d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > Legit Dueling > United Guilds Melee Ladder > Us East Non Ladder
Prev1227822792280228122823123Next
Add Reply New Topic
Member
Posts: 12,416
Joined: Jan 15 2013
Gold: 105.69
Feb 8 2016 06:16pm
Quote (Gtakin @ Feb 8 2016 05:45pm)
fuck it.. im in

Gtakin/Gtakin./Duramax/Zeal

now what?

lol


challenge people, get your rank up

establish dominance, become an alpha

@RightBaked

No change on #1

No change on #2 (rule #3)

You shouldn't be allowed to skip ranks, especially if you are able to make it to the top.

There's a reason for a rank - system.

"To be the best, you have to beat the best"

sup

Member
Posts: 6,685
Joined: Sep 13 2008
Gold: 24.00
Feb 8 2016 06:26pm
Quote (Beingly @ Feb 8 2016 06:03pm)
yes and no

no extensions sounds good ppl wont have to bother posting asking for one it also clears up the confusion of when to ask for it

and dueling everyone at the top is fair imo should stay as is


This ^

also,

challenging
07. DjOrchard17/DjOrchard17/EastDown - Zeal (assuming he is still @ 7)
Member
Posts: 37,627
Joined: May 22 2010
Gold: 66.00
Feb 8 2016 06:49pm
rewriting this cause it didnt really make sense

#1 we are voting to remove extentions and make challenges 5 days long(or 6 please specify if you would like 6 or i will assume the current 5 days with extention is fine)

#2 we are voting to revise rule #3 so 1st can be challenged from third

#1
Yes - 7
no- 5

#2

yes-4
no -3
Member
Posts: 17,219
Joined: Jun 19 2011
Gold: 223,475.00
Feb 8 2016 07:04pm
Rule #3

Its just a matter of opinion , I remember Mike and I dueling (top2) each other over and over untill we quit from mass boredom , it protects the top 2 the most and doesn't give the rest of list to even challenge.

#3 spot barely gets a chance to challenge cause busy defending from the 2 below them.

It stalemates the top 3 more than anything , I tried both versions and with out that rule it promotes a little bit more movement , at least a chance for people to challenge for top 3 spots.

In the end the top players rise and defend regardless , if they cant get past #3 then they quit.

Food for thought , I want to join maybe shortly ;)
Member
Posts: 58,674
Joined: Mar 3 2010
Gold: 36,219.00
Trader: Trusted
Feb 8 2016 07:35pm
for me, i wouldn't mind a change on the challenge length. 5 day challenge with no extension.
as for the #3 rule, i've battled damn hard to get #1 before, and am trying to now. the #3 has 48 full hours to try to challenge #2 if they lose. this has been the way since the inception and seems fitting.
what happens then if #3 challenges #1 and wins. does #2 auto downgrade to #3? seems unjust for those who have clawed their way to where they are.

summary: 1-yes 2-no
Member
Posts: 12,416
Joined: Jan 15 2013
Gold: 105.69
Feb 8 2016 07:38pm
Quote (Jubeii52 @ Feb 8 2016 08:35pm)
for me, i wouldn't mind a change on the challenge length. 5 day challenge with no extension.
as for the #3 rule, i've battled damn hard to get #1 before, and am trying to now. the #3 has 48 full hours to try to challenge #2 if they lose. this has been the way since the inception and seems fitting.
what happens then if #3 challenges #1 and wins. does #2 auto downgrade to #3? seems unjust for those who have clawed their way to where they are.

summary: 1-yes 2-no


what i was trying to say

^_^

1 - null, dont count this vote
2 - no, 1st shouldnt be able to be challenged by 3rd
Member
Posts: 5,400
Joined: Dec 26 2003
Gold: 125.92
Feb 8 2016 07:42pm
Quote (Jubeii52 @ Feb 8 2016 08:35pm)
for me, i wouldn't mind a change on the challenge length. 5 day challenge with no extension.
as for the #3 rule, i've battled damn hard to get #1 before, and am trying to now. the #3 has 48 full hours to try to challenge #2 if they lose. this has been the way since the inception and seems fitting.
what happens then if #3 challenges #1 and wins. does #2 auto downgrade to #3? seems unjust for those who have clawed their way to where they are.

summary: 1-yes 2-no



#1 would drop to #3 if he lost to #3.
Member
Posts: 37,627
Joined: May 22 2010
Gold: 66.00
Feb 8 2016 07:51pm
lol rough weekend i had the votes all fucked up


****fixed


#1 we are voting to remove extentions and make challenges 5 days long(or 6 please specify if you would like 6 or i will assume the current 5 days with extention is fine)

#2 we are voting to revise rule #3 so 1st can be challenged from third

#1
Yes - 8
no- 5

#2

yes-3
no -6

This post was edited by RightBaked on Feb 8 2016 07:53pm
Member
Posts: 14,390
Joined: Feb 26 2010
Gold: 132.57
Feb 8 2016 07:52pm
#1 yes - 5days
#2 no
Member
Posts: 37,627
Joined: May 22 2010
Gold: 66.00
Feb 8 2016 07:57pm
Quote (Oganix @ Feb 8 2016 10:52pm)
#1 yes - 5days
#2 no


#1 we are voting to remove extentions and make challenges 5 days long(or 6 please specify if you would like 6 or i will assume the current 5 days with extention is fine)

#2 we are voting to revise rule #3 so 1st can be challenged from third

#1
Yes - 9
no- 5

#2

yes-3
no -7
Go Back To Legit Dueling Topic List
Prev1227822792280228122823123Next
Add Reply New Topic