d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1324632473248324932505001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 45,718
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Aug 9 2023 10:50am
Quote (fender @ 10 Aug 2023 00:45)
learn to read. show me someone uses the term "orcs" for all russians, including those that oppose the war russia started, and i will agree with you that it's problematic / racist / de-humanising. you can't though, because people reserve it for those that INVADE, MURDER, RAPE, and TORTURE - and in that context, it's a well deserved slur - no matter how sympathetic YOU are towards murderers and rapists.


Gotcha Karen.
Member
Posts: 52,224
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,902.00
Aug 9 2023 11:00am
Quote (Goomshill @ Aug 9 2023 09:49am)
I'm not going to try any of the foods with pickles in them, either


Not those stupid bread and butter pickles, no. But dill pickles? I'm all about them.



In other news, the Ruble continues to slide, now off 25% from pre-war levels. "I remain a master strategist," Darth Putin.
Member
Posts: 4,621
Joined: Jan 30 2021
Gold: 751.50
Aug 9 2023 11:52am
oh boy, somebody in the mental asylum kept the doors open again
Member
Posts: 56,386
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 579,208.49
Aug 9 2023 11:56am
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Aug 9 2023 05:50pm)
Gotcha Karen.


For anyone that missed that exchange:

1. Ferdia : "when users refer to Putin as pootin, or Russians as orc's, this is the same method of propaganda that the Germans used to dehumanize the Russians. its a common theme, and has been used extensively in modern times to allow for inhuman behavior against people that the narrative has labeled as less then human, we only need to look at how people in the middle east were treated in that war when they were prisoners of war. All this type of propaganda should be seen for what it is and we should all say no to it. defining a race of people as subhuman is simply wrong and a path to horrible events.

2. Fender : "You also don't know what "war" means?" <-- dodged the fact that he is using the expressions

3. Ferdia : "You dodged the whole pootin and orc's thing, and conveniently forgot about 7 years of bombing in eastern ukraine, nevermind decades of civil unrest supported by the west (accepted the west is more attractive). arguing about when the war started is semantics. of course the war started with russias invasion, if that makes you feel like you scored a point fair enough. if that was all, bye!"

4. Fender : "the whole "orcs" pearl clutching is YOUR dodge"

i.e. I commented on the dangers of using dehumanizing language, He responded by trying to deflect my point, I called him out for dodging and he then said that I was dodging. These mental gymnastic's on his part are amazing.


Member
Posts: 45,718
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Aug 9 2023 12:17pm
Quote (ferdia @ 10 Aug 2023 01:56)
For anyone that missed that exchange:

1. Ferdia : "when users refer to Putin as pootin, or Russians as orc's, this is the same method of propaganda that the Germans used to dehumanize the Russians. its a common theme, and has been used extensively in modern times to allow for inhuman behavior against people that the narrative has labeled as less then human, we only need to look at how people in the middle east were treated in that war when they were prisoners of war. All this type of propaganda should be seen for what it is and we should all say no to it. defining a race of people as subhuman is simply wrong and a path to horrible events.

2. Fender : "You also don't know what "war" means?" <-- dodged the fact that he is using the expressions

3. Ferdia : "You dodged the whole pootin and orc's thing, and conveniently forgot about 7 years of bombing in eastern ukraine, nevermind decades of civil unrest supported by the west (accepted the west is more attractive). arguing about when the war started is semantics. of course the war started with russias invasion, if that makes you feel like you scored a point fair enough. if that was all, bye!"

4. Fender : "the whole "orcs" pearl clutching is YOUR dodge"

i.e. I commented on the dangers of using dehumanizing language, He responded by trying to deflect my point, I called him out for dodging and he then said that I was dodging. These mental gymnastic's on his part are amazing.


Because he couldn't cope with reality. Reality is the world is changing , polarity is shifting. It's similar to how some Manchester United Fans couldn't cope after Sir Alex left with City wining multiple championships and Liverpool getting another PL title edging closer to the record that United once held.
Similarly speaking, Liverpool fans couldn't cope in the 90s and 2000s when United were marauding through the Premier League.

Couldn't cope.

This post was edited by Hamsterbaby on Aug 9 2023 12:17pm
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Aug 9 2023 12:22pm
Quote (ferdia @ 9 Aug 2023 19:56)
For anyone that missed that exchange:

1. Ferdia : "when users refer to Putin as pootin, or Russians as orc's, this is the same method of propaganda that the Germans used to dehumanize the Russians. its a common theme, and has been used extensively in modern times to allow for inhuman behavior against people that the narrative has labeled as less then human, we only need to look at how people in the middle east were treated in that war when they were prisoners of war. All this type of propaganda should be seen for what it is and we should all say no to it. defining a race of people as subhuman is simply wrong and a path to horrible events.

2. Fender : "You also don't know what "war" means?" <-- dodged the fact that he is using the expressions

3. Ferdia : "You dodged the whole pootin and orc's thing, and conveniently forgot about 7 years of bombing in eastern ukraine, nevermind decades of civil unrest supported by the west (accepted the west is more attractive). arguing about when the war started is semantics. of course the war started with russias invasion, if that makes you feel like you scored a point fair enough. if that was all, bye!"

4. Fender : "the whole "orcs" pearl clutching is YOUR dodge"

i.e. I commented on the dangers of using dehumanizing language, He responded by trying to deflect my point, I called him out for dodging and he then said that I was dodging. These mental gymnastic's on his part are amazing.


keep lying to your imaginary audience, pootin apologist. you literally replied to a post in which i debunked the narrative that "the west" somehow started this war ( https://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=92094408&f=119&p=649807348 ), when it was russia - as you had to admit yourself. you then clutched your pearls about calling a murderous dictator "pootin", and his murdering invaders "orcs" (something i personally don't even do most of the time, i've used that expression maybe once)...

if you're genuinely not intelligent enough to distinguish between using a slur to discriminate against a whole race / ethnicity / nationality in general, and using a slur to insult murderers and rapists, you should not be posting here. but i have a feeling that you DO know the difference, and that you are just too dishonest to acknowledge it, because it would completely obliterate your attempt to portray invaders, murderers, rapists, and torturers as victims. but hey, keep twisting yourself into a pretzel in order to downplay the suffering pootin is inflicting on the world and ukraine in particular...
Member
Posts: 34,186
Joined: May 25 2007
Gold: 21.00
Warn: 10%
Aug 9 2023 12:29pm
Quote (fender @ Aug 9 2023 11:22am)
keep lying to your imaginary audience, pootin apologist. you literally replied to a post in which i debunked the narrative that "the west" somehow started this war ( https://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=92094408&f=119&p=649807348 ), when it was russia - as you had to admit yourself. you then clutched your pearls about calling a murderous dictator "pootin", and his murdering invaders "orcs" (something i personally don't even do most of the time, i've used that expression maybe once)...

if you're genuinely not intelligent enough to distinguish between using a slur to discriminate against a whole race / ethnicity / nationality in general, and using a slur to insult murderers and rapists, you should not be posting here. but i have a feeling that you DO know the difference, and that you are just too dishonest to acknowledge it, because it would completely obliterate your attempt to portray invaders, murderers, rapists, and torturers as victims. but hey, keep twisting yourself into a pretzel in order to downplay the suffering pootin is inflicting on the world and ukraine in particular...


How exactly is refusing to dehumanize Russian soldiers = portraying them as victims?

Russian soldiers are people, not "orcs" or whatever other dehumanizing term you want to call them. That doesn't mean they are victims.

This post was edited by El1te on Aug 9 2023 12:30pm
Member
Posts: 45,718
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Aug 9 2023 12:38pm
Quote (El1te @ 10 Aug 2023 02:29)
How exactly is refusing to dehumanize Russian soldiers = portraying them as victims?

Russian soldiers are people, not "orcs" or whatever other dehumanizing term you want to call them. That doesn't mean they are victims.


He has no concept that the military or at least most of the military doesn't have the choice but to follow orders.
If a military of a nation refuses orders just because of a moral concept that they hold. That country will be demolished within a week.

Although that being said, time and time again we will have some commanders that makes noble decisions that will prevent horrendous civilian casualties which is something we should be proud, thankful and relief of.
I don't think he served in his national defense before or at all. So it is hard for him to grasp the concept.

The tragedy of wars and conflicts is always being started by irresponsible politicians and hawks on both ends. That is the reality of life and the citizens of those nations end up bearing the brunt of the consequences.

This post was edited by Hamsterbaby on Aug 9 2023 12:47pm
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Aug 9 2023 12:44pm
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Aug 9 2023 12:46pm
Quote (El1te @ 9 Aug 2023 20:29)
How exactly is refusing to dehumanize Russian soldiers = portraying them as victims?

Russian soldiers are people, not "orcs" or whatever other dehumanizing term you want to call them. That doesn't mean they are victims.


oh, you can refuse to call them "orcs", that is perfectly fine, i don't think anyone has a problem with that. i don't usually call them that myself, but that is not at all the point. the point is that people falsely claim the term "orcs" is used in a racist way, to discriminate against all russians, just like the nazis de-humanised all jews - and that is simply not true. as far as i can tell, people here exclusively use it to describe invaders, murderers, rapists, and torturers.

show me someone who uses it against all russians, and i will happily agree with you they are in the wrong. you can't though, just like ferdia and all the other pootin apologists couldn't do that. it's just pearl clutching from people sympathetic to the russian cause, trying to downplay the suffering those invaders, murderers, and rapists cause in ukraine. "boohoohoo, how dare anyone call them names?" ridiculous...
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1324632473248324932505001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll