d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev18558568578588595001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 28,884
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
May 25 2022 10:02am
This is one of the better analysis i've seen on the war as of now. This guy is an ex-CIA officer that focused extensively on Russia. Solid account to follow.

https://twitter.com/KofmanMichael/status/1529475216606478336
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
May 25 2022 10:25am
Quote (Djunior @ 25 May 2022 15:35)
I looked up the numbers. You're a nation of 68 million. You're importing large volumes of Russian gas and you're therefor one of the big Russia enablers lol.

Need more slam?


I have a fan club with a large volume of shit in their heads.

Quote (Norlander @ 25 May 2022 15:37)
57 roubles/month for unlimited gas per person. That's what I call cheap.


This is great, only have to buy and maintain a gas boiler now...
Member
Posts: 39,751
Joined: Nov 16 2005
Gold: 13.37
May 25 2022 10:44am
Quote (Saucisson6000 @ 25 May 2022 19:25)
I have a fan club with a large volume of shit in their heads.



This is great, only have to buy and maintain a gas boiler now...


When you have central heating you pay less for gas. About $100 for everything including 500 mb/s internet and unlimited cell plus stationary phone if you live alone. Ukrainians pay even less.
My second appartments don't have warm water though, so I bought Czech gas boiler, heating is central but shitty, it depends on supplying company, using electric heating if winter is cold.

This post was edited by Norlander on May 25 2022 11:03am
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
May 25 2022 11:17am
Quote (Norlander @ 25 May 2022 16:44)
When you have central heating you pay less for gas. About $100 for everything including 500 mb/s internet and unlimited cell plus stationary phone if you live alone. Ukrainians pay even less.
My second appartments don't have warm water though, so I bought Czech gas boiler, heating is central but shitty, it depends on supplying company, using electric heating if winter is cold.


Hopefully with climate change we will soon be happy to not die at 60°C like in India, Pakistan etc...
Member
Posts: 24,021
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,554.14
May 25 2022 11:33am
Quote (Saucisson6000 @ May 25 2022 12:17pm)
Hopefully with climate change we will soon be happy to not die at 60°C like in India, Pakistan etc...


You mean I was wrong thinking you was a northern african muzzy?
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
May 25 2022 11:57am
Quote (sirthom @ 25 May 2022 17:33)
You mean I was wrong thinking you was a northern african muzzy?


I think you are wrong since the day you clearly said that extermination camps never existed (or were cool working camps and nobody died)
And that american slavery market was under Jews control.
Member
Posts: 24,021
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,554.14
May 25 2022 12:00pm
Quote (Saucisson6000 @ May 25 2022 12:57pm)
I think you are wrong since the day you clearly said that extermination camps never existed (or were cool working camps and nobody died)
And that american slavery market was under Jews control.


So a pakistanis muzzy the whole time.
Should have known.

But don't shake your hand either way, right. ;)
Member
Posts: 54,183
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
May 25 2022 12:34pm
Quote (Goomshill @ 25 May 2022 15:02)
https://www.jpost.com/international/article-707646

Russia's deputy foreign minister gave a statement that Russia would be willing to set up a corridor for commercial shipping to leave Odessa with Ukrainian grain, in exchange for lifting of western sanctions


Russia doing what Russia does best, finding the fulcrum


Slight contradiction to your previous arguments, isn't it?

First, you and like-minded posters here in this thread argued that the sanctions don't hurt Russia meaningfully, that they're just shrugging them off while their economy keeps humming, the rouble being stronger than before the war, etc.
Now, you depict Russia's poisoned bait of lifting the sea blockade in exchange for a lift on Western sanctions as another brilliant maneuver by the Russians.

If the sanctions on Russian exports and banks weren't hurting Russia, the concession they would demand in exchange for the lifted sea blockade would be something else, say a stop to Western arms shipment into Ukraine or a lift of the ban on microchip exports from the West to Russia. ;)



Quote (Goomshill @ 25 May 2022 15:10)
Trump spent his entire presidency trying to pressure the EU into weaning themselves off Russia and diversifying their energy imports, specifically citing geopolitical security. Now they're only trying to do it in a rush at the last minute, faced with unworkable limitations that give Russia the leverage it needs. Everyone knew what Nord Stream II represented and that Russia was building influence by exports. And yet the same people who are trying to be gung-ho on Russia now spent the last 6 years laughing it off when the strategy was called out. Trump correctly identified that global conflicts had to be fought with long term economic solutions, not acute military solutions, which he codified a few months after taking office as the Trump Doctrine. Now here are a bunch of morons trying those pitiful half-assed military interventions when Russia has them by the balls with economics.

1. Russia/the Soviet Union had been a reliable supplier of commodities for decades. Even at the height of the Cold War, they never budged on their gas shipments to Western Europe.
2. It is absolutely clear that this war will leave Russia significantly weaker economically and geopolitically in the long run. It is irrational. European leaders had no illusions about Putin, they knew he is a scumbag and a villain. But until he decided to pull the trigger on the invasion of Ukraine, he had always acted in rational fashion. Often times malicious, often times against our interests, but always rational.
3. Is is an inescapable fact that Europe depends on imports to meet its energy and commodity demand. Whoever supplies Europe will gain influence, and unfortunately, almost all oil and gas states in the world are autocratic regimes full of human rights abuses and hostile ideology. Just look at all the shit the US put up with in the ME throughout the years because they depended on oil from the region. Replacing Russia with Qatar or Saudi-Arabia is not a big step up for Europe.
4. Trump wanted to increase the world market share of US LNG and increase the influence of the US on Europe in this fashion. Are you seriously suggesting that Trump realized how much of a dangerous adversary Putin was before everyone else, that his primary motivation was to save the stupid Europeans from themselves, rather than advancing American business interests? His arguments were nothing but a justification for his nationalistic "America First" economic agenda, not some deep geopolitical strategy.

Member
Posts: 54,183
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
May 25 2022 12:48pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ 25 May 2022 18:02)
This is one of the better analysis i've seen on the war as of now. This guy is an ex-CIA officer that focused extensively on Russia. Solid account to follow.

https://twitter.com/KofmanMichael/status/1529475216606478336


Excellent analysis, thanks for posting! :)
I agree with most of his assessment.

Quote
The overall military balance in this war still trends in Ukraine's favor, given manpower availability and access to extensive Western military support. That will show itself more over time. But the local balance in the Donbas during this phase is a different story.

Ha, I've made pretty much the same argument just yesterday. ^^

Another interesting quote:
Quote
There are rumors that UKR is bringing in reinforcements to prevent a larger Russian breakout. Either way, the fight in the Donbas is much less significant for UKR than it is for Russia. If it must, Ukraine can trade territory for attrition, then hope to retake it later.

Right now, I think this is the modal outcome for the war: Russia's concerted offense slowly captures all of Luhansk and makes gains in Donetsk. The decisive battle will play out around Kramatorsk. Either way, after the battle for the Donbass is over, both sides' forces will be depleted and unable to mount further offenses. As Western heavy arms pour into Ukraine over the summer, the initiative will shift to Ukraine. They will try to retake the region around Kherson, no idea if it works. If it does, Ukraine will also try to retake the Donbass. I expect these attempts to fail and Russia to keep the Donbass as well as the land strip between Donetsk and Crimea. Then, we will finally arrive at a stalemate in which both sides have nothing to gain anymore and are willing to sincerely negotiate a peace treaty.
Member
Posts: 28,884
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
May 25 2022 12:48pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ May 25 2022 02:34pm)
Slight contradiction to your previous arguments, isn't it?

First, you and like-minded posters here in this thread argued that the sanctions don't hurt Russia meaningfully, that they're just shrugging them off while their economy keeps humming, the rouble being stronger than before the war, etc.
Now, you depict Russia's poisoned bait of lifting the sea blockade in exchange for a lift on Western sanctions as another brilliant maneuver by the Russians.

If the sanctions on Russian exports and banks weren't hurting Russia, the concession they would demand in exchange for the lifted sea blockade would be something else, say a stop to Western arms shipment into Ukraine or a lift of the ban on microchip exports from the West to Russia. ;)



Of course sanctions damage them, I don't think anyone argued that. It's like arguing against that the sky is blue. I think the counter-argument to the sanctions is and was that it won't actually change their push with the war. There's so much evidence of this if we look globally. North Korea, Iran, Cuba, Venezuela, etc. Decades of sanctions doesn't actually get the despots to change their mind.

Sanctions are slowing and forcing their economy to contract and change but talking heads 3 months ago were forecasting that sanctions would completely shut down the Russian economy with their currency crumbling, begging for food, etc. Reality is no where near that, I think most of the western world is actually shocked and kind of annoyed how well they've handled sanctions thus far.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev18558568578588595001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll