d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1333633373338333933404528Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 43,376
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 49,930.00
Aug 21 2023 04:57am


Better hope the F-16s don't F up in Ukraine. :thumbsup:

" The United States approved the $8 billion sale of Lockheed Martin Corp. F-16 fighter jets to Taiwan in 2019.
Once complete, the deal will take the island's F-16 fleet to more than 200 jets, the most in Asia, according to Reuters. "

This post was edited by Hamsterbaby on Aug 21 2023 04:57am
Member
Posts: 51,717
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 15,520.00
Aug 21 2023 05:01am
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Aug 21 2023 11:57am)
^ferdia

Better hope the F-16s don't F up in Ukraine. :thumbsup:

" The United States approved the $8 billion sale of Lockheed Martin Corp. F-16 fighter jets to Taiwan in 2019.
Once complete, the deal will take the island's F-16 fleet to more than 200 jets, the most in Asia, according to Reuters. "


?

but then they can just send more...
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Aug 21 2023 05:13am
Quote (babun1024 @ 21 Aug 2023 12:53)
Sinkova has already fallen ( a village 6-14km from Kupyansk). Kupyansk' Ukrainian Administration left the city. Those are confirmed by Ukrainians themselves. UAF is detonating bridges and is creating barricades to halt Russian advance. Looks like Bakhmut 3.0


"already" :lol:

https://map.ukrdailyupdate.com/?lat=49.768737&lng=37.707481&z=12&c=1

looool

This post was edited by Meanwhile on Aug 21 2023 05:15am
Member
Posts: 91,169
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,504.69
Aug 21 2023 06:05am
Quote (El1te @ Aug 18 2023 03:50pm)
I think your reasoning is odd - by your reasoning, you wouldn't be concerned if a political party in the West arises as a neo-Nazi party bearing all the same symbols, ideology, and rhetoric, since they have not yet engaged in open mass murder?

I do agree that the whole discussion of nazis is a bit silly though since it simply doesn't matter. The Russian government stated that the operation of Nazis in Ukraine was a reason for their invasion. So it is what it is, discussion doesn't change anything here. Either you think Russia is justified or is not justified in the invasion, presence of Nazis or not will not change peoples opinion


Concerned? yes. pretense for a war? no.
Member
Posts: 26,557
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 20,065.00
Aug 21 2023 06:16am
Quote (ferdia @ Aug 21 2023 06:43am)
Your not understanding. If Ukraine gets enough F16's to attain air superiority then Russia will have a serious problem. ignore what you are reading "wont change the war etc etc", if Ukraine has its skies, Russia is conventionally goosed. the population of Ukraine vs the population of Russia will no longer matter. Lets wait and see how many F16's ukraine gets. If they dont get more then 150 it means they have been betrayed by the West (but still cause problems for Russia). If they get more then 150 it means that the West seriously wants WW3 (as this would be a serious game changer).

fair disclosure: I dont know the tipping point of numbers of f16's. I plucked 150 out of the air. if there is someone else that can tell us how many F16's Ukraine would need to protect its skies, feel free to chip in. Mine was a guess after reading a bit about it.

F16's can engage russian craft from longer ranges. this as i understand it is one of the key requirements. I think the US and its allies are downplaying F16 capabilities.


F-16s are 40 year old planes and the S-300 which came out around the same time was specifically designed to take these type of planes down. Since then Russians developed and deployed even more advanced AA systems S-400,500s, so like Hamsterbaby, most experts agree that those planes will be extremely vulnerable at the front. They are an escalation and may have some impact but ultimately very limited. Nor would they really be able to engage Russian aircraft because Russia isn't really using front line Aircraft all that much (because Ukrainians also have S-300s), what they do is launch Kinzhal's and Kalibr's and other type of long range cruise missiles from Caspian Sea or Black Sea which then travel hundreds of miles to their targets.

I don't know how many they get but in the short term (lets say by year end) it's a relatively small amount <10 and even that is fairly optimistic to expect because pilot training takes awhile. In the next two years it could be a lot more but that hinges on continual western support for years to come, which IMO is not a given.
Member
Posts: 43,376
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 49,930.00
Aug 21 2023 06:29am
Quote (ofthevoid @ 21 Aug 2023 20:16)
F-16s are 40 year old planes and the S-300 which came out around the same time was specifically designed to take these type of planes down. Since then Russians developed and deployed even more advanced AA systems S-400,500s, so like Hamsterbaby, most experts agree that those planes will be extremely vulnerable at the front. They are an escalation and may have some impact but ultimately very limited. Nor would they really be able to engage Russian aircraft because Russia isn't really using front line Aircraft all that much (because Ukrainians also have S-300s), what they do is launch Kinzhal's and Kalibr's and other type of long range cruise missiles from Caspian Sea or Black Sea which then travel hundreds of miles to their targets.

I don't know how many they get but in the short term (lets say by year end) it's a relatively small amount <10 and even that is fairly optimistic to expect because pilot training takes awhile. In the next two years it could be a lot more but that hinges on continual western support for years to come, which IMO is not a given.


They should have sent them for training 2 months into the war last year. I mean why now ? You are not going to train F -16 pilots in 6 months. Minimal is 8 to 9 months.
Our boys in Singapore who does F - 16 Training takes about 12 months and you have to go on sorties, mock battles etc etc . Now is August, by next June, July the pilots are supposedly " trained " . Delivery ?
Air fields ? You mean Ukraine are going to fly their F - 16S from Romania and Poland ? US Elections ?

So many things is going to happen.

If your F - 16S is not going to perform fairly well, it is going to affect sales. I mean if you are going to send the upgraded F-16 Block 70s, obviously it is going to be totally different.
But those that are sent over is not.

Pragmatic A-10s will be so much more effective. Send more drones for hit and run , rinse and repeat. Use minimal amount of $$$$ for the most effective weapons, drag it out till they are tired.
Do what the Rice Farmers did in Vietnam. :lol:

This post was edited by Hamsterbaby on Aug 21 2023 06:33am
Member
Posts: 26,557
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 20,065.00
Aug 21 2023 07:03am
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Aug 21 2023 08:29am)
They should have sent them for training 2 months into the war last year. I mean why now ? You are not going to train F -16 pilots in 6 months. Minimal is 8 to 9 months.
Our boys in Singapore who does F - 16 Training takes about 12 months and you have to go on sorties, mock battles etc etc . Now is August, by next June, July the pilots are supposedly " trained " . Delivery ?
Air fields ? You mean Ukraine are going to fly their F - 16S from Romania and Poland ? US Elections ?

So many things is going to happen.

If your F - 16S is not going to perform fairly well, it is going to affect sales. I mean if you are going to send the upgraded F-16 Block 70s, obviously it is going to be totally different.
But those that are sent over is not.

Pragmatic A-10s will be so much more effective. Send more drones for hit and run , rinse and repeat. Use minimal amount of $$$$ for the most effective weapons, drag it out till they are tired.
Do what the Rice Farmers did in Vietnam. :lol:


Nature of using planes has shifted too. Precisely because AA systems are so effective. Instead of having bombers basically 'drop down', almost everything now is being retrofitted to glide to target. Even old FAB bombs which were just your typical drop bomb has been improvised with glide vehicle. Early on the Russians lost some planes and learned from those tactics.

Quote
The Ukrainian military notes that Russia has a large stockpile of FAB-500s and is systematically upgrading them with glide kits. Although they only have limited accuracy, the size of these munitions poses a serious threat.


https://rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/special-resources/meatgrinder-russian-tactics-second-year-its-invasion-ukraine#:~:text=The%20Ukrainian%20military%20notes%20that,munitions%20poses%20a%20serious%20threat.

I guess if Ukraine get's F-16 that are capable of carrying glide missiles/bombs that can be fired from let's say as far as Dnipro or whatever that could impactful and a gamer changer but we'll see how long the US leash is. They would also have to be launched from Ukraine, which the Russians would be targeting.

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Aug 21 2023 07:03am
Member
Posts: 51,717
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 15,520.00
Aug 21 2023 07:12am
for sure 2023 is a right off.
Member
Posts: 26,557
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 20,065.00
Aug 21 2023 07:51am
I think ultimately this war is weakening Russia as a whole and i'd agree that it lowers their future growth rate but there's a pretty nasty side effect for it's opponents. They are spending more on their war-machine more than ever, they have more brain and industrial power dedicated to that more than before.

We legitimately could end up with a much more advanced military adversary in a few years. Sure losing 100k, 200k, 300k and billions in commodities revenue is a negative but if they modernize their military out of necessity because this war forced them to, our ultimate goal was a huge failure.

Iran2.0, or North Korea 2.0. Weaker economy but absolutely much stronger militaries vs if they were left alone and allowed to focus on social/economic issues.
Member
Posts: 43,376
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 49,930.00
Aug 21 2023 07:55am
Quote (ofthevoid @ 21 Aug 2023 21:51)
I think ultimately this war is weakening Russia as a whole and i'd agree that it lowers their future growth rate but there's a pretty nasty side effect for it's opponents. They are spending more on their war-machine more than ever, they have more brain and industrial power dedicated to that more than before.

We legitimately could end up with a much more advanced military adversary in a few years. Sure losing 100k, 200k, 300k and billions in commodities revenue is a negative but if they modernize their military out of necessity because this war forced them to, our ultimate goal was a huge failure.

Iran2.0, or North Korea 2.0. Weaker economy but absolutely much stronger militaries vs if they were left alone and allowed to focus on social/economic issues.


Similar to China....If You force them, they will think of some crap themselves and make it work.

There you go. Look what they did recently. Sometimes I find it amusing that some people honestly believe that everyone else apart from them are so backwards that they are still living in mud huts and still surviving via hunter gatherer lifestyle.
:rofl:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolf_Amendment

This post was edited by Hamsterbaby on Aug 21 2023 07:55am
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1333633373338333933404528Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll