d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Diablo II > Diablo 2 Discussion > Low Level Dueling > Proposed Lvl 18 Tvt Rules > Iso Feedback
Prev12345611Next
Add Reply New Topic
Member
Posts: 109,637
Joined: Jul 3 2007
Gold: 40.00
Jan 14 2020 09:26am
Quote (lld_mayhem @ Jan 14 2020 09:23am)
The goal is to strengthen the viability of casters while also softening up OP builds.
Removing auras on chargers does a LOT of work in terms of reducing their overall damage. Other options are either expensive fg-wise or hard to police. Im not sure if this rule change is enough in 1v1, but im fine with just no aura chargers in tvt.
Same with 10 life rep, no glitched cthons on a zon, not sure if more needs to be done in 1v1, but this seems ok in tvt as well.

I would like a lower MDR cap, but it seems as though this might pose a problem in terms of replacing gear etc. The idea was that to a ph sin for example 5 DR/0 MDR and 0 DR/5 MDR are the same thing, but to a bone necro/trapper/fissure druid they are not.

lower res caps are also hard to manage (trophy gear may have high fire or light res) as well as hard to police.


As an aside, i am glad that we are all having an open debate on this topic. Its been bouncing around within private conversations for a while now, and i think its about time to shed some light on the issue again



Well re the res, zons get res from rings, so it’s the same idea as forcing rep cap in my eyes

Thinking of our account, it’s easy to drop down to 65% res on all of our 18’s tbh

Lowering res might also be easier than a mdr cap as well. It really depends and I hope someone proves me wrong by x trophy item that gives them max fire res.
Member
Posts: 26,932
Joined: Mar 18 2007
Gold: 4,995.69
Jan 14 2020 10:35am
My opinion regarding rules is summed up as follows:

Rules for pub games should be considered as guidelines rather than requirements. The only rule needed for pubs is dont be a dick. If you have people still willing to abuse certain things and go nuts tryharding in pub games ha, well they have confidence issues perhaps. Want to try a hyb flail on a mauler? Go for it in a pub game! Amp on a nec? Sure why not! If the teams are lopsided because of it stop using amp! Thats how pubs on europe have always been in my experience. Things like bo, amp, etc all either get used or dont depending on how evenly matched the teams are and how fun the rounds are.

Rules for tournaments - do not make a bible in order to try to make every char competitive. That does not need to be the case. Every char does not need to have a chance vs every other char. Nothing wrong with rock paper scissors. If there is something completely broken and easily fixed (cthons) fix it! Sure! Is there 1 or two builds that are far stronger than the rest? Sure, try to fix that! Do I want to make fairly sweeping changes to make 1 fringe char competitive? No. Someone likes playing phsins so wants them buffed, ok. What about the person who likes playing as a rabies druid or plague zon. Do we ban deaths vs them? Lightning zons and cs zons suck - do we ban light res vs them? Extreme examples I know. Top tier, mid tier and shit tier exist and there is nothing wrong with that. Have fun with the mid and shit tier in pubs and leave mid and top tier for tours.

Quote (IAmAsylum @ Jan 14 2020 03:26pm)
Well re the res, zons get res from rings, so it’s the same idea as forcing rep cap in my eyes

Thinking of our account, it’s easy to drop down to 65% res on all of our 18’s tbh

Lowering res might also be easier than a mdr cap as well. It really depends and I hope someone proves me wrong by x trophy item that gives them max fire res.


I dont know about that. Take a bowa - you then cant have more than 20 single res on any jewel, circ, rings or amulet. I'd say pretty much every bowa made on europe would either need to remake to remove anya or else look for sweeping gear changes again.
Member
Posts: 18,730
Joined: Jun 1 2009
Gold: 0.00
Jan 14 2020 11:02am
Quote (LaochraGael @ Jan 14 2020 05:35pm)
My opinion regarding rules is summed up as follows:

Rules for pub games should be considered as guidelines rather than requirements. The only rule needed for pubs is dont be a dick. If you have people still willing to abuse certain things and go nuts tryharding in pub games ha, well they have confidence issues perhaps. Want to try a hyb flail on a mauler? Go for it in a pub game! Amp on a nec? Sure why not! If the teams are lopsided because of it stop using amp! Thats how pubs on europe have always been in my experience. Things like bo, amp, etc all either get used or dont depending on how evenly matched the teams are and how fun the rounds are.

Rules for tournaments - do not make a bible in order to try to make every char competitive. That does not need to be the case. Every char does not need to have a chance vs every other char. Nothing wrong with rock paper scissors. If there is something completely broken and easily fixed (cthons) fix it! Sure! Is there 1 or two builds that are far stronger than the rest? Sure, try to fix that! Do I want to make fairly sweeping changes to make 1 fringe char competitive? No. Someone likes playing phsins so wants them buffed, ok. What about the person who likes playing as a rabies druid or plague zon. Do we ban deaths vs them? Lightning zons and cs zons suck - do we ban light res vs them? Extreme examples I know. Top tier, mid tier and shit tier exist and there is nothing wrong with that. Have fun with the mid and shit tier in pubs and leave mid and top tier for tours.



I dont know about that. Take a bowa - you then cant have more than 20 single res on any jewel, circ, rings or amulet. I'd say pretty much every bowa made on europe would either need to remake to remove anya or else look for sweeping gear changes again.


Just to be clear, i never intended to say "i play a ph sin, so bend the meta around me" 5 PDR/0 MDR is the same as 0 PDR/5 MDR to a ph sin. But the same cannot be said against any other caster. My point was simply "im ok with losing 50% of my damage through reductions, but id rather it be via PDR as this doesnt cripple other casters"

I am also not focusing on 1v1 at all (i think 1v1 and tvt rules should be different). I realize that not all chars are viable for tvt, but there are several builds that have a lot of potential in the right environment. Perhaps this means tvt/1v1 gear swaps. Im ok droping down to 65 fire res on my zon for example in tvt to encourage fb & fire wall sorcs/trappers/fissure dudus/etc for a diverse meta. Then for a tournament, id swap to my 1v1 gear.




Member
Posts: 92,990
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Jan 14 2020 11:12am
best tvt char for against bowa/pala team is a summon druid. 5 wolves, how to boost your pala/ama, tanky af, can use stun sometimes. and just cast wolves all day with a shit load of mana.

all for like a 50 fg char :P

as to franks ridiculous claim, i reject it and choose to try and make shit tier jump mid tier straight to top tier, forever. :rofl:
Member
Posts: 4,099
Joined: Sep 26 2019
Gold: 1,006.12
Jan 14 2020 11:22am
Every char needs to have a chance against each other, a bible is needed.
Member
Posts: 26,932
Joined: Mar 18 2007
Gold: 4,995.69
Jan 14 2020 11:24am
Its just a shame you missed out on some of the active times during europe lvl18 team games.

Characters like fireball sorcs, fissure, throw barbs, necs, ph/bf sins etc were all very common in team games. Even rangers, libbys, smiters, etc all had plenty of exposure.

Take a fissure druid as it stands. Is it a bit lacklustre? In a 1v1 and 2v2 yes. In a 3v3 and 4v4 that small chip damage suddenly applying to 3 or 4 players becomes huge! Not to mention oak applying to 4 players instead of 1 or 2. A fire sorc, again in 1v1 and 2v2 its not great. In 3v3 you have a char with huge life, always max block, telekenesis, frost nova, decent chip damage in fb and great mobility. An excellent utility char if used correctly. Firewall sucks. Me and Sa_Se tried it with trophy gear and it is just unviable completely. The right environment isnt just decided by the rules but also by the games.

Also, like I said, "rules" should be guidelines for pubs. 3v3 and 4v4 is not and will never be competitive in a tournament sense. No point writing in about hybrids, lvl24 chars etc - just use them and have fun. No one will really care. TvT "rules" should be about 2v2 and 2v2 only imo.

And as for the ph sin thingy, I didnt mean it to sound like I was calling you out as a ph sin player. I just meant that of all the characters, that one is the one that will see a very noticable change in performance by the rule changes suggested. I dont believe it cripples other casters though - like I mentioned for ele damage, it will do 1pvp damage difference to the vast majority of ele chars. For magic chars you have necs (will lose damage yes but will not impact the outcome of a duel, just make it take a little longer) and libbys (hammer is chip damage to use defensively while waiting for the real damage, an offensive charge). Im not going to lie, I hate pure phsins as a character, and if 0dr 0mdr was against them then they could become boarderline op and disgusting to play vs or as. But the real reason for my challenge is that I dont believe the change is big enough to merit throwing away any gear people have with mdr on it.

by the way, sometimes when having a discussion it can seem like more of an argument than a discussion, or that one's attitude or temper is high. Just wanted to be clear that this is not the case for me and I'm happy to have these reasoned discussions :)


Quote (thesnipa @ Jan 14 2020 05:12pm)
best tvt char for against bowa/pala team is a summon druid. 5 wolves, how to boost your pala/ama, tanky af, can use stun sometimes. and just cast wolves all day with a shit load of mana.

all for like a 50 fg char :P

as to franks ridiculous claim, i reject it and choose to try and make shit tier jump mid tier straight to top tier, forever. :rofl:


Haha I like the thought process! Still, summon druid will do no damage so the pala name locks the zon and moves in asap. Will get to her sooner or later regardless of summons. Zon stays back a bit but can multi to make space for the charger to get in close and/or just name lock the zon from a distance. Still, I have 50fg so I might just make him in case I am wrong and I want to be op :lol:

This post was edited by LaochraGael on Jan 14 2020 11:27am
Member
Posts: 18,730
Joined: Jun 1 2009
Gold: 0.00
Jan 14 2020 11:26am
Quote (Avenged321 @ Jan 14 2020 06:22pm)
Every char needs to have a chance against each other, a bible is needed.


I realize that this reply is slightly sarcastic, but i do think it would be refreshing having tvt duels where fire chars can actually apply pressure. If anything, it wpuld help breathe life back into a 20 year old game

This post was edited by lld_mayhem on Jan 14 2020 11:27am
Member
Posts: 134,823
Joined: Apr 4 2009
Gold: 1,932.00
Jan 14 2020 11:28am
But i still cant wsg
Member
Posts: 109,637
Joined: Jul 3 2007
Gold: 40.00
Jan 14 2020 11:32am
Quote (thesnipa @ Jan 14 2020 11:12am)
best tvt char for against bowa/pala team is a summon druid. 5 wolves, how to boost your pala/ama, tanky af, can use stun sometimes. and just cast wolves all day with a shit load of mana.

all for like a 50 fg char :P

as to franks ridiculous claim, i reject it and choose to try and make shit tier jump mid tier straight to top tier, forever. :rofl:



+ dire wolf + HoW skills on one of our fissure pelts. It’s awesome for Tvt

3 wolves, ability to choose oak or HoW, massive life rep, plus fissure damage

Thing is awesome for like a 100 fg + spare parts char lol
Member
Posts: 92,990
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Jan 14 2020 11:34am
Quote (IAmAsylum @ Jan 14 2020 11:32am)
+ dire wolf + HoW skills on one of our fissure pelts. It’s awesome for Tvt

3 wolves, ability to choose oak or HoW, massive life rep, plus fissure damage

Thing is awesome for like a 100 fg + spare parts char lol


For a few ladders running my build for ladder 18 was:

3 os spirit wolf pelt
angelics ammy
angelics ring
manald heal ring
angelic armor
angelic wep x 2
b fists
hsaurus belt
hsaurus boots
pelta shield x2

15 lifers, some 7 frw / mana gcs

like 50 fg total and u could tvt all season long lol
Go Back To Low Level Dueling Topic List
Prev12345611Next
Add Reply New Topic