d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1417641774178417941805001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 23,947
Joined: Jul 15 2008
Gold: 122,361.69
Mar 30 2024 01:01pm
According to uk intelligence Russia is recruiting 30000 a month

If we assume 3000 dead a month and 3000 injured beyond return (200 killed in action/seriously injured per day), that is a surplus of 24000 soldiers a month. So every 8 months, they have 4 new field armies..

These numbers aren´t reasonable if you are looking to freeze the conflict.

https://twitter.com/DefenceHQ/status/1774049069322682668
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Mar 30 2024 02:37pm
Quote (ownyaah @ Mar 30 2024 08:01pm)
According to uk intelligence Russia is recruiting 30000 a month

If we assume 3000 dead a month and 3000 injured beyond return (200 killed in action/seriously injured per day), that is a surplus of 24000 soldiers a month. So every 8 months, they have 4 new field armies..

These numbers aren´t reasonable if you are looking to freeze the conflict.

https://twitter.com/DefenceHQ/status/1774049069322682668


From your own source:

https://twitter.com/DefenceHQ/status/1764244391630184736

Member
Posts: 23,947
Joined: Jul 15 2008
Gold: 122,361.69
Mar 30 2024 02:52pm
Quote (Meanwhile @ Mar 30 2024 09:37pm)


Okay lets assume 355k russians have been killed, and wounded beyond return.

How many ukranians?

That source states, as many other western have including zelensky:

Russia has a 6 to 8 advantage in artillery
Russia has a massive advantage in glide bombs
Russia has more anti-air
Russia has more long range missiles
Russia has an even, or some advantage in short-range drones
Russia has a massive advantage in long range drones (shaheed)
Russia has a massive advantage in mid-range drones (lancets)

Go ahead. If you ask me, the most optimistic take would be 1:1 in any world, but somehow despite all of these advantages russia loses 10 to 1? Is it because of superior genetics?

This post was edited by ownyaah on Mar 30 2024 02:55pm
Member
Posts: 20,044
Joined: Apr 13 2016
Gold: 32,397.50
Mar 30 2024 02:53pm
Quote (ownyaah @ Mar 30 2024 07:01pm)
According to uk intelligence Russia is recruiting 30000 a month

If we assume 3000 dead a month and 3000 injured beyond return (200 killed in action/seriously injured per day), that is a surplus of 24000 soldiers a month. So every 8 months, they have 4 new field armies..

These numbers aren´t reasonable if you are looking to freeze the conflict.

https://twitter.com/DefenceHQ/status/1774049069322682668


An army of recruits won't last long on the front.

Afaik it is true Russia is recruiting enough men, mostly through "crypto-mobilisation"
But sending a new recruit to the front isn't anything except sending cannon fodder; Which ironically is likely perfect for Gerasimov's generals.

Edit - The conflict is already frozen.

This post was edited by Prox1m1ty on Mar 30 2024 02:53pm
Member
Posts: 23,947
Joined: Jul 15 2008
Gold: 122,361.69
Mar 30 2024 02:56pm
Quote (Prox1m1ty @ Mar 30 2024 09:53pm)
An army of recruits won't last long on the front.

Afaik it is true Russia is recruiting enough men, mostly through "crypto-mobilisation"
But sending a new recruit to the front isn't anything except sending cannon fodder; Which ironically is likely perfect for Gerasimov's generals.

Edit - The conflict is already frozen.


Recruits last longer than mobiks.

-I will consider conflict frozen when 100fabs, 8000 artillery shells aren´t fired daily.

This post was edited by ownyaah on Mar 30 2024 02:56pm
Member
Posts: 20,044
Joined: Apr 13 2016
Gold: 32,397.50
Mar 30 2024 03:07pm
Quote (ownyaah @ Mar 30 2024 08:56pm)
Recruits last longer than mobiks.

-I will consider conflict frozen when 100, 8000 artillery shells aren´t fired daily.


Russia has had artillery superiority for 2 years. I think what is more of a change is Russia using glide kits on FAB's and taking more risks with jets.
Aside from incremental gains and taking two largely symbolic destroyed villages Russia is not making large sweeping territorial pushes. And Ukraine is certainly not.

Unless Russia has the stomach to attempt a broader offensive this summer, the front is largely frozen.
Member
Posts: 39,640
Joined: Nov 16 2005
Gold: 13.37
Mar 30 2024 03:08pm
Quote (ownyaah @ 30 Mar 2024 23:52)
Okay lets assume 355k russians have been killed, and wounded beyond return.

How many ukranians?

That source states, as many other western have including zelensky:

Russia has a 6 to 8 advantage in artillery
Russia has a massive advantage in glide bombs
Russia has more anti-air
Russia has more long range missiles
Russia has an even, or some advantage in short-range drones
Russia has a massive advantage in long range drones (shaheed)
Russia has a massive advantage in mid-range drones (lancets)

Go ahead. If you ask me, the most optimistic take would be 1:1 in any world, but somehow despite all of these advantages russia loses 10 to 1? Is it because of superior genetics?


Told ya Ukrainians are the Master Race, close to Aryans and therefore Tadjiks.
Member
Posts: 23,947
Joined: Jul 15 2008
Gold: 122,361.69
Mar 30 2024 03:10pm
Quote (Prox1m1ty @ Mar 30 2024 10:07pm)
Russia has had artillery superiority for 2 years. I think what is more of a change is Russia using glide kits on FAB's and taking more risks with jets.
Aside from incremental gains and taking two largely symbolic destroyed villages Russia is not making large sweeping territorial pushes. And Ukraine is certainly not.

Unless Russia has the stomach to attempt a broader offensive this summer, the front is largely frozen.


The frontline is very slowly moving, a stalemate of sorts, but its not frozen, the conflict is obviously still ongoing.

Could be that this is where the lines are drawn, or like you said another broad offensive. Or a 3rd option, attrition goes on for a year, two, five, and then another push comes.

It is still too early to call the conflict there is still obvious amassing of production&troops
Member
Posts: 23,947
Joined: Jul 15 2008
Gold: 122,361.69
Mar 30 2024 03:11pm
Quote (Norlander @ Mar 30 2024 10:08pm)
Told ya Ukrainians are the Master Race, close to Aryans and therefore Tadjiks.


praise :hail:
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Mar 30 2024 03:16pm
Quote (Prox1m1ty @ Mar 30 2024 04:53pm)
An army of recruits won't last long on the front.

Afaik it is true Russia is recruiting enough men, mostly through "crypto-mobilisation"
But sending a new recruit to the front isn't anything except sending cannon fodder; Which ironically is likely perfect for Gerasimov's generals.

Edit - The conflict is already frozen.


The front-line is static because thousands of men are dying to maintain it. That's not the same thing as a frozen conflict. Russia clearly believes that it can force a victory through attrition. If Ukraine begins to run out of men the front-line will collapse and Ukrainian statehood with it.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1417641774178417941805001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll