d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Covid 19 Vaccine
Prev18958968978988991273Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 12,978
Joined: Apr 28 2008
Gold: 6.66
Jan 1 2022 02:58am
Quote (xPailess @ 1 Jan 2022 00:47)


That is saying the CDC does not collect records of those particular cases.

Are you trying to make a case that people sick with Covid do not spread Covid? We know people who have gotten Covid, recovered & have never been vaccinated have gotten Covid more than once.

If non vaccinated individuals being capable of being reinfected is not in contention what is the point of documenting if those who have been reinfected spread the disease?

edit
also you can't just post an article & some text as if the text is an accurate representation of the contents of the article. For one that is just a random judges conclusion on the threshold of PCR testing accuracy being sufficient for grounds of reasonable doubt to uphold a quarantine. The judge's ruling isn't a peer reviewed study, the article makes it clear that scientific bodies find his reasoning unscientific.

Nothing close to supporting your claim. Even if the judge were 100% correct it would simply mean the PCR testing procedures are not sufficient on their own to determine if an individual is actively contagious & can justifiably be quarantined.

This post was edited by LouisLeGros on Jan 1 2022 03:15am
Member
Posts: 33,647
Joined: Jul 1 2016
Gold: 110.00
Jan 1 2022 03:13am
Quote (LouisLeGros @ Jan 1 2022 03:58am)
That is saying the CDC does not collect records of those particular cases.

Are you trying to make a case that people sick with Covid do not spread Covid? We know people who have gotten Covid, recovered & have never been vaccinated have gotten Covid more than once.

If non vaccinated individuals being capable of being reinfected is not in contention what is the point of documenting if those who have been reinfected spread the disease?


These are questions that should be asked though and the fact that there is no record is staggering.
Instead of deflecting why not get answers on the matter ?

Kinda common sense to record the statistics of if a person after recovery can still pass a "infectious disease" from person to person, At least i think that would be something that should be documented or no ?
Do we not need information on people recovering and possibly making this work ?

I guess that 99.97% survival rate makes it so it doesnt really matter heh ?
Member
Posts: 12,978
Joined: Apr 28 2008
Gold: 6.66
Jan 1 2022 03:26am
Quote (xPailess @ 1 Jan 2022 01:13)
These are questions that should be asked though and the fact that there is no record is staggering.
Instead of deflecting why not get answers on the matter ?

Kinda common sense to record the statistics of if a person after recovery can still pass a "infectious disease" from person to person, At least i think that would be something that should be documented or no ?
Do we not need information on people recovering and possibly making this work ?

I guess that 99.97% survival rate makes it so it doesnt really matter heh ?


They would have information on reinfection, severity of reinfection, chance of reinfection. I don't see a gotcha on not recording non vaccinated reinfected individuals spreading it after reinfection. What useful information do you get from that statistic?

You seem to be looking for any reason to dismiss public health measures against covid. If there was data on the R0 of reinfected patients that were vs weren't vaccinated what kind of data would be necessary to change your position?
Member
Posts: 33,647
Joined: Jul 1 2016
Gold: 110.00
Jan 1 2022 03:29am
Quote (LouisLeGros @ Jan 1 2022 04:26am)
They would have information on reinfection, severity of reinfection, chance of reinfection. I don't see a gotcha on not recording non vaccinated reinfected individuals spreading it after reinfection. What useful information do you get from that statistic?

You seem to be looking for any reason to dismiss public health measures against covid. If there was data on the R0 of reinfected patients that were vs weren't vaccinated what kind of data would be necessary to change your position?


Laughable, You mean taking away your constitutional rights ?
Interment camps like in austrailia
Forced small medical procedures ?
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Jan 1 2022 03:34am
Quote (xPailess @ 1 Jan 2022 09:29)
Laughable, You mean taking away your constitutional rights ?
Interment camps like in austrailia
Forced small medical procedures ?


How about deporting secessionists ?
Member
Posts: 12,978
Joined: Apr 28 2008
Gold: 6.66
Jan 1 2022 03:39am
Quote (xPailess @ 1 Jan 2022 01:29)
Laughable, You mean taking away your constitutional rights ?
Interment camps like in austrailia
Forced small medical procedures ?


Provide some constitutional case law that prevents vaccine requirements. Hint you can't because it's been settled law for a long time. Also you've demonstrated repeatedly that you won't acknowledge any point or respond to any question & simply respond with gish gallop & moving goal posts.

Also good luck finding any modern society that does not recognize the need for the enforcement of a quarantine when deemed necessary.
Member
Posts: 26,743
Joined: Apr 18 2007
Gold: 1,246.69
Jan 1 2022 03:41am
Quote (LouisLeGros @ Jan 1 2022 02:58am)
That is saying the CDC does not collect records of those particular cases.

Are you trying to make a case that people sick with Covid do not spread Covid? We know people who have gotten Covid, recovered & have never been vaccinated have gotten Covid more than once.

If non vaccinated individuals being capable of being reinfected is not in contention what is the point of documenting if those who have been reinfected spread the disease?

edit
also you can't just post an article & some text as if the text is an accurate representation of the contents of the article. For one that is just a random judges conclusion on the threshold of PCR testing accuracy being sufficient for grounds of reasonable doubt to uphold a quarantine. The judge's ruling isn't a peer reviewed study, the article makes it clear that scientific bodies find his reasoning unscientific.

Nothing close to supporting your claim. Even if the judge were 100% correct it would simply mean the PCR testing procedures are not sufficient on their own to determine if an individual is actively contagious & can justifiably be quarantined.



Tons of fully Vaccinated nurses have gotten covid 2-3x with negative tests in between. I know a 1 right now on quarantine despite having booster shot and having covid prior and now they have covid again and can’t go on their trip to hawaii now.
Being vaccinated doesn’t prevent you from getting it or even spreading it, but it can reduce symptoms

This post was edited by KRR on Jan 1 2022 03:42am
Member
Posts: 47,047
Joined: Sep 5 2016
Gold: 100.00
Jan 1 2022 03:41am
Quote (Saucisson6000 @ Jan 1 2022 01:34am)
How about deporting secessionists ?


you mean like the people that where screaming in the streets for four years Burning Looting and Murdering screeching "NOT MY PRESIDENT" you mean those people?
Member
Posts: 47,047
Joined: Sep 5 2016
Gold: 100.00
Jan 1 2022 03:44am
Quote (LouisLeGros @ Jan 1 2022 01:39am)
Provide some constitutional case law that prevents vaccine requirements. Hint you can't because it's been settled law for a long time. Also you've demonstrated repeatedly that you won't acknowledge any point or respond to any question & simply respond with gish gallop & moving goal posts.

Also good luck finding any modern society that does not recognize the need for the enforcement of a quarantine when deemed necessary.


seems all bidens mandates get crushed by supreme court?

make your case their was even a pandemic to start with
Member
Posts: 3,046
Joined: Oct 1 2021
Gold: 1,979.01
Jan 1 2022 03:45am
Quote (NetflixAdaptationWidow @ Jan 1 2022 12:07am)
I'm not some chode getting their information from tiktok, CNN, MSNBC, or bitchute. I work for a hospital system. I've seen our ER being full and seen doctors who haven't had any ER experience getting called in to do emergency shifts.


You haven't seen shit. Stop lying to us and yourself.

My wife is in hospitals every day (actually does, on what you could call the "front lines") and has never reported anything out of the ordinary, in fact she says most of the places are bare. Literally no actual people have seen these supposed overrun hospitals, nor do they know anyone who has.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev18958968978988991273Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll