting and find the problem it is a bit foolish to blame the CPU manufacturer. While it's not impossible for a CPU to go bad, I think it is highly unlikely under normal circumstances.


i understand that, but nothing about my hardware changed aside from various graphics cards, and the only "software" change I had was a bios update for the ssd which shouldn't have had any negative impact.
ssd tests completely fine, ram tests completely fine, gpu fine as well (within its performance range on each card i had), so my only outlier was the cpu

literally nothing about my use-case scenario had changed within the time period of me owning the chip aside from never torrenting anymore because i'm lazy & gpu/bios like i mentioned.

my only other thought is misapplication of my liquid metal tim for the cpu die but i was extremely careful on first application of it and even ended up reapplying it down the road and it looked within spec from my first application when removing the ihs.
i had never bluescreened aside from an unstable undervolt once, bumped it up a tad and ran *plenty* of tests and played many games, never happened again. system performance just dropped over time even on a fresh install.

This post was edited by handlewithnocare on Aug 7 2019 01:32am
Member
Posts: 15,960
Joined: Nov 29 2008
Gold: 40.64
Aug 7 2019 02:34am
Quote (handlewithnocare @ Aug 7 2019 12:30am)
i understand that, but nothing about my hardware changed aside from various graphics cards, and the only "software" change I had was a bios update for the ssd which shouldn't have had any negative impact.
ssd tests completely fine, ram tests completely fine, gpu fine as well (within its performance range on each card i had), so my only outlier was the cpu

literally nothing about my use-case scenario had changed within the time period of me owning the chip aside from never torrenting anymore because i'm lazy & gpu/bios like i mentioned.

my only other thought is misapplication of my liquid metal tim for the cpu die but i was extremely careful on first application of it and even ended up reapplying it down the road and it looked within spec from my first application when removing the ihs.
i had never bluescreened aside from an unstable undervolt once, bumped it up a tad and ran *plenty* of tests and played many games, never happened again. system performance just dropped over time even on a fresh install.


I would suspect the ASRock mobo- cheap brand and a rocky history. ASRock was an offshoot Asus did to compete with cheap OEM boards in prebuilt machines. The company has since been sold to Pegatron. I digress. The mobo is just a suspicion though. Removing the IHS and applying liquid metal is dangerous stuff. Doesn't really matter at this point since you can't easily diagnose that without having another Z97 and 4790k to swap everything out.

My only point was you don't know what was causing the system hang ups. it's unreasonable to blame Intel.
Member
Posts: 20,978
Joined: Apr 19 2006
Gold: 85.00
Aug 7 2019 07:33am
Quote (handlewithnocare @ Aug 7 2019 12:13am)
it couldn't have possibly been chip degradation (undervolting, delidded & always kept cool) and the only thing to have changed in that time was a new graphics card (290 > 980ti > 1080ti > 2080) and an nvme ssd

if it were anything, it was a bios update for the nvme ssd, but i doubt that.



3700x seems to be working fine tbh
small hiccup with the ram speeds but that's settled now so i'm gucci



i mean i've always liked amd, and i loved my 4790k when i got it because of the immediate upgrade from the 8320, but random system hangs became more and more apparent over time
i seriously doubt it was user error, it's basically impossible to do that if you have any common sense.
system wasn't bogged down at any point, all i do is internet browse and game/stream occasionally, which a 4790k is more than capable of.


Quote (handlewithnocare @ Aug 7 2019 02:30am)
i understand that, but nothing about my hardware changed aside from various graphics cards, and the only "software" change I had was a bios update for the ssd which shouldn't have had any negative impact.
ssd tests completely fine, ram tests completely fine, gpu fine as well (within its performance range on each card i had), so my only outlier was the cpu

literally nothing about my use-case scenario had changed within the time period of me owning the chip aside from never torrenting anymore because i'm lazy & gpu/bios like i mentioned.

my only other thought is misapplication of my liquid metal tim for the cpu die but i was extremely careful on first application of it and even ended up reapplying it down the road and it looked within spec from my first application when removing the ihs.
i had never bluescreened aside from an unstable undervolt once, bumped it up a tad and ran *plenty* of tests and played many games, never happened again. system performance just dropped over time even on a fresh install.




hey my child bogged down system and many unexperienced pc users bog down theirs too but its the cpu manufacturer lol

like I said user error


Quote (NatureNames @ Aug 7 2019 03:34am)
I would suspect the ASRock mobo- cheap brand and a rocky history. ASRock was an offshoot Asus did to compete with cheap OEM boards in prebuilt machines. The company has since been sold to Pegatron. I digress. The mobo is just a suspicion though. Removing the IHS and applying liquid metal is dangerous stuff. Doesn't really matter at this point since you can't easily diagnose that without having another Z97 and 4790k to swap everything out.

My only point was you don't know what was causing the system hang ups. it's unreasonable to blame Intel.


asrock is fine but yes unreasonable to blame
when I use to flip and fix pcs i'd find many users were bloatware knobs which pretty much caused many of the issues
but loved those that wanted to sell off perfectly fine machines for cheap cause they are going to get newest lol
Member
Posts: 769
Joined: Apr 17 2019
Gold: 1.69
Aug 7 2019 12:48pm
Quote (yupitsmeh @ Aug 7 2019 08:33am)
hey my child bogged down system and many unexperienced pc users bog down theirs too but its the cpu manufacturer lol

like I said user error




asrock is fine but yes unreasonable to blame
when I use to flip and fix pcs i'd find many users were bloatware knobs which pretty much caused many of the issues
but loved those that wanted to sell off perfectly fine machines for cheap cause they are going to get newest lol


What if you get blue screens after a fresh reinstall of windows after reformatting with nothing installed?
Also swapped out ram, still blue screen. Swapped out ssd. Still blue screen. Swapped out gpu. Still blue screen. Swapped out power supply. Still blue screen.

Motherboard and cpu issue?
Member
Posts: 109,874
Joined: Feb 1 2006
Gold: 10,152.00
Aug 7 2019 12:51pm
Could be driver related even on fresh install.
Best bet would to post the mini dumps to have it evaluated
Member
Posts: 769
Joined: Apr 17 2019
Gold: 1.69
Aug 7 2019 12:53pm
Quote (King Atrhur @ Aug 7 2019 01:51pm)
Could be driver related even on fresh install.
Best bet would to post the mini dumps to have it evaluated


If the cpu/mobo was bought used and overclocked heavily by previous owner could that be an issue?
Member
Posts: 20,978
Joined: Apr 19 2006
Gold: 85.00
Aug 7 2019 12:57pm
Quote (ggurg0d @ Aug 7 2019 01:48pm)
What if you get blue screens after a fresh reinstall of windows after reformatting with nothing installed?
Also swapped out ram, still blue screen. Swapped out ssd. Still blue screen. Swapped out gpu. Still blue screen. Swapped out power supply. Still blue screen.

Motherboard and cpu issue?


maybe? windows completely updated or newest build installed so many build versions of windows its work
there are many things to narrow it down to what though
i'd be looking at bluescreen error with bluescreenviewer/etc to give me insight of what is crashing

Member
Posts: 20,978
Joined: Apr 19 2006
Gold: 85.00
Aug 8 2019 01:52pm
Quote (NatureNames @ Aug 7 2019 03:34am)
I would suspect the ASRock mobo- cheap brand and a rocky history. ASRock was an offshoot Asus did to compete with cheap OEM boards in prebuilt machines. The company has since been sold to Pegatron. I digress. The mobo is just a suspicion though. Removing the IHS and applying liquid metal is dangerous stuff. Doesn't really matter at this point since you can't easily diagnose that without having another Z97 and 4790k to swap everything out.

My only point was you don't know what was causing the system hang ups. it's unreasonable to blame Intel.


how is asrock extreme6 suspicious
please explain this one
Member
Posts: 10,248
Joined: Nov 30 2010
Gold: 670.00
Aug 8 2019 02:31pm
Quote (kclla @ Jul 27 2019 09:53pm)
I mean I'd bet money that it's a better gaming experience than a 5 Gen old 4 Core

I'm sure you can squeeze more FPS out of the 9900K for sure.


u get 10fps more on a 9900k then the new ryzen ... but for specific titles... for 2-300$ more.. price per performance isnt worth... team blue isnt keeping up with team red... AMD is going to surpass intel in universal cpu... intel is becoming a niche targeted at people who do a ton of heavy multiple core work... 4k editing etc...

but Amd is less then 3% behind... now when they were 20-23% behind and they did it in less then 8months... so intels failing they also failed to reduce the di to 7nm while AMD did it... plus when the BIN an chip its horrible and you have to pay a premium for unlocked chips while amd just gives it too you out the box
Member
Posts: 20,978
Joined: Apr 19 2006
Gold: 85.00
Aug 8 2019 02:40pm
Quote (solicit @ Aug 8 2019 03:31pm)
u get 10fps more on a 9900k then the new ryzen ... but for specific titles... for 2-300$ more.. price per performance isnt worth... team blue isnt keeping up with team red... AMD is going to surpass intel in universal cpu... intel is becoming a niche targeted at people who do a ton of heavy multiple core work... 4k editing etc...

but Amd is less then 3% behind... now when they were 20-23% behind and they did it in less then 8months... so intels failing they also failed to reduce the di to 7nm while AMD did it... plus when the BIN an chip its horrible and you have to pay a premium for unlocked chips while amd just gives it too you out the box


@ bolded explain more
because amd smokes intel at price to performance in majority of work load tasks

things like adobe, cad, gaming, etc that take advantage of stronger cores (and that is only because of the higher clocks) and certain loads(avx) are intels only prize right now
amd smt is better than intels too
Go Back To Computers & IT Topic List
Prev123456Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll