d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Football & Rugby >
Poll > Which Hit Was Dirtier?
Prev14567812Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
  Guests cannot view or vote in polls. Please register or login.
Member
Posts: 66,871
Joined: Feb 24 2009
Gold: 250.00
Warn: 10%
Nov 20 2019 12:11pm
Quote (EmericAn @ Nov 20 2019 06:52am)
If the crown of the helmet hit Mason he literally could have died. A brick weighs 5 pounds a helmet ways 6 pounds.

I’m sorry, but that’s 1,000 times dirtier than Gronk laying the people’s elbow on someone. I understand he missed 1 game due to injury and Mason zero games. But that doesn’t change the facts


Pretty sure these people are all just trolling. If not, I'm legit concerned about everyone here.
Member
Posts: 40,619
Joined: Jan 9 2007
Gold: 23.00
Nov 20 2019 12:12pm
Quote (Jewlio @ Nov 20 2019 05:41am)
gronk because it was a cheap shot blind attack with full body weight to the head
that randolph nerd was the one attacking myles and saw it the whole way, hes just slow to react like he is on the field


Almost as bad as Ryan.
Member
Posts: 35,685
Joined: Jan 19 2004
Gold: 79,366.46
Nov 20 2019 12:16pm
Quote (jadeoshbogosh @ Nov 20 2019 01:11pm)
Pretty sure these people are all just trolling. If not, I'm legit concerned about everyone here.

Same. I honestly don't see how a superficial bump on the noggin even compares to permanent brain damage, especially in a league that claims to care about player safety.
Member
Posts: 42,679
Joined: Jul 8 2008
Gold: 8,000.00
Nov 20 2019 12:17pm
it is interesting that the bills players just wanted a flag, Steelers wanted to knock Garrett out
Member
Posts: 23,749
Joined: Sep 8 2008
Gold: 14,550.00
Nov 20 2019 12:19pm
Quote (Terps @ Nov 20 2019 01:09pm)
Alright, so what Garrett did is agreed to be only marginally worse at most.

With Gronk's suspension as a baseline, I would say we're looking at a one game suspension plus a fine.


he should get 1 game plus a fine, but also a paycheck for running security on the field.

i think 1 game plus like a $100 fine is more than fair.

mason should need to write myles a written apology and do a public service announcement proving he learned from his mistakes. we can't have people kicking other players in the groin after a play, or attempting to remove their helmets. that is completely uncalled for, i think we can all agree on that.
Member
Posts: 14,327
Joined: Jan 16 2009
Gold: 10.94
Nov 20 2019 12:34pm
Quote (Terps @ Nov 20 2019 01:16pm)
Same. I honestly don't see how a superficial bump on the noggin even compares to permanent brain damage, especially in a league that claims to care about player safety.


Does the outcome make one more dirty than the other? Would you rather have a guy jump on your back 10 times or get hit in the head with a helmet 10 times? Obviously if you knew the outcomes in advance you would take getting hit with a helmet but let's say you dont.
Member
Posts: 30,314
Joined: Nov 7 2015
Gold: 15.20
Nov 20 2019 12:36pm
Garrett for sure but Gronk was still dirty as fuck

Would you rather take the Gronk hit or Garrett? Gronk all day. Garrett could have potentially killed Rudolph.
Member
Posts: 2,590
Joined: Sep 15 2019
Gold: 74.00
Nov 20 2019 12:37pm
Quote (003 @ Nov 20 2019 07:34pm)
Does the outcome make one more dirty than the other? Would you rather have a guy jump on your back 10 times or get hit in the head with a helmet 10 times? Obviously if you knew the outcomes in advance you would take getting hit with a helmet but let's say you dont.


Context is important
In the helmet scenario u would be charging at a guy brandishing a helmet after u just started a fight & kicked him in the nuts

This post was edited by Panther_is_kill on Nov 20 2019 12:40pm
Member
Posts: 14,327
Joined: Jan 16 2009
Gold: 10.94
Nov 20 2019 12:42pm
Quote (Panther_is_kill @ Nov 20 2019 01:37pm)
Context is important
In the helmet scenario u would be charging at a guy brandishing a helmet after u just started a fight & kicked him in the nuts


That's fine. Even as a steelers fan I'm not happy with his actions. But people throw tantrums all the time in the NFL.

If I cut you off in traffic and then cuss you out, does that give you the right to pull a knife on me?
Member
Posts: 2,590
Joined: Sep 15 2019
Gold: 74.00
Nov 20 2019 12:43pm
Quote (003 @ Nov 20 2019 07:42pm)
That's fine. Even as a steelers fan I'm not happy with his actions. But people throw tantrums all the time in the NFL.

If I cut you off in traffic and then cuss you out, does that give you the right to pull a knife on me?

Goodness no

That's such an awful comparison 😕

This post was edited by Panther_is_kill on Nov 20 2019 12:43pm
Go Back To Football & Rugby Topic List
Prev14567812Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll