d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Derek Chauvin Trial Live
Prev17891011168Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Mar 30 2021 01:02pm
Quote (djman72 @ Mar 30 2021 01:57pm)
I agree with you. I don't see a scenario where Floyd "should" have died or his death was justified. I haven't dived into it fully, but the evidence of manslaughter is pretty clear.

I generally side with the police in these terrible scenarios - probably 75% of the time plus - but this is not one of them. Floyd might have been a "bad guy" he was high on drugs apparently and wasn't a model citizen.

That doesn't mean you should have your life terminated. Your character doesn't factor into that.


The lethal amount of fentanyl and severe coronary heart disease were clearly major factors in his death.

He was placed on the ground because he asked to be placed on the ground and he had just been lawfully arrested for passing counterfeit bills, of which he was clearly guilty.

I think manslaughter has a chance at being proven, but we shouldn't assume because the defense has a strong case and we don't send people to prison because we're upset that someone else somewhere might be racially profiled.
Member
Posts: 53,552
Joined: Mar 6 2008
Gold: 1,908.33
Mar 30 2021 01:19pm
Quote (duffman316 @ Mar 30 2021 02:28pm)
Iirc he said that he couldn't breath while sitting upright in the police car


Correct. He was manic and in distress and said he couldn't breathe several times when he was in the car. He also asked to be put on the ground. Those are the reasons why they took him out of the car and put him on the ground.
The drugs and stress clearly played a major role here which makes the case much messier and different than originally thought.

If anyone hasn't seen it yet, Crowder played the full footage from one of the bodycams at the beginning of his show yesterday.
Member
Posts: 14,012
Joined: Jun 15 2019
Gold: 7.82
Mar 30 2021 01:19pm
Quote (bogie160 @ Mar 30 2021 03:02pm)
The lethal amount of fentanyl and severe coronary heart disease were clearly major factors in his death.

He was placed on the ground because he asked to be placed on the ground and he had just been lawfully arrested for passing counterfeit bills, of which he was clearly guilty.

I think manslaughter has a chance at being proven, but we shouldn't assume because the defense has a strong case and we don't send people to prison because we're upset that someone else somewhere might be racially profiled.


he worked security at a strip club where he likely received cash paymnents, he may not have known it was a counterfeit bill, also, we are talking about $20............it should not have cost him his life.
Member
Posts: 10,060
Joined: Mar 30 2010
Gold: 10,779.02
Mar 30 2021 01:21pm
Quote (bogie160 @ Mar 30 2021 02:02pm)
The lethal amount of fentanyl and severe coronary heart disease were clearly major factors in his death.

He was placed on the ground because he asked to be placed on the ground and he had just been lawfully arrested for passing counterfeit bills, of which he was clearly guilty.

I think manslaughter has a chance at being proven, but we shouldn't assume because the defense has a strong case and we don't send people to prison because we're upset that someone else somewhere might be racially profiled.


Can you confidently say that this man would have died without police intervention that day because of the Fentanyl and his heart issues?

I don't think you can.
Member
Posts: 92,993
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Mar 30 2021 01:24pm
Quote (djman72 @ Mar 30 2021 02:21pm)
Can you confidently say that this man would have died without police intervention that day because of the Fentanyl and his heart issues?

I don't think you can.


hey man he asked to be put on the ground, and he must have asked for a knee on his neck for 9 mins too......

the officer fucked up, put him away for 20 years, out in 10 with good behavior, and send a message.
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Mar 30 2021 01:30pm
Quote (djman72 @ Mar 30 2021 03:21pm)
Can you confidently say that this man would have died without police intervention that day because of the Fentanyl and his heart issues?

I don't think you can.


Police intervention was warranted. We need to know beyond a reasonable doubt that Chauvin took unlawful actions in the arrest of Floyd which subsequently resulted in his death. If there's a reasonable chance that the (lethal) amount of fentanyl in his system and severe coronary heart disease would have resulted in his death, Chauvin should walk.

Quote (Budgeting @ Mar 30 2021 03:19pm)
he worked security at a strip club where he likely received cash paymnents, he may not have known it was a counterfeit bill, also, we are talking about $20............it should not have cost him his life.


It shouldn't have cost him his life if it was $10,000. Why he was arrested is important not because it means he deserved to die, but because it illustrates that the officers had a lawful reason for detaining him. Most people in his situation do not resist arrest, are not high on fentanyl, do not have his severe health risk factors, and do not die. The officer was using a restraining tactic which he was trained to use as a non-lethal technique. Whether you think the department was right or wrong to decide that, he had every reason to suspect that what he was doing did not present a risk to Floyd's life.
Member
Posts: 10,060
Joined: Mar 30 2010
Gold: 10,779.02
Mar 30 2021 01:31pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Mar 30 2021 02:24pm)
hey man he asked to be put on the ground, and he must have asked for a knee on his neck for 9 mins too......

the officer fucked up, put him away for 20 years, out in 10 with good behavior, and send a message.


He probably asked to be let go and carry on about his day.

Killing justified.

/s.
Member
Posts: 92,993
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Mar 30 2021 01:55pm
Quote (bogie160 @ Mar 30 2021 02:30pm)
Police intervention was warranted. We need to know beyond a reasonable doubt that Chauvin took unlawful actions in the arrest of Floyd which subsequently resulted in his death. If there's a reasonable chance that the (lethal) amount of fentanyl in his system and severe coronary heart disease would have resulted in his death, Chauvin should walk.



It shouldn't have cost him his life if it was $10,000. Why he was arrested is important not because it means he deserved to die, but because it illustrates that the officers had a lawful reason for detaining him. Most people in his situation do not resist arrest, are not high on fentanyl, do not have his severe health risk factors, and do not die. The officer was using a restraining tactic which he was trained to use as a non-lethal technique. Whether you think the department was right or wrong to decide that, he had every reason to suspect that what he was doing did not present a risk to Floyd's life.


shooting a dying man is a crime. as should be kneeling on the neck of someone in the midst of a potentially fatal OD.

people arent dogs, u dont put them down if they eat chocolate.
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Mar 30 2021 02:05pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Mar 30 2021 03:55pm)
shooting a dying man is a crime. as should be kneeling on the neck of someone in the midst of a potentially fatal OD.

people arent dogs, u dont put them down if they eat chocolate.


Was he aware that Floyd was OD'ing on fentanyl? The defense has a clear case. I don't know all the facts, so we will need to wait for our justice system to play this out, but most people (including ITT) are assuming that this is a cut and dry murder case. That certainly doesn't seem the case.
Member
Posts: 21,058
Joined: Jun 3 2019
Gold: 930.45
Warn: 10%
Mar 30 2021 02:08pm
Quote (bogie160 @ 30 Mar 2021 16:05)
Was he aware that Floyd was OD'ing on fentanyl? The defense has a clear case. I don't know all the facts, so we will need to wait for our justice system to play this out, but most people (including ITT) are assuming that this is a cut and dry murder case. That certainly doesn't seem the case.


Do you have any legal experience? Your post is quite wrong.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev17891011168Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll