Quote (Black XistenZ @ Oct 3 2022 06:57pm)
They point of contention isn't that it's ineffective, it's that not everyone can do it. The world only needs so many tax havens, not every country can rely exclusively on the financial sector to carry their GDP.
On the contrary, the world doesn't "need" a tax haven but there will always be one.
Ireland is not even the biggest. Just check out Jersey, the channel islands or British virgin islands.
If they could corporations would not pay any taxes, funneling all income through loopholes.
At a point there needs to be some compromise like setting up HQ's in competitive regions eg Ireland
Ireland don't have a monopoly on low corporation tax any other well placed country could compete.
My specific point is that being within the UK, Scotland does not fully control its tax flows.
While being similarly setup to London (not the city of London)
or to Manchester.
Eg English speaking, secular, high levels of education
Edinburgh is similarly capable of becoming a global hub for business.
With one main difference. Property prices.
£100k will get you 5x or 10x the property in Scotland as it would in London.
Very attractive proposition if you were looking to setup an international headquarters.
The UK government knows this and they do not want compete with another player on their doorstep.
Vice versa their is huge potential for an independent Scotland in essentially competing with or even undercutting England.
Again, I actually don't agree with lower and lower corporate taxes. I do however see it as a means to an end of the union.