d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > d2jsp > General Help > Rating Traders?
12Next
Closed New Topic
Member
Posts: 42,707
Joined: Jul 1 2007
Gold: 1,427.50
Jan 26 2022 10:39am
A random idea that I've thought about.

How do you feel about a system where we can rate people we do trades with?

And having some sort of system where we can view their history and rating?

I don't really have any specific ideas of the nitty gritty of it, but it seems like a possible thing to implement.

Thoughts?
Retired Moderator
Posts: 45,222
Joined: Jul 15 2008
Gold: 86,015.80
Trader: Trusted
Jan 26 2022 10:40am
Pretty sure that was suggested several times before and got denied.
Member
Posts: 40,446
Joined: Dec 5 2007
Gold: 7,517.50
Warn: 10%
Jan 26 2022 10:41am
This is very good idea.

Make topic here:

https://forums.d2jsp.org/forum.php?f=258
Member
Posts: 42,707
Joined: Jul 1 2007
Gold: 1,427.50
Jan 26 2022 10:49am
Quote (dj_cj @ 26 Jan 2022 11:40)
Pretty sure that was suggested several times before and got denied.



Why was it denied?
Member
Posts: 11,370
Joined: Apr 12 2009
Gold: 1,772.20
Jan 26 2022 10:53am
This has been recommended several times in the past.

This will not be happening, we already have Verified members, trusted, and then staff. Throwing in ratings opens up for manipulation and trolls being able to leverage eachother's ratings or perhaps scammers intentionally increasing their ratings so that they are deemed "more trustworthy"

Ratings, join date, post count don't really matter, they don't solve root problems.

The only solution is to use a mediator.
Member
Posts: 42,707
Joined: Jul 1 2007
Gold: 1,427.50
Jan 26 2022 10:57am
Quote (Krawk @ 26 Jan 2022 11:53)
This has been recommended several times in the past.

This will not be happening, we already have Verified members, trusted, and then staff. Throwing in ratings opens up for manipulation and trolls being able to leverage eachother's ratings or perhaps scammers intentionally increasing their ratings so that they are deemed "more trustworthy"

Ratings, join date, post count don't really matter, they don't solve root problems.

The only solution is to use a mediator.


I'm not saying this is a solution to scamming or anything like that.

I'm viewing this as a way to see who's a shithead/bm trader kind of thing.

But I understand what you're saying.
Retired Moderator
Posts: 14,105
Joined: Sep 28 2021
Gold: 1.00
Trader: Trusted
Jan 26 2022 10:59am
I’m voting no on this as this function can and will be used maliciously by some if implemented.
Member
Posts: 14,746
Joined: Nov 30 2005
Gold: 16,276.50
Jan 26 2022 11:00am
Already have one, it's the scammer tag
Retired Moderator
Posts: 23,621
Joined: May 13 2007
Gold: 0.69
Trader: Trusted
Jan 26 2022 11:04am
Quote (Krawk @ Jan 26 2022 09:53am)
This has been recommended several times in the past.

This will not be happening, we already have Verified members, trusted, and then staff. Throwing in ratings opens up for manipulation and trolls being able to leverage eachother's ratings or perhaps scammers intentionally increasing their ratings so that they are deemed "more trustworthy"

Ratings, join date, post count don't really matter, they don't solve root problems.

The only solution is to use a mediator.


This.

Always use a mediator. It’s fast, free, and secure:
https://forums.d2jsp.org/info.php?p=11


Member
Posts: 42,707
Joined: Jul 1 2007
Gold: 1,427.50
Jan 26 2022 11:10am
Quote (Lionhearted @ 26 Jan 2022 11:59)
I’m voting no on this as this function can and will be used maliciously by some if implemented.


It's not a poll. I posted this here on purpose.


Quote (Vibrations @ 26 Jan 2022 12:04)
This.

Always use a mediator. It’s fast, free, and secure:
https://forums.d2jsp.org/info.php?p=11


Like I said, my thought process behind this isn't to replace mediators or even prevent scamming.
Go Back To General Help Topic List
12Next
Closed New Topic