d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Amy Coney Barrett Hearings
Prev1333435363746Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Oct 27 2020 09:28am
Quote (Mangix @ Oct 27 2020 11:25am)
For the purposes of increasing dem numbers in the senate.


The Democrats are doing enough already with mass immigration and free money promises they can't deliver on.

I think we need a few more Republican states to balance it out.

Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Oct 27 2020 09:29am
Quote (bogie160 @ Oct 27 2020 11:28am)
The Democrats are doing enough already with mass immigration and free money promises they can't deliver on.

I think we need a few more Republican states to balance it out.


Why do we need more impoverished states for balance? Lol, that is insane.

You want to emulate the success of Mississippi.
Member
Posts: 93,001
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Oct 27 2020 09:29am
Quote (ofthevoid @ Oct 27 2020 10:25am)
To me that breakdown looks fair and you see the senate flipping every few cycles, in the short run +2 votes for D may not be huge given some senate breakdown scenario but think about cases where you literally needed 1-2 votes to flip for something to happen or to fail.

Why upset this fair back and forth by giving one side a guaranteed +2
Fair here is incorporate DC into either Maryland or Virginia and have those Senators represent them


it comes down to results in senate vs what is legally and morally justified.

now may not be the right time to right a historical wrong, but the lack of statehood of DC goes back to an era where the founders saw DC as a haven and temporary home for Bureaucrats not necessarily needing votes, as compared to the very populace area it is today.

in any case im not sure we could get the states to ratify DC into statehood, so its more hypothetical, which leans me even more into morality and further from senate landscape protection.

Quote (Skinned @ Oct 27 2020 10:27am)
Richard Posner.

He was featured a lot in my philosophy of law class.


certainly a good choice, but is also 81

and by contrast was age 42ish when he was appointed to USCA 7th circuit, ABC held the same seat at 45ish.

he has really just had more years to sit the bench, and is more accomplished as a writer.

frankly Posner is likely just too centrist to get a nomination in this polarized meta, shame really. good answer tho

This post was edited by thesnipa on Oct 27 2020 09:33am
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Oct 27 2020 09:30am
Quote (Skinned @ Oct 27 2020 11:29am)
Why do we need more impoverished states for balance? Lol, that is insane.

You want to emulate the success of Mississippi.


Stop being a bigot. Blaming Mississippi for poverty is like blaming blacks for poverty.
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Oct 27 2020 09:32am
Quote (bogie160 @ Oct 27 2020 11:30am)
Stop being a bigot. Blaming Mississippi for poverty is like blaming blacks for poverty.


No it isn't. The brain-drain is the fault of faulty leadership. Educated people can't live there for some reason. .

Never pegged you as a cultural relativist.

This post was edited by Skinned on Oct 27 2020 09:32am
Member
Posts: 33,928
Joined: Sep 10 2007
Gold: 25.00
Oct 27 2020 09:33am
Quote (bogie160 @ Oct 27 2020 11:28am)
The Democrats are doing enough already with mass immigration and free money promises they can't deliver on.

I think we need a few more Republican states to balance it out.


Because even when in full control Democrats still cater to Republicans. Constantly tip toeing, and making concessions to opposition, to their own detriment. When Republicans have control they only cater to themselves. When they don't have control they obstruct as much as they can. That's all the justification I need, to prove who is more responsible in the driver seat.
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Oct 27 2020 09:36am
Quote (Skinned @ Oct 27 2020 11:32am)
No it isn't. The brain-drain is the fault of faulty leadership. Educated people can't live there for some reason.

Never pegged you as a cultural relativist.


I am an economic determinist. Mississippi has been dying a slow death since the end of the Civil War.
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Oct 27 2020 09:38am
Quote (thesnipa @ 27 Oct 2020 16:25)
can a single pard armchair lawyer name a potential nominee with even close to the qualifications RBG had that is starkly different than what ACB has?

and further how should a scotus pick's qualifications be measured with regards to teaching law, specifically constitutional or federal law classes at Ivy league or similar schools? as compared to being say an appellate lawyer in the state or federal system.


why? that's not required to realise that she got here based on her politics (and gender), and not based on merit / her legal brilliance. no need to jump through your hoops, they are just transparent deflection attempts.
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Oct 27 2020 09:40am
Quote (bogie160 @ Oct 27 2020 11:36am)
I am an economic determinist. Mississippi has been dying a slow death since the end of the Civil War.


And probably before.

As a state, stillborn.
Member
Posts: 54,184
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Oct 27 2020 09:57am
Quote (thesnipa @ 27 Oct 2020 17:29)
it comes down to results in senate vs what is legally and morally justified.

now may not be the right time to right a historical wrong, but the lack of statehood of DC goes back to an era where the founders saw DC as a haven and temporary home for Bureaucrats not necessarily needing votes, as compared to the very populace area it is today.

in any case im not sure we could get the states to ratify DC into statehood, so its more hypothetical, which leans me even more into morality and further from senate landscape protection.


Do the other states have to sign off on the admission of a new state to the union? To the best of my knowledge, other states have no say/veto power in the process - their ratification is only necessary when amending the Constitution.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1333435363746Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll