d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > Sports Coliseum > Baseball > Astros Back In The News > Sign Stealing
Prev1678910Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 21,689
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,445.24
Warn: 10%
Jan 31 2020 03:55am
Quote (stuartg85 @ Jan 20 2020 06:51am)
i was like 12 during that bonds sosa race and it's honestly the last time baseball has been exciting


Never happened.

Member
Posts: 3,466
Joined: Oct 6 2015
Gold: 0.00
Jan 31 2020 06:45am
Quote (sirthom @ Jan 31 2020 03:55am)
Never happened.


Truth it was Sosa/Big Mac
Member
Posts: 23,566
Joined: Apr 5 2010
Gold: 22,821.00
Feb 21 2020 11:08am
When McGuire broke the record the whole sports world went crazy!

What a time to be alive!
Member
Posts: 43,773
Joined: Jul 12 2009
Gold: 13,750.00
Feb 21 2020 01:16pm
Quote (MigNado @ Feb 21 2020 12:08pm)
When McGuire broke the record the whole sports world went crazy!

What a time to be alive!


i'm curious why all these players are saying how good they'd be knowing pitches (trout, stanton, judge, etc)

houston's splits show they were better on the road than at home

also, some of those videos that show the banging are so real time i have to question how prevalent it really was

there's some where the second the catcher shows the sign there's a bang

didn't they say it was relayed to a room, then shouted down a hallway to the dugout trashcan?

you're telling me a bunch of dudes with the education of an 8 year old can read a sign, decode it, yell it down a hall to another player who understands immediately to process to bang or not?

also, the logic of the system seems flawed

"no bang = fastball"

what if they just couldn't decode in time? rofl. almost seems like an unproductive advantage, you think "hmmm no bang, fastall" but it's just that the ballboy didn't find the drum stick fast enough

This post was edited by stuartg85 on Feb 21 2020 01:17pm
Member
Posts: 21,689
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,445.24
Warn: 10%
Feb 21 2020 02:56pm
Quote (stuartg85 @ Feb 21 2020 01:16pm)
i'm curious why all these players are saying how good they'd be knowing pitches (trout, stanton, judge, etc)

houston's splits show they were better on the road than at home

also, some of those videos that show the banging are so real time i have to question how prevalent it really was

there's some where the second the catcher shows the sign there's a bang

didn't they say it was relayed to a room, then shouted down a hallway to the dugout trashcan?

you're telling me a bunch of dudes with the education of an 8 year old can read a sign, decode it, yell it down a hall to another player who understands immediately to process to bang or not?

also, the logic of the system seems flawed

"no bang = fastball"

what if they just couldn't decode in time? rofl. almost seems like an unproductive advantage, you think "hmmm no bang, fastall" but it's just that the ballboy didn't find the drum stick fast enough


so their cheating is lessened because it may not always have been effective? ridiculous....

cheating is cheating. they should all be banned for life and title stripped.
go homer somewhere else.

but everyone cheats so is ok right?
Member
Posts: 43,773
Joined: Jul 12 2009
Gold: 13,750.00
Feb 21 2020 02:59pm
Quote (sirthom @ Feb 21 2020 03:56pm)
so their cheating is lessened because it may not always have been effective? ridiculous....

cheating is cheating. they should all be banned for life and title stripped.
go homer somewhere else.

but everyone cheats so is ok right?


ok, so the sox and yankees should both have been banned too then...

https://www.sny.tv/yankees/news/what-are-the-yankees-accused-of-in-sign-stealing-scandal-and-what-are-the-facts/312352288

"Weber openly admitted this to the league during its investigation. That's it. Technically a violation"

cheating is cheating, right?

i'm not saying they didn't break a rule, i'm asking how people think this provided an advantage when the numbers don't show it
Member
Posts: 21,689
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,445.24
Warn: 10%
Feb 21 2020 04:34pm
double post, opps

This post was edited by sirthom on Feb 21 2020 04:37pm
Member
Posts: 21,689
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,445.24
Warn: 10%
Feb 21 2020 04:37pm
Quote (stuartg85 @ Feb 21 2020 02:59pm)
ok, so the sox and yankees should both have been banned too then...

https://www.sny.tv/yankees/news/what-are-the-yankees-accused-of-in-sign-stealing-scandal-and-what-are-the-facts/312352288

"Weber openly admitted this to the league during its investigation. That's it. Technically a violation"

cheating is cheating, right?

i'm not saying they didn't break a rule, i'm asking how people think this provided an advantage when the numbers don't show it


im perfectly ok with that, ban them all. zero tolerance.

Member
Posts: 43,773
Joined: Jul 12 2009
Gold: 13,750.00
Feb 21 2020 04:45pm
Quote (sirthom @ Feb 21 2020 05:37pm)
im perfectly ok with that, ban them all. zero tolerance.


ok, so vacate every world series from what, 1985 through 2010?

again though, any insight into the advantage from sign stealing?

Member
Posts: 43,773
Joined: Jul 12 2009
Gold: 13,750.00
Feb 21 2020 04:50pm
Quote (stuartg85 @ Feb 21 2020 05:45pm)
ok, so vacate every world series from what, 1985 through 2010?

again though, any insight into the advantage from sign stealing?


oh, and the cardinals in 2013-2016 since that's when he was caught? ban that team from the league maybe?

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/former-st-louis-cardinals-executive-pleads-guilty-to-hacking-houston-astros/

Go Back To Baseball Topic List
Prev1678910Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll