d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev13713723733743754528Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 37,941
Joined: Nov 16 2005
Gold: 13.37
Apr 8 2022 08:47am
Quote (Surfpunk @ 8 Apr 2022 17:17)


Thanks for clarifying. They seem to be redeploying T-64 also. I still think these old ones are going for Donetzk/Luhansk militia.
Member
Posts: 91,169
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,504.69
Apr 8 2022 08:48am
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Apr 8 2022 09:39am)
Genocide : I might be able to give some insight on this ( Since I am working in the Region )
State Sponsored organ farming : I believe this is blown out of proportion or might be fake news but I wouldn't be surprise if some people are doing it but I will put it at gangs and local corrupted government officials there is some truth to it.
Ecological disaster ( definitely Yes )


insight would be greatly appreciated.

as to the organ farming i agree its likely not from the top orders, its just known about and ignored by the top.
Member
Posts: 43,380
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 49,930.00
Apr 8 2022 08:50am
Quote (ferdia @ 8 Apr 2022 22:41)
what I mean is - Australia is also in the sphere of influence of China. By this I mean, Australia recovered much sooner then the rest of the western world to the financial crisis because they were closer economically(for want of a better word) to China then the rest of the world. China as I understand it is asserting pressure within its "sphere of influence" which inconveniently for Australia, includes them. My understanding is therefore:

1. add Australia to your list and thus the list looks like this:

Vietnam : Dont really like China
Cambodia : OK relationship with China
Burma : Good relationship with China
Philippines : Used to be good relationship with USA have USA Base but now Durtete cosying up to China
Thailand : Neutral
Singapore : Playing both sides to the West and China but Singapore has a special relationship with China
Indonesia : Hate USA and China
Malaysia : Hate USA and China
Laos : More towards China.
Australia : Strong relations to West, distrustful of China


Oh yes.
As a matter of fact depending on which party was elected to the government in Australia , their policy changes towards China.
The John Howard, Julia Gillard and Kevin Rudd years were very welcoming towards the Chinese.

But now no longer.
The Chinese have to take a blame on this. They did in fact try to influence politicians and the politics in Australia to a certain point.
And it back fired.

The Chinese are taking a more laid back strategy with New Zealand though, thats why business as usual with the Kiwis.
Member
Posts: 43,380
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 49,930.00
Apr 8 2022 09:02am
Quote (thesnipa @ 8 Apr 2022 22:48)
insight would be greatly appreciated.

as to the organ farming i agree its likely not from the top orders, its just known about and ignored by the top.


Genocide ( I know you are talking about the Xinjiang Area the Uyghur )

Let me go in point form

1. Genocide ( No ) Cultural Genocide ? ( Yes, you can put it that way.)
2. Concentration Camps / Re education centers ( Yes )
3. 1 Million or more Uyghur in Camps ( No ) I believe the number is around 100k to 200k at max. ( Most have been released )
4. Chinese government encouraging inter marriage between Han Chinese and Uyghur (Yes) but not forced

First thing first we have to understand why the Chinese government did that. It got worst after 2009.
If you are talking about the Muslim population , the Chinese never had problems with the Muslims. As a matter of fact some of their top generals in the army in History are Muslims.

That being said Xinjiang is full of resources and it is a place and region that the Chinese government will not give up.
I know it is a bad analogy but put it this way so please pardon me if this doesnt sound right.

If Texas or Hawaii wants to separate or there is an independent movement , I am sure the federal government will do something
Texas ( oil )
Hawaii ( Strategic)

Organ Farming, the central government will not allow it , it might have happened before and if it did I am not surprised. But for the past 10 years at least I dont think such cases happened anymore.
Does the central government knows about it ? I am really not sure, they might and even if they try to stop it, it takes some time. There are some really disgusting gangs and officials in China in Tier 3 to 5 cities and township . I can assure you.
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Apr 8 2022 09:04am
In the scenario where Russia actual governement(s) fall an finally join the west, and that countries around China continue to grow without being worried because protected by the west, then China may end up not being supreme at all, especially with its ageing population.
Member
Posts: 43,380
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 49,930.00
Apr 8 2022 09:09am
Quote (Saucisson6000 @ 8 Apr 2022 23:04)
In the scenario where Russia actual governement(s) fall an finally join the west, and that countries around China continue to grow without being worried because protected by the west, then China may end up not being supreme at all, especially with its ageing population.


If the Russia government falls. But we have to take India into the equation as well.
But the population in India and China combine is almost half the world's population.

There are ardent supporters of the West and USA in the Indo Pacific region.
But honestly speaking there ain't many.
You can count with one hand.

And yes, China is now experiencing a population problem.
But China can make policies really quick if they want to , to solve the problem.
They have already studied places like Japan, South Korea, Singapore where these countries are experiencing population problems.

And some of their polices can be a bit drastic if they want to solve the population problem but they can be rather effective.
Member
Posts: 52,473
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,404.67
Apr 8 2022 09:10am
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ 8 Apr 2022 17:02)
Genocide ( I know you are talking about the Xinjiang Area the Uyghur )

Let me go in point form

1. Genocide ( No ) Cultural Genocide ? ( Yes, you can put it that way.)
2. Concentration Camps / Re education centers ( Yes )
3. 1 Million or more Uyghur in Camps ( No ) I believe the number is around 100k to 200k at max. ( Most have been released )
4. Chinese government encouraging inter marriage between Han Chinese and Uyghur (Yes) but not forced

First thing first we have to understand why the Chinese government did that. It got worst after 2009.
If you are talking about the Muslim population , the Chinese never had problems with the Muslims. As a matter of fact some of their top generals in the army in History are Muslims.

That being said Xinjiang is full of resources and it is a place and region that the Chinese government will not give up.
I know it is a bad analogy but put it this way so please pardon me if this doesnt sound right.

If Texas or Hawaii wants to separate or there is an independent movement , I am sure the federal government will do something
Texas ( oil )
Hawaii ( Strategic)

Organ Farming, the central government will not allow it , it might have happened before and if it did I am not surprised. But for the past 10 years at least I dont think such cases happened anymore.
Does the central government knows about it ? I am really not sure, they might and even if they try to stop it, it takes some time. There are some really disgusting gangs and officials in China in Tier 3 to 5 cities and township . I can assure you.


Any insights on the reports/rumors about forced sterilizations of Uyghur girls and women? If these sterilizations are true, how does that not amount to genocide?

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Apr 8 2022 09:11am
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Apr 8 2022 09:14am
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ 8 Apr 2022 15:09)
If the Russia government falls. But we have to take India into the equation as well.
But the population in India and China combine is almost half the world's population.

There are ardent supporters of the West and USA in the Indo Pacific region.
But honestly speaking there ain't many.
You can count with one hand.

And yes, China is now experiencing a population problem.
But China can make policies really quick if they want to , to solve the problem.
They have already studied places like Japan, South Korea, Singapore where these countries are experiencing population problems.

And some of their polices can be a bit drastic if they want to solve the population problem but they can be rather effective.


The Himalaya is like a wall
Member
Posts: 91,169
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,504.69
Apr 8 2022 09:21am
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Apr 8 2022 10:02am)
Genocide ( I know you are talking about the Xinjiang Area the Uyghur )

Let me go in point form

1. Genocide ( No ) Cultural Genocide ? ( Yes, you can put it that way.)
2. Concentration Camps / Re education centers ( Yes )
3. 1 Million or more Uyghur in Camps ( No ) I believe the number is around 100k to 200k at max. ( Most have been released )
4. Chinese government encouraging inter marriage between Han Chinese and Uyghur (Yes) but not forced

First thing first we have to understand why the Chinese government did that. It got worst after 2009.
If you are talking about the Muslim population , the Chinese never had problems with the Muslims. As a matter of fact some of their top generals in the army in History are Muslims.

That being said Xinjiang is full of resources and it is a place and region that the Chinese government will not give up.
I know it is a bad analogy but put it this way so please pardon me if this doesnt sound right.

If Texas or Hawaii wants to separate or there is an independent movement , I am sure the federal government will do something
Texas ( oil )
Hawaii ( Strategic)

Organ Farming, the central government will not allow it , it might have happened before and if it did I am not surprised. But for the past 10 years at least I dont think such cases happened anymore.
Does the central government knows about it ? I am really not sure, they might and even if they try to stop it, it takes some time. There are some really disgusting gangs and officials in China in Tier 3 to 5 cities and township . I can assure you.


i am sure that the muslim imprisonment is very similar to how we treated the indians in the 1800s. smaller and smaller reservations of land, constant moving, and violent reactions to uprisings.

this is one of america's greatest domestic shames, along with slavery. and we as the US shouldnt allow China to do the same. but we will.
Member
Posts: 43,380
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 49,930.00
Apr 8 2022 09:23am
Quote (Black XistenZ @ 8 Apr 2022 23:10)
Any insights on the reports/rumors about forced sterilizations of Uyghur girls and women? If these sterilizations are true, how does that not amount to genocide?


They would rather the Han Chinese marry the girls and produce babies then to sterilize them.

There are a lot of reports out there in the West.
But I have also spoken to a number of Uryhurs in XinJiang and those that came to Shenzhen, Hong Kong and Guangzhou area to work.
They painted a different picture to me.
They are angry at the government for trying to change their culture but the sterilization is a bit far fetch
That being said , if you say there are forced sterilizations I wouldn't be surprised either.
I am not good enough with this subject on sterilization (forced) enough to make a statement on it.

I don't want to give wrong information and I am only basing on the information I get when i was doing trade in Xinjiang and speaking to a number of natives.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev13713723733743754528Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll