d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > Legit Dueling > United Guilds Melee Ladder > Us East Non Ladder
Prev15435445455465473166Next
Add Reply New Topic
Views: 617491Replies: 31651Track Topic
Member
Posts: 28,258
Joined: Jan 29 2004
Gold: 2,000.00
#5441
May 4 2010 10:22pm
Quote (LilNeko @ May 5 2010 12:16am)
Hows 2 available people!??! He just skipping one person and that's aleph. try can't challenge 2 ahead because HORM IS AFK.

if you want idc..it's really bad decission tbh. brad going say same thing  or say something agree with you but hey it's your decission. -_-


I didn't know anyone was on hold lol you just asked me if 18 vs 15 would be 2 spots or 3 and it's clearly 3 ><

But since 16 is on hold it's fine to just skip him and challenge 15. 17 can also challenge 14 since we're just making it seem like the skipped person doesn't exist. Only fair way of going about it. But no he shouldn't get removed just because he's being on hold for 2 weeks since that's not a big deal.
Member
Posts: 15,513
Joined: Apr 22 2009
Gold: 0.00
#5442
May 4 2010 10:23pm
Quote (dark-soul @ May 5 2010 12:22am)
I didn't know anyone was on hold lol you just asked me if 18 vs 15 would be 2 spots or 3 and it's clearly 3 ><

But since 16 is on hold it's fine to just skip him and challenge 15. 17 can also challenge 14 since we're just making it seem like the skipped person doesn't exist. Only fair way of going about it. But no he shouldn't get removed just because he's being on hold for 2 weeks since that's not a big deal.


Ok then.
Member
Posts: 103,224
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 15,410.01
#5443
May 4 2010 10:23pm
Quote (CoffeeMasterX @ May 4 2010 09:21pm)
14. nflgo/nfl-conc/whitebread—Conc

15. Biglouy/Biglouy/Luis—Conc

16. HormigaBrava/Panasonic./Tribune—Zeal <-- skip til May 14

17. uqbar98/mitos/Zlt—Zeal

18. Tryambaka/baka_pvp/Tryambaka—Fury

Ok, here we go Jess.

You let tryambaka challenge Biglouy, that's 3 ranks above his, because hormigabrava is afk. He could have challenged either 17 or 15, according to you. Two available people.

You basically said uqbar98 couldn't do the same thing, he could only challenge biglouy, and since Hormigabrava is "afk," he can't challenge anyone else, giving him only one possible challenge, unlike Tryambaka.

Therefore, to be fair, uqbar98 can challenge nflgo, which is also technically 3 ranks above him, seeing as the afk person is holding these people up. Either let him challenge Dave, or remove hormigabrava from the ladder.

It's not fair to force someone to wait just because someone can't duel.

Please explain how this is wrong.


3) You are allowed to challenge up to 2 ranks above you

15. Biglouy/Biglouy/Luis—Conc

16. HormigaBrava/Panasonic./Tribune—Zeal <-- skip til May 14

17. uqbar98/mitos/Zlt—Zeal

18. Tryambaka/baka_pvp/Tryambaka—Fury

i count 2 for try cuz horm is unable to duel soo he has no choice to challenge biglouy. only person uqbar can challenge is biglouy you get it or no? LOL
Quote (dark-soul @ May 4 2010 09:22pm)
I didn't know anyone was on hold lol you just asked me if 18 vs 15 would be 2 spots or 3 and it's clearly 3 ><

But since 16 is on hold it's fine to just skip him and challenge 15. 17 can also challenge 14 since we're just making it seem like the skipped person doesn't exist. Only fair way of going about it. But no he shouldn't get removed just because he's being on hold for 2 weeks since that's not a big deal.


hes on hold for like 2 weeks..:( It's 2 spots clearly lol

but mehh u2 decissions. it's clearly reads 2 spots.

This post was edited by LilNeko on May 4 2010 10:25pm
Member
Posts: 19,729
Joined: Apr 7 2010
Gold: 100.23
#5444
May 4 2010 10:24pm
Quote (dark-soul @ May 5 2010 12:22am)
I didn't know anyone was on hold lol you just asked me if 18 vs 15 would be 2 spots or 3 and it's clearly 3 ><

But since 16 is on hold it's fine to just skip him and challenge 15. 17 can also challenge 14 since we're just making it seem like the skipped person doesn't exist. Only fair way of going about it. But no he shouldn't get removed just because he's being on hold for 2 weeks since that's not a big deal.


That is odd reasoning Jess, you're letting him skip horm because he can't duel horm?

That's giving one person an unfair advantage by jumping 3 spots, the skip should apply as a void till he's back. To keep everyone on a level field

This post was edited by Meatyy on May 4 2010 10:26pm
Member
Posts: 28,258
Joined: Jan 29 2004
Gold: 2,000.00
#5445
May 4 2010 10:24pm
Quote (LilNeko @ May 5 2010 12:23am)
3) You are allowed to challenge up to 2 ranks above you

15. Biglouy/Biglouy/Luis—Conc

16. HormigaBrava/Panasonic./Tribune—Zeal <-- skip til May 14

17. uqbar98/mitos/Zlt—Zeal

18. Tryambaka/baka_pvp/Tryambaka—Fury

i count 2 for try cuz horm is unable to duel soo he has no choice to challenge biglouy.  only person uqbar can challenge is biglouy you get it or no? LOL


The rule doesn't really include "on hold" ranks so it's kinda diff. 17 can challenge 14 and 18 can challenge 15. I dunno people going on hold kind of messes things up but it happens no big deal.
Member
Posts: 15,513
Joined: Apr 22 2009
Gold: 0.00
#5446
May 4 2010 10:25pm
Quote (LilNeko @ May 5 2010 12:23am)
3) You are allowed to challenge up to 2 ranks above you

15. Biglouy/Biglouy/Luis—Conc

16. HormigaBrava/Panasonic./Tribune—Zeal <-- skip til May 14

17. uqbar98/mitos/Zlt—Zeal

18. Tryambaka/baka_pvp/Tryambaka—Fury

i count 2 for try cuz horm is unable to duel soo he has no choice to challenge biglouy.  only person uqbar can challenge is biglouy you get it or no? LOL


I really don't understand how you are not getting this. I am no longer part of this issue. He can make the challenge. Problem solved.
Member
Posts: 103,224
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 15,410.01
#5447
May 4 2010 10:26pm
Quote (dark-soul @ May 4 2010 09:24pm)
The rule doesn't really include "on hold" ranks so it's kinda diff. 17 can challenge 14 and 18 can challenge 15. I dunno people going on hold kind of messes things up but it happens no big deal.


correctly. @_@
Quote (Meatyy @ May 4 2010 09:24pm)
This. Looks like everyone is an agreement on this note. So does that mean you're staying ugbar? Kinda lame to leave over something that can easily be solved by simple reasoning.


mehh whatever, if you 2 wants to put it up. i don't rlly care. it's clearly read 2 spots. plus its says rules.
Quote (CoffeeMasterX @ May 4 2010 09:25pm)
I really don't understand how you are not getting this. I am no longer part of this issue. He can make the challenge. Problem solved.


soo if 2# is skipped it's possible 3 vs 1 or 4 v1 ? that's cool.

This post was edited by LilNeko on May 4 2010 10:27pm
Member
Posts: 28,258
Joined: Jan 29 2004
Gold: 2,000.00
#5448
May 4 2010 10:26pm
Quote (CoffeeMasterX @ May 5 2010 12:25am)
I really don't understand how you are not getting this. I am no longer part of this issue. He can make the challenge. Problem solved.


Well there's nothing in the rules about people holding their rank while they're away so if we just go by the rules then she's right.

So much drama in this thread lately -_-

In the future please just send any issues via pm to myself or another admin so it gets resolved quickly.

This post was edited by dark-soul on May 4 2010 10:27pm
Member
Posts: 15,513
Joined: Apr 22 2009
Gold: 0.00
#5449
May 4 2010 10:27pm
Quote (dark-soul @ May 5 2010 12:26am)
Well there's nothing in the rules about people holding their rank while they're away so if we just go by the rules then she's right.


No, if she let's Try skip over him then she's being a hypocrite.
Member
Posts: 103,224
Joined: Jun 6 2006
Gold: 15,410.01
#5450
May 4 2010 10:28pm
Quote (dark-soul @ May 4 2010 09:26pm)
Well there's nothing in the rules about people holding their rank while they're away so if we just go by the rules then she's right.


Quote (CoffeeMasterX @ May 4 2010 09:27pm)
No, if she let's Try skip over him then she's being a hypocrite.


I'm going by rules..and i wish i was hypocrite. -_- soo basicly soo if 2# is skipped it's possible 3 vs 1 or 4 v1 ? that's cool.


This post was edited by LilNeko on May 4 2010 10:28pm
Go Back To Legit Dueling Topic List
Prev15435445455465473166Next
Add Reply New Topic

© 2003-2026 d2jsp  Contact