d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1443744384439444044414465Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 12,488
Joined: Oct 2 2007
Gold: 22,095.00
Aug 28 2024 07:00pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Aug 27 2024 09:18pm)
Sometimes, I wonder if history books will conclude that we were already in WW3 and just hadn't realized it yet....


i think theres alot of merit to that.
ww2 started in 39, pearl harbor in 41, takes a while to get the world (or the US) stage in motion. the invasion of Ukraine seemingly hasnt made a big enough impact, yet.

i remember when trump got elected they said the doomsday clock was the closest its ever been to midnight or zero or wtv. i dont necessarily buy that, but id be curious to know where the hands on the clock are now.

This post was edited by C4NTWO on Aug 28 2024 07:04pm
Member
Posts: 29,322
Joined: Dec 29 2016
Gold: 109,989.69
Aug 28 2024 07:41pm
Quote (C4NTWO @ Aug 28 2024 08:00pm)
i think theres alot of merit to that.
ww2 started in 39, pearl harbor in 41, takes a while to get the world (or the US) stage in motion. the invasion of Ukraine seemingly hasnt made a big enough impact, yet.

i remember when trump got elected they said the doomsday clock was the closest its ever been to midnight or zero or wtv. i dont necessarily buy that, but id be curious to know where the hands on the clock are now.


Doomsday clock is political B.S. for crap like climate change.
Member
Posts: 52,225
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,404.67
Aug 28 2024 07:42pm
Quote (bogie160 @ 28 Aug 2024 23:23)
They'll keep pushing. The minimum territorial demands are the 4 oblasts outlined in Russia's constitution, but I'd wager a whole lot that Putin also wants considerable control over rump Ukraine. Russian opposition media is reporting that voluntary enlistment skyrocketed post-Kursk as Russians from wealthier regions experience a rally around the flag effect. I'm not saying Putin won't negotiate, but it would come with preconditions which would collapse the current Ukrainian regime.

Besides, I've never believed that Russian goals were limited to one strip of land. They want to link with Transnistria and Moldova, they want the historic "Russian" cities of Odessa and Kharkiv, and they want a puppet regime in Kiev. It now looks like they could have it, so why stop now?


100% agreed. Which is exactly where I was going: Putin wants far more than just the Donbass, this war has never been about "protecting the innocent residents of Russian-speaking Ukraine from the evil Azovites and their political arm in Kyiv". Likewise, I have stressed time and time again that the calls for a "negotiated peace" are pointless while Russia believes they can get everything if they keep pushing.

Side note: it is of course completely ridiculous from Russia to demand control over the full Cherson and Zaporizhzhia oblasts which they never had under their full control at any point during this war. This is not a serious or logically consistent proposal (these oblasts aren't even overwhelmingly Russian-speaking) and exposes the justifications Russia has given for this war as a mere pretext for a landgrab and/or the attempt to subjugate a satellite which had the audacity to break free.

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Aug 28 2024 07:43pm
Member
Posts: 29,322
Joined: Dec 29 2016
Gold: 109,989.69
Aug 28 2024 07:46pm
Quote (zorzin @ Aug 28 2024 07:08pm)
Sure but atleast these things can theoretically buy the Ukranians time. It's the same thing with the kursk incursion; it's a gambit to get a firing position deeper into Russian territory. (atleast I think so cause nothing else makes sense)

The only way Ukraine "doesn't lose worse" is by holding on to as much land till Trump hopefully gets elected. A lend-lease program between uncle sam and Ukraine could be devastating to Russia.


How so, you've already done that and the United States, as well as Europe has proven themselves to have no industrial capacity to slow down Russia, a country with an alleged GDP of less than Texas.
Should tell you how fake and gay our economy is.
Member
Posts: 52,225
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,404.67
Aug 28 2024 07:59pm
Quote (PapaPsych @ 29 Aug 2024 03:46)
How so, you've already done that and the United States, as well as Europe has proven themselves to have no industrial capacity to slow down Russia, a country with an alleged GDP of less than Texas.
Should tell you how fake and gay our economy is.


The West has slow-walked and half-assed the supplies to Ukraine. The key issue is a lack of political will, rather than a lack of industrial prowess. At the end of the day, no Western country cares enough about Ukraine to go on wartime footing, or to gut their own militaries by sending a big share of their own materiel and stockpiles. They're mostly getting the leftovers and what our diminished peacetime arms industry can muster.
Member
Posts: 29,322
Joined: Dec 29 2016
Gold: 109,989.69
Aug 28 2024 08:08pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Aug 28 2024 08:59pm)
The West has slow-walked and half-assed the supplies to Ukraine. The key issue is a lack of political will, rather than a lack of industrial prowess. At the end of the day, no Western country cares enough about Ukraine to go on wartime footing, or to gut their own militaries by sending a big share of their own materiel and stockpiles. They're mostly getting the leftovers and what our diminished peacetime arms industry can muster.


United States only makes 500 patriot missiles a year, Russia fires over 4000 missiles at Ukraine a year.
This is the same case with all of their weapons systems up and down the line.
Member
Posts: 52,225
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,404.67
Aug 28 2024 08:09pm
Quote (PapaPsych @ 29 Aug 2024 04:08)
United States only makes 500 patriot missiles a year, Russia fires over 4000 missiles at Ukraine a year.
This is the same case with all of their weapons systems up and down the line.


Do you seriously think the United States, with all its people, factories and natural resources, wouldn't be able to produce far more than 500 patriots per year if it really wanted?
Member
Posts: 29,322
Joined: Dec 29 2016
Gold: 109,989.69
Aug 28 2024 09:02pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Aug 28 2024 09:09pm)
Do you seriously think the United States, with all its people, factories and natural resources, wouldn't be able to produce far more than 500 patriots per year if it really wanted?


Yes, its that pathetic, or else they would of increased production already.
Hows increasing artillery production going??
The only thing that happened was it increased astronomically the cost of these weapon systems, why would Government subcontractors not want this.
Stinger missiles go from $20k to $400K
Artillery shells are now pushing 4K a piece.

This post was edited by PapaPsych on Aug 28 2024 09:02pm
Member
Posts: 14,670
Joined: Jun 27 2010
Gold: 100,701.50
Aug 28 2024 09:17pm
Quote (PapaPsych @ Aug 29 2024 05:02am)
Yes, its that pathetic, or else they would of increased production already.
Hows increasing artillery production going??
The only thing that happened was it increased astronomically the cost of these weapon systems, why would Government subcontractors not want this.
Stinger missiles go from $20k to $400K
Artillery shells are now pushing 4K a piece.


Patriot PAC3 cost about $4 million each that's problematic when the Ukrainians (who got them for free) fire them in volleys
Member
Posts: 29,322
Joined: Dec 29 2016
Gold: 109,989.69
Aug 28 2024 09:25pm
Quote (Djunior @ Aug 28 2024 10:17pm)
Patriot PAC3 cost about $4 million each that's problematic when the Ukrainians (who got them for free) fire them in volleys


They were always fired in Volleys, that's how they get the chance of hitting higher.
In desert storm it was standard procedure to send 4 of them for every incoming missile.
This is still standard procedure with the new improved PAC3, because money is no object.
But the amount of missiles they can build a year is limited.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1443744384439444044414465Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll