And be in playoffs, but not win it all? lol absolutely not

What does getting into the playoffs get you? Do you get a trophy? Does it get added to your resume? Does it improve your chances for the HOF? Nope, nobody will remember a team "making the playoffs" and not winning it all.

What does winning the leagues MOST VALUABLE PLAYER award get you? A spot in baseball history.

This post was edited by Sixers on Nov 24 2021 03:54pm

Lol wuttt

Crazy shit.

MVP Award > Just making the playoffs


Winning it all? Sure, i could see that. But just making the playoffs? Useless.

That statement is dumb as shit. Only reason they had a chance to make playoffs was cuz of Wheeler and Harper's mvp season.
Not sure why he has to have 0 mvp votes to be in the playoffs.

100% yes

gotta get there to win it.

look what the braves just did

I'm not sure if you're talking about his statement or mine.

But....i'm saying if you had to choose winning an MVP award and not making the playoffs, OR not winning MVP and making the playoffs but being eliminated in the first round? Easy, i'll take MVP.



Yes, if you win it all, sure.

But if you don't, then MVP is 100000% more valuable. Just making the playoffs and not winning it all is cool and all, but nobody remembers that.

Everyone remembers league MVP's, especially two time league MVP's.

I just don't get why u have to chose? Like why is Harper not getting mvp mean Phillies make playoffs? The hypothetical situation itself is really stupid.

Yes, agreed. We're saying if you had to choose, like in your career to have one MVP award OR make the playoffs once but not win it all.

Which would you prefer? MVP of course.

MVP award comes first to everything except winning a World Series. And honestly, a lot of guys would rather have the MVP award too (even though they won't admit that).

If ur not first, ur last. So I'll take thr mvp over having a mediocre season and getting bounced in the first(the one time you make it)

shouldnt be mvp if your not on a team that makes the playoffs also

forgot to throw that out there


if you cant get ur club into the dance who fuckin cares