d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > The Lockdown Cult
Prev145678165Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 41,232
Joined: Apr 14 2006
Gold: 5,341.71
Dec 18 2020 12:13pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Dec 18 2020 12:01pm)
You said if cases went down properly the situation would not have been as drastic. I point to Europe because for a long time people gave that as an example of what went down properly meant. Even with their lower rates over the summer they still saw a pretty strong spike between October and November where they actually had higher numbers than ours.

The point is not to compare Europe to the US, the point is that some of the measures we thought would work have no evidence that they actually did but here we are trying to implement them longer and longer. Hopefully, the vaccine gives us long term immunity but if not we can't keep applying blunt tools that actually do more damage and are basically being implemented on notions "well it makes sense that if we close more businesses down then people wouldn't catch or spread Covid" Does it really though? Does the small business being closed help but the thousands of people that are funneled into the same walmarts, targets, etc not have an impact?



They had higher numbers in October /November because there spike was earlier than ours. Talk to me in February when you can compare appropriate parts of the curves with each other. This is a classic case of cherry picking data points and comparing apples with oranges. Our start of the spike vs their peaking numbers. Again, objectively , cases per capita in regards to where we are on our respective curves, there is no objective comparison. Our spike slope will be steeper and higher, no questions about it. We will reach hospital saturation and staffing saturation in every state of the Country, they will not


Member
Posts: 53,368
Joined: Sep 2 2004
Gold: 57.00
Dec 18 2020 12:16pm
Quote (Bazi @ 18 Dec 2020 12:58)
-_-
The vaccine is free lol

good

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-12-18/wealthy-patients-scramble-covid-19-vaccine

people offering a lot for the free vaccine -_-
Member
Posts: 28,867
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Dec 18 2020 12:26pm
Quote (Bazi @ Dec 18 2020 01:13pm)
They had higher numbers in October /November because there spike was earlier than ours. Talk to me in February when you can compare appropriate parts of the curves with each other. This is a classic case of cherry picking data points and comparing apples with oranges. Our start of the spike vs their peaking numbers. Again, objectively , cases per capita in regards to where we are on our respective curves, there is no objective comparison. Our spike slope will be steeper and higher, no questions about it. We will reach hospital saturation and staffing saturation in every state of the Country, they will not


Bold call. Maybe it will happen maybe not.

Not sure where you're getting the correct comparisons for the cycles that would make it apples to apples? For example, why do you want to compare their October to our February? I see their first spike in mid-march for them and mid-April for us so the difference in cycles would be like a month, not 4 months.
That's also consistent with what we're seeing now. They peaked in late October-November and about a month later maybe a little over we're starting to peak.

And again that has little to nothing to do with saying lockdown measures do much tbh.
Member
Posts: 41,232
Joined: Apr 14 2006
Gold: 5,341.71
Dec 18 2020 12:31pm
Quote (excellence @ Dec 18 2020 12:16pm)



Capitali$m
Member
Posts: 41,232
Joined: Apr 14 2006
Gold: 5,341.71
Dec 18 2020 12:33pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Dec 18 2020 12:26pm)
Bold call. Maybe it will happen maybe not.

Not sure where you're getting the correct comparisons for the cycles that would make it apples to apples? For example, why do you want to compare their October to our February? I see their first spike in mid-march for them and mid-April for us so the difference in cycles would be like a month, not 4 months.
That's also consistent with what we're seeing now. They peaked in late October-November and about a month later maybe a little over we're starting to peak.

And again that has little to nothing to do with saying lockdown measures do much tbh.


It is not a bold call, it’s just following the numbers. An easy call

Also I didn’t say compare their October with our feb

I said by February U will have the data to compare winter peaks country to country


This post was edited by Bazi on Dec 18 2020 12:46pm
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Dec 18 2020 12:37pm
Quote (Thor123422 @ Dec 18 2020 11:59am)
Go back and point to where I said that.


Still can't find anywhere to substantiate his straw man.
Member
Posts: 33,921
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,528.52
Dec 18 2020 12:50pm
Quote (Bazi @ Dec 18 2020 11:56am)
What u are missing is mask mandates work when the whole population follows suit. Even in cali as liberal as it is , 30% of the population remains anti mask

Their effectiveness in preventing droplet spread is already well documented even prior to covid

Wisconsin /MI have mask “mandates” and half the people where masks. If u enforce mandates people will cry naziism



Florida is doing better though. Sounds like the liberals arent following their own rules.
Member
Posts: 54,081
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Dec 18 2020 01:05pm
Quote (Thor123422 @ 18 Dec 2020 16:10)
So he wants to open schools and take steps to make that safe.

That explains why you guys are looking so desparate. It's hard to argue against a cautious evidence based approach.

You guys look really pathetic blaming Biden instead of blaming the states that took forever to even do mask mandates.


What a ridiculous spin. The gist of the story is not that Biden wants to open schools and do it safely - everyone wants that. The true news is that Biden is only willing to open schools under hard to achieve conditions, and is himself expecting widespread and prolonged school closures if he gets his way.

Also note that criticism of Biden's (proposed) approach does not mean that I blame him for the public health mess he will inherit from Trump.
Member
Posts: 28,867
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Dec 18 2020 01:09pm
Quote (Thor123422 @ Dec 18 2020 01:37pm)
Still can't find anywhere to substantiate his straw man.


That was easy. Why is it so important for you to have some entity to blame for this which 10/10 times is synonymous with essentially the other side politically?

Quote
You guys look really pathetic blaming Biden instead of blaming the states that took forever to even do mask mandates.


Quote (Bazi @ Dec 18 2020 01:33pm)
It is not a bold call, it’s just following the numbers. An easy call

Also I didn’t say compare their October with our feb

I said by February U will have the data to compare winter peaks country to country


I was comparing the October/November Europe peak to our November/Dec peak so far. That's a fairly close comparison following the cycles.
Member
Posts: 12,320
Joined: Jul 22 2007
Gold: 84.67
Warn: 10%
Dec 18 2020 01:24pm
This post is a violation of the site rules and appropriate action was taken.

Quote (bogie160 @ Dec 18 2020 12:38pm)
This is the sort of myopia I'm talking about. Some people simply can't comprehend that there are costs and consequences to all of our actions.


If you disagree with the cdc's guidelines youre a tard who wants people to die. Go shoot up a polling place.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev145678165Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll