Quote (IceMage @ 4 Dec 2020 14:35)
Like I said, I don't view the health of a political party strictly by how well they do electorally. If 4 years of massive incompetence, corruption, and cruelty is rewarded with record turnout... that reveals something dark about American society. The Republican party and right-wing in general in this country the last 4 years has fallen pretty hard. These people are angrier, crazier, and more detached from reality than they were before Trump showed up. So while it's good electorally for Republicans that Trump brought new people out, and did well with Hispanics, it's not a positive indicator for the health of the Republican party, or democracy in general, moving forward.
Trump's support is predicated on his personality cult, negative partisanship, grievance politics, etc. He didn't even run a populist, nationalist campaign this time. How many times did he even bring up immigration or the wall? It was 24/7 grievance and "Dems bad". And it worked.
So you would prefer a party with a consistent ideology and a "sensible" platform that keeps losing election after election and loses more and more institutional power? Do you seriously think
that would make for a more healthy party?
Look, I get where you're coming from, I'm fully aware that the GOP was, and perhaps still is, playing with the fire. But they were in a position where they had to take this kind of risk to prevent them from slipping further and further, to the point of irrelevance. This argument was articulated better than I ever could in the following article:
https://claremontreviewofbooks.com/digital/the-flight-93-election/I think the key point where we're disagreeing is that you think all these Trump voters are angry and full of grievances because they're nasty or stupid people, or hopeless cases left behind by the leftward undertow of modern society, while I think that they're angry for damn good reason. You seem to think that it would be for the best of the country if these people were left without a political home, without proper democratic representation. I think that their issues and grievances have been ignored for far too long, and that they will keep throwing human grenades like Donald Trump at DC until they are heard, truly heard.
The Democratic party and the mainstream media didnt learn their lesson, and they would have been "punished" by a second Trump term if they hadn't been bailed out by a pandemic ex machina. That's perhaps what's frustrating me the most about 2020, from a political point of view: none of the conflicts were truly settled. Trump had proven too erratic and incompetent, so he had to go, but aside from that, the country is back to square one; the outlook are 4 years of stalemate under a lame duck presidency.
This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Dec 4 2020 08:31am