d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev16206216226236244526Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 4,591
Joined: Jan 30 2021
Gold: 751.50
Apr 22 2022 06:05am
Quote (ofthevoid @ Apr 22 2022 01:54pm)
Only reason this guy is not dead is because he was too visible and public. He looks and sounds visibly scared though, will probably keep his mouth shut after this.


dude is already livestreaming again and talking smack ^_^
Member
Posts: 46,796
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 22,159.69
Apr 22 2022 06:09am
Quote (ferdia @ Apr 22 2022 06:39am)
I wholeheartedly agree that Russia has been propping up a Pro Russian Government in Ukraine for decades. I also agree that in an ideal world no other country can tell another country what it can or cannot do. However, we do not live in an ideal world and its very easy to point at another country that tells countries what to do with impunity, and when they dont agree then either they face decades long sanctions (as we see in cuba, iran) or are termed "traitors" with no backbone and are too used to "surrendering" (france).

I am all for Ukraine being EU, in Nato, open, free and all that, i have friends from ukraine for more then 20 years and they are great. The pursuit to self rule and self determine is a fundamental principal that I agree with. The problem however is that by pursuing this freedom they affected Russia's regional security. Where war was the inevitable outcome of recent (years) events I really feel that going slower and less being a dick would have been a better option for Ukraine. We knew years ago that russia would go to war over this. Therefore a gradual shift rather then an immediate shift, as i have previously said in this topic, was the safer option. i.e. wait a few more decades. now i really dont mind if you want to challenge this point "not let them be free immediately" but that thought process is very naive.


But what does open and free and fair mean, in this context?
Ukraine had free and fair elections, at least neither the west nor east found issue with them. But Ukraine was a country divided, and the pro-Russian east out-voted the pro-Western west. We supported a coup d'etat and replaced a Russian state oligarchy pilfering their natural resources with a western state oligarchy pilfering their natural resources. They lost what little self-determination they had by being torn between two masters, and certainly never gained our idealized society. Yanukovych was balancing the interests of a society leaning progressively more towards the EU against the greater stake and willingness to act of Russia, and that got tossed out the window in the name of chaos and bloodshed and a proxy war. The attractions of Europe that so many Ukrainians wanted were really just the luxuries of wealth, not the high minded principles we abandon to prop up coups and arm nazis.
Member
Posts: 51,702
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 15,520.00
Apr 22 2022 06:13am
Quote (Goomshill @ Apr 22 2022 01:09pm)
But what does open and free and fair mean, in this context?
Ukraine had free and fair elections, at least neither the west nor east found issue with them. But Ukraine was a country divided, and the pro-Russian east out-voted the pro-Western west. We supported a coup d'etat and replaced a Russian state oligarchy pilfering their natural resources with a western state oligarchy pilfering their natural resources. They lost what little self-determination they had by being torn between two masters, and certainly never gained our idealized society. Yanukovych was balancing the interests of a society leaning progressively more towards the EU against the greater stake and willingness to act of Russia, and that got tossed out the window in the name of chaos and bloodshed and a proxy war. The attractions of Europe that so many Ukrainians wanted were really just the luxuries of wealth, not the high minded principles we abandon to prop up coups and arm nazis.


I will leave this for someone else to answer, unless you want me to answer, in which case the answer would be (for me anyway): they would be under the umbrella of the west and not have to care about russia's likes and dislikes. maybe rephrase your question.



This post was edited by ferdia on Apr 22 2022 06:40am
Member
Posts: 46,796
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 22,159.69
Apr 22 2022 06:19am
Quote (ferdia @ Apr 22 2022 07:13am)
I will leave this for someone else to answer, unless you want me to answer, in which case the answer would be (for me anyway): they would be under the umbrella of the west and not have to care about russia's likes and dislikes.


We showed them right off the bat our interests in them were about the same as in Argentina or Iran or Iraq or any other vassal puppet state in a proxy war- not folded under the umbrella of EU socialism as wishful Ukrainian bloggers might hope. We were happy to steal their wealth, not share our own. We'll send them guns to amplify the slaughter, but when the dust settles we won't be investing in rebuilding Ukraine any more than Syria or Iraq or Afghanistan. We wouldn't even do nation-building when it fell outside of Russia's hands. More than half a century of US foreign policy has not reflected any better outcomes on being western vassals than eastern vassals. Heck at least the pawns of China are made by debt for their mass infrastructure and construction projects that benefit those societies, America blows countries up.
Member
Posts: 26,556
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 20,065.00
Apr 22 2022 06:23am
Quote (Goomshill @ Apr 22 2022 08:09am)
But what does open and free and fair mean, in this context?
Ukraine had free and fair elections, at least neither the west nor east found issue with them. But Ukraine was a country divided, and the pro-Russian east out-voted the pro-Western west. We supported a coup d'etat and replaced a Russian state oligarchy pilfering their natural resources with a western state oligarchy pilfering their natural resources. They lost what little self-determination they had by being torn between two masters, and certainly never gained our idealized society. Yanukovych was balancing the interests of a society leaning progressively more towards the EU against the greater stake and willingness to act of Russia, and that got tossed out the window in the name of chaos and bloodshed and a proxy war. The attractions of Europe that so many Ukrainians wanted were really just the luxuries of wealth, not the high minded principles we abandon to prop up coups and arm nazis.


The tilt to the EU was going to happen regardless of the coup. You're right that the primary reason for that is economic. They look next door to Poland, Slovakia, Czech, etc. and see better standards of living. Most Ukrainians wanted the fluidity of open borders to go work in Germany or England without costly and contorted visas. We really should have stayed out though and not foment and fund the violent uprising that was led by the far right.

Member
Posts: 16,935
Joined: Feb 24 2018
Gold: 7,398.00
Apr 22 2022 06:25am
https://www.dallasnews.com/news/politics/2022/04/21/ukrainian-refugees-need-sponsors-starting-monday-ending-asylum-claims-at-us-mexico-border/

After allowing a fraction of the amount of refugees Europe accepted the US closed the doors. Well, you can make money by selling weapons into a active war zone not so much by helping the refugees, right?

This post was edited by babun1024 on Apr 22 2022 06:25am
Member
Posts: 38,137
Joined: May 28 2006
Gold: 0.00
Apr 22 2022 06:25am
Quote (thesnipa @ Apr 22 2022 02:57pm)
so i said exactly what i claimed more or less. i said objectively it can lead to more pedos, no where did i say dont condemn pedos i just asked if you'd considered the implications.

imagine doing a post search and an hour of research just to get proven wrong, ty lol made my morning already. kudos on ctrl+f on the right keyphrase tho, clearly your memory is fairly good on wording.


you condemned the shaming of pedos as supposedly a negative thing that can birth more pedos, just like i claimed and just like you denied

post search lasted 3 minutes too aswell, if it would take you an hour i now understand why you threw a tantrum when asked to do the search
Member
Posts: 16,935
Joined: Feb 24 2018
Gold: 7,398.00
Apr 22 2022 06:30am
Quote (HeLiCaL @ Apr 22 2022 02:25pm)
you condemned the shaming of pedos as supposedly a negative thing that can birth more pedos, just like i claimed and just like you denied

post search lasted 3 minutes too aswell, if it would take you an hour i now understand why you threw a tantrum when asked to do the search


That's another story. Somehow, the left does the wrong thing while having "noble" intentions. By punishing pedos hard you force them to go underground. Do you think ignoring their existence solves the problem and they don't commit any crimes anymore? It should be recognized as a mental disorder, treated and made sure they never come in contact with children. Instead, leftists act as if they are victims, can be treated and reintegrated into the society at the cost of children. As you see both of your parties are way off.

Same with rapes, people call for harsher punishment like castration etc. but the you give perpetrators the motive to kill their victims to not leave anyone who could accuse them.
Same with fatphobie, obesity is a sickness and was recognized as such by WHO. Instead of using the definition to get treatment which they wouldn't get prior to recognition lots of obese people assumed if it's a sickness morbid obesity is ok and the others have to accept the way they are :bonk:

This post was edited by babun1024 on Apr 22 2022 06:48am
Member
Posts: 46,796
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 22,159.69
Apr 22 2022 06:32am
Quote (ofthevoid @ Apr 22 2022 07:23am)
The tilt to the EU was going to happen regardless of the coup. You're right that the primary reason for that is economic. They look next door to Poland, Slovakia, Czech, etc. and see better standards of living. Most Ukrainians wanted the fluidity of open borders to go work in Germany or England without costly and contorted visas. We really should have stayed out though and not foment and fund the violent uprising that was led by the far right.


Is there a hypothetical world, just in terms of economics, where Germany and France and Italy could have the production to sustain extending their debt-spending socialism across Ukraine? With the benefit of that creeping influence and without an overthrow, making them an offer as a sovereign nation rather than a coup. Even now in the midst of jingoism so demented we're embracing Nazis, the EU is extremely reluctant to embrace Ukraine. The consequence of the Syrian war was Brexit and the EU's long term sustainability being questioned, and the past few years up until Ukraine were the first rumblings of Polexit / Hungexit which were far off due to their economic reliance. But Ukraine had a population higher than those two countries combined, nearly 2/3 of another Germany to support. Try paying health insurance coverage and pensions for all the dirt poor ukrainians in addition to a bunch of ethiopians and syrians. In governments more willing to embrace climate suicide pacts than austerity. Putin broke up that party by sending a bunch of hungry mouths to their doorstep, folding Ukraine into the EU didn't seem realistic

Look now at the UK sending african migrants to Rwanda and taking in half as many refugees from ukraine as ireland did. Now there's a cold dose of reality on Ukraine's future with Europe

This post was edited by Goomshill on Apr 22 2022 06:34am
Member
Posts: 16,935
Joined: Feb 24 2018
Gold: 7,398.00
Apr 22 2022 06:50am
Quote (Goomshill @ Apr 22 2022 02:32pm)
Look now at the UK sending african migrants to Rwanda and taking in half as many refugees from ukraine as ireland did. Now there's a cold dose of reality on Ukraine's future with Europe

They even had the audacity to propose sanctioning Germany over not stopping gas imports from Russia :lol:
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2022/04/19/germany-wont-stop-buying-russian-gas-should-face-sanctions/

Baltic states would be the first ones to oppose, you and I know why..

This post was edited by babun1024 on Apr 22 2022 06:50am
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev16206216226236244526Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll