Quote (ofthevoid @ Aug 2 2021 08:18pm)
Agree to disagree on how close of a call this actually was. Actions to me speak louder than words. The fact that they were shouting dumb shit is not an indictment of how far they were willing to take things. In the end, they went home peacefully with none of them as far as we know looking to fulfill what they started subsequently. Like that matters a ton, not sure why you're glossing over it. If even a tiny percentage of these people were serious about an insurrection, lets say 1%, they had plenty of chances to attempt some sort of armed ambushes of politicians they disagreed with or whatever subsequently. If they are too soft to do that, it's safe to safe they were too soft to actually commit real violence in January.
Charge the people that committed crimes with what's appropriate and spare us the political theatre that's 100 % being pushed for maximum political damage to the other side. Like the messaging here is so crystal, you either oppose Trump (and republicans) or you support racists, sexists, fascists, Russian spies and now insurrections. It's the ultimate gutter politics.
One person was killed. One, at the hands of a cop that shot her dead, not going to argue on whether it was justified or not because I don't know but that's what happened. I have no problem acknowledging there was violence and that storming the building was criminal and people should face repercussions. I do however have a problem with blown out of proportion political takes and investigations. This is Russiagate all over again. Create a narrative and who fucking cares if it's true or not or if even what's being portrayed is an accurate and unbiased account. I mean look at the spin now. The cop that died of natural causes was now murdered. Lol. Nope, this is not political at all and is an accurate saga of the events that took place!
I mean, in the Goodman scenario, the doors were wide open and if the crowd turned the other way, they'd have unfettered access to the VP and all the Senators. That obviously would have been a disaster and it's a hypothetical that we should never have to think about. As for going home peacefully, what else did you expect them to do? Remember, MOST (95%+) of the rioters simply got caught up in the moment. They felt like they accomplished something, had their 15 minutes of fame, and then went home. The insurrectionists (i.e. zip tie guy), on the other hand, failed in their objective so they had no choice but to leave. They simply didn't have the numbers or the fervor of the crowd on their side. At the end of the day, these people are pathetic, incompetent, and foolish. That doesn't mean we shouldn't use this as a wake up call and patch up the weaknesses in our security.
Here is an example of a woman who I'd consider a protestor and possibly even a rioter (not an insurrectionist):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yr1o8fnjNN8Like...this is just how dumb some of these people are. They are announcing their fucking names, where they are from, and why they are there. This is what happens when you are the anti-intellectual party for decades.
I don't think you can get around the fact that there needs to be an investigation because we obviously don't want it to happen again. The unfortunate reality is that this was a political event and the head of the Republican party (Trump) was one of the primary causes of the violence. Even if God himself did the investigation, the Republicans would HAVE to find fault with the investigation because they stand the most to lose and politics is a zero sum game. I agree that it'd be nice to not have political theater but that's simply impossible.
Russiagate was legitimately bad and became too political. Obviously the notion that Trump was an evil mastermind colluding with Putin is a liberal fantasy but we shouldn't let partisan narratives distract us from the facts. I think too many people conflated Trump, the individual, with the "Trump Campaign." One could argue that the buck should stop with him but that's beyond the scope of the Jan 6 discussion. As for officer Sicknick, can you find me an article after the coroner's report that says that he was murdered?
It seems to me that you're more concerned with spin than actual events and I think you're better than that. There's no need to over-correct and downplay awful things.