d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1449244934494
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 52,324
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,404.67
Oct 7 2024 09:48pm
Quote (El1te @ 8 Oct 2024 04:55)
Oh big time. The Lithuanians probably hate the Russians more than any other peoples, even more than Ukraine. They were conquered by the Soviet Union and had every reason to dislike them. Now we're getting into "revisionist" WWII history which is considered heresy by the regime. The German-aligned Axis people were largely motivated by anti-communism, figures I read were that about 60% of Germans were motivated by anti-communism and only 20% by antisemitism. Jewish people and communists were seen as the same entity, as they believed that communism was a Jewish-led revolution (were they wrong? We see parallels today). There is also the fact that the Poles were actively engaging in the genocide and ethnic cleansing of Germans, Lithuanians and other Germanic non-Poles in the nascent Polish state, which was the casus belli for the German occupation in 1939.


Nah, the Nazis had planned to invade Poland and other places in Eastern Europe for a long time. The alleged Polish massacres of Germanic people were just the pretext for the landgrab and ethnic cleansings which the Nazis were gonna carry out sooner or later anyway. Keep in mind that Hitler and Stalin had already agreed upon splitting up and annexing Poland.

The concept of "Judeo-Bolshevism" was a staple of Nazi propaganda and had barely any basis in reality.
Member
Posts: 29,219
Joined: May 25 2007
Gold: 2,075.69
Oct 7 2024 10:00pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Oct 7 2024 08:48pm)
Nah, the Nazis had planned to invade Poland and other places in Eastern Europe for a long time. The alleged Polish massacres of Germanic people were just the pretext for the landgrab and ethnic cleansings which the Nazis were gonna carry out sooner or later anyway. Keep in mind that Hitler and Stalin had already agreed upon splitting up and annexing Poland.

The concept of "Judeo-Bolshevism" was a staple of Nazi propaganda and had barely any basis in reality.


I mean this is forbidden history, especially in your country so I understand if you don't want to discuss it out of fear of persecution by the state

But just know that people don't just decide to invade people for no reason, it's simply not how the human condition operates. Even the dreaded Mongols didn't do this, they only wiped out people who defied them and refused to pay tribute (tax) and commit soldiers to their host (and murdered their emissaries)

The genocides in Poland were happening well before 1939 and were ongoing since hostilities first ended in 1918 when Germany was in a weak and fragile state

This post was edited by El1te on Oct 7 2024 10:09pm
Member
Posts: 8,535
Joined: Mar 2 2006
Gold: 3,971.00
Oct 7 2024 10:18pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ 8 Oct 2024 04:44)
I kinda understand why many Ukrainians sided with the Nazis back in the day, considering the Holodomor and the all-around abuse they had suffered at the hands of Stalin. Maybe there's a similar reason for the Lithuanians? Their historic capital Vilnius had been annexed by the Russian Empire during WW1, was then briefly freed by the Germans, then seized by the Poles during the chaotic interwar period, then annexed yet again by the Soviets. They had pretty good reasons to hate both the Poles and the Russians...


Nazi collaborators were mostly from Western Ukraine that was a part of Poland until 1945. They didn’t experience Holodomor and Stalin. Their actions were mostly driven out of revenge for Polish ethnic cleansings after ww1 (volhyn massacre) abd their hate for jews (the word pogrom was invented in Ukraine)
Member
Posts: 29,219
Joined: May 25 2007
Gold: 2,075.69
Oct 7 2024 11:04pm
Quote (Malopox @ Oct 7 2024 09:18pm)
Nazi collaborators were mostly from Western Ukraine that was a part of Poland until 1945. They didn’t experience Holodomor and Stalin. Their actions were mostly driven out of revenge for Polish ethnic cleansings after ww1 (volhyn massacre) abd their hate for jews (the word pogrom was invented in Ukraine)


From the Wikipedia page on Volhyn:

Quote
The ruling Germans also actively encouraged both Ukrainians and Poles to kill each other.


These Ukrainian Nazis are still fighting in the service of a defeated German regime that used them as usual idiot disposable frontline soldiers that they aimed to also kill after the dust settled
Member
Posts: 8,535
Joined: Mar 2 2006
Gold: 3,971.00
Oct 7 2024 11:31pm
Quote (El1te @ 8 Oct 2024 07:04)
From the Wikipedia page on Volhyn:



These Ukrainian Nazis are still fighting in the service of a defeated German regime that used them as usual idiot disposable frontline soldiers that they aimed to also kill after the dust settled


More or less yeah. Ukranians were considered untermenschen and were to be disposed off to make space for lebensraum of the aryans. Melnyk (OUN-M) realised that right away, refused to collaborate and paid dearly for that. Bandera realized that in 1943 once he and his cronies murdered tens if not hundreds of thousands that he would not be allowed sovereignty, but it was too late. He was then removed from the chessboard for a more direct German oversight of eg 14th Waffen SS Galicia formed in 1943 with German command.

Hence the belief of modern Ukranian nationalists that Bandwra was “betrayed” by the Germans. He wasn’t betrayed, he betrayed his own kin and was a useful idiot committing massacres.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1449244934494
Add Reply New Topic New Poll