Quote (thesnipa @ Oct 27 2020 11:15am)
they aren't represented by 1/2 tho. they just dont have the votes. otherwise that logic drops us into places where over half of america isn't represented, and it just a bit of a moot point then.
barriers to representation via votes isnt the same as actual non representation, aka the thing we revolted because of against King George.
but just look at the last few senates and add 2 to democrats, results are world breaking:
115th Congress (2017-2019)
Majority Party: Republican (51 seats)
Minority Party: Democrat (47 seats)
Other Parties: 2 Independents (both caucused with the Democrats)
= gop mandate still
114th Congress (2015-2017)
Majority Party: Republican (54 seats)
Minority Party: Democrat (44 seats)
Other Parties: 2 Independents (both caucused with the Democrats)
= gop mandate still
113th Congress (2013-2015)
Majority Party: Democrat (53 seats)
Minority Party: Republican (45 seats)
Other Parties: 2 Independents (both caucused with the Democrats)
= dnc mandate, no super majority
112th Congress (2011-2013)
Majority Party: Democrat (51 seats)
Minority Party: Republican (47 seats)
Other Parties: 1 Independent; 1 Independent Democrat (both caucused with the Democrats)
= dnc mandate, no super majority
111th Congress (2009-2011)
Majority Party: Democrat (57 seats)
Minority Party: Republican (41 seats)
Other Parties: 1 Independent; 1 Independent Democrat (both caucused with the Democrats)
= dnc mandate, w/ super majority
110th Congress (2007-2009)
Majority Party: Democrat (49 seats)
Minority Party: Republican (49 seats)
Other Parties: 1 Independent; 1 Independent Democrat (both caucused with the Democrats)
= dnc mandate, no super majority
109th Congress (2005-2007)
Majority Party: Republican (55 seats)
Minority Party: Democrat (44 seats)
Other Parties: Independent (1 seat) (caucused with the Democrats)
= gop mandate still
and of course none of this happens in a vaccuum, who knows how many more seats the GOP could muster by fear mongering over a DC swamp takeover of senate and push a few purple states back into the redzone.
To me that breakdown looks fair and you see the senate flipping every few cycles, in the short run +2 votes for D may not be huge given some senate breakdown scenario but think about cases where you literally needed 1-2 votes to flip for something to happen or to fail.
Why upset this fair back and forth by giving one side a guaranteed +2
Fair here is incorporate DC into either Maryland or Virginia and have those Senators represent them