d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo > Diablo 3 > D3 Discussion > Worth Playingin 2018?
Prev13456712Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 16,621
Joined: Jan 7 2017
Gold: 90.58
Jul 22 2018 12:50pm
Quote (D_urRRR @ Jul 22 2018 05:54am)
I have an item you need, you have one I need, we exchange it.

Oh my look at what we have here, a trade.


But that's gated behind a 2 hour trade limit window, and only people you partied with AFAIK. That's not trading, that's temporary sharing :(
Member
Posts: 19,183
Joined: Nov 12 2005
Gold: 30.70
Jul 22 2018 01:00pm
Quote (JohnMiller92 @ Jul 22 2018 02:50pm)
But that's gated behind a 2 hour trade limit window, and only people you partied with AFAIK. That's not trading, that's temporary sharing :(


As it's not ideal, I understand the opposing point of view, but I still feel it's trading, because it is an exchange of items.
Member
Posts: 4,525
Joined: Jun 7 2014
Gold: 179.00
Jul 22 2018 01:05pm
Quote (D_urRRR @ Jul 22 2018 02:00pm)
As it's not ideal, I understand the opposing point of view, but I still feel it's trading, because it is an exchange of items.



You're sharing items.

I can't open a trade window with you at any moment for an item you may need that I found a few days ago.

Just face the fact that you lost
Member
Posts: 7,730
Joined: Apr 4 2016
Gold: 0.00
Jul 22 2018 01:19pm
Quote (D_urRRR @ Jul 22 2018 03:00pm)
As it's not ideal, I understand the opposing point of view, but I still feel it's trading, because it is an exchange of items.


you're unfit to raise children
Member
Posts: 16,621
Joined: Jan 7 2017
Gold: 90.58
Jul 22 2018 01:26pm
Quote (D_urRRR @ Jul 22 2018 11:00am)
As it's not ideal, I understand the opposing point of view, but I still feel it's trading, because it is an exchange of items.


What if I want to give you an item right now?

We can't. So what's that called?

This post was edited by JohnMiller92 on Jul 22 2018 01:26pm
Member
Posts: 19,183
Joined: Nov 12 2005
Gold: 30.70
Jul 22 2018 01:47pm
Quote (HeroOfSwag @ Jul 22 2018 03:05pm)
You're sharing items.

I can't open a trade window with you at any moment for an item you may need that I found a few days ago.

Just face the fact that you lost


I didn't lose lol.

Sharing an item would be you using said item, and I use it, in the same fashion how I have PvP characters on D2 that I share with friends on this site. Sharing and trading are 2 very different things.

Quote (JohnMiller92 @ Jul 22 2018 03:26pm)
What if I want to give you an item right now?

We can't. So what's that called?


That item would be account bound in this scenario. That same item could be found while in a party grinding with me and can be exchanged for an item I find that you need. That event is a trade well made. If I gave an item I find, that is simply a donation. If I play and everything I find that is tradeable, won't be once I pass through that window of tradeable opportunity.

This post was edited by D_urRRR on Jul 22 2018 01:48pm
Member
Posts: 16,621
Joined: Jan 7 2017
Gold: 90.58
Jul 22 2018 01:54pm
Quote (D_urRRR @ Jul 22 2018 11:47am)
I didn't lose lol.

Sharing an item would be you using said item, and I use it, in the same fashion how I have PvP characters on D2 that I share with friends on this site. Sharing and trading are 2 very different things.



That item would be account bound in this scenario. That same item could be found while in a party grinding with me and can be exchanged for an item I find that you need. That event is a trade well made. If I gave an item I find, that is simply a donation. If I play and everything I find that is tradeable, won't be once I pass through that window of tradeable opportunity.


Yeah I meant my last post to be more of a rhetorical. But yeah, it's "technically" trading, but it's a gimped version of it, and not even beneficial towards the game though

This post was edited by JohnMiller92 on Jul 22 2018 01:55pm
Member
Posts: 10,057
Joined: Oct 10 2011
Gold: 701.02
Jul 22 2018 02:04pm
Quote (JohnMiller92 @ Jul 22 2018 03:54pm)
Yeah I meant my last post to be more of a rhetorical. But yeah, it's "technically" trading, but it's a gimped version of it, and not even beneficial towards the game though



Stop using logic
Member
Posts: 19,183
Joined: Nov 12 2005
Gold: 30.70
Jul 22 2018 02:06pm
Quote (JohnMiller92 @ Jul 22 2018 03:54pm)
Yeah I meant my last post to be more of a rhetorical. But yeah, it's "technically" trading, but it's a gimped version of it, and not even beneficial towards the game though


Agreed. And this is honestly where this subject should end, not just with us, because we can easily understabd one another, but as a whole section in general.
Member
Posts: 7,730
Joined: Apr 4 2016
Gold: 0.00
Jul 22 2018 02:07pm
Quote (D_urRRR @ Jul 22 2018 03:47pm)
That same item could be found while in a party grinding with me and can be exchanged for an item I find that you need. That event is a trade well made.


that doesnt happen you fucking idiot
Go Back To D3 Discussion Topic List
Prev13456712Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll