d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev13233243253263274527Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 3,771
Joined: Sep 29 2021
Gold: 14,158.00
Apr 3 2022 06:35pm
Quote (Saucisson6000 @ Apr 3 2022 06:28pm)
It's an acquired fact, the french journalist of the basic mostly trusted paper was there, and the corpses are still here and will stay here because ukrainians are waiting for international inspectors to see it by themselves...

https://www.francetvinfo.fr/monde/europe/manifestations-en-ukraine/guerre-en-ukraine-des-crimes-de-guerre-ont-ils-ete-commis-a-boutcha_5061055.html

Bucha is at the north west of Kyiv: it's not a contested area, it's not soldiers. It's the place that was massively occupied by russians before, when they were trying to take the main city.


So basically the Ukrainians go in to the former Russian-held area and murder a bunch of people whom they brand as 'collaborators', and then immediately go around and blame it on Russia, turning it into the latest 'serious incident' to drum up support for a NATO intervention.

For God's sake, how do you people fall for this crap? Do you not realize that Ukraine has everything to gain (an intervention) and nothing to lose by pushing this false narrative, since there is NOBODY to hold them accountable for lying?

Oh yeah, I'm sure the very same regime that murdered 14,000 people in Donbass and who have been caught killing hundreds more in areas under THEIR control wouldn't shoot some more people in Bucha and frame it on Russia!
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Apr 3 2022 06:37pm
Quote (chopstickz777 @ 4 Apr 2022 00:35)
So basically the Ukrainians go in to the former Russian-held area and murder a bunch of people whom they brand as 'collaborators', and then immediately go around and blame it on Russia, turning it into the latest 'serious incident' to drum up support for a NATO intervention.

For God's sake, how do you people fall for this crap? Do you not realize that Ukraine has everything to gain (an intervention) and nothing to lose by pushing this false narrative, since there is NOBODY to hold them accountable for lying?

Oh yeah, I'm sure the very same regime that murdered 14,000 people in Donbass and who have been caught killing hundreds more in areas under THEIR control wouldn't shoot some more people in Bucha and frame it on Russia!


You lost your mind.
Member
Posts: 22,573
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,785.13
Warn: 40%
Apr 3 2022 06:42pm
The war in Ukraine is designed to distract the population and serve as a cover story for the breakdown of the monetary system.
Member
Posts: 52,048
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,933.00
Apr 3 2022 06:46pm
Quote (chopstickz777 @ Apr 3 2022 07:02pm)
Santara. Please explain it to me, because I am truly having a hard time understanding how you take up the position that you do.

You're in the US military. Therefore, you should know that a million or so people died because of the invasion of Iraq and many tens of thousands more died due to the invasion of Afghanistan. You should know that the original reasons (chemical weapons and OBL) were proven false, that there were no chemical weapons in Iraq and that OBL turned out not to be in Afghanistan.

You should know about how tens of thousands were killed during during Obama's "no fly zone" in Libya. You should know how thousands more were killed during the US airstrikes on ISIS in Syria, which were often indiscriminate.

But now you're up in arms over Ukraine? How is Russia's operation ANY worse than what the US has done multiple times over the past few decades? Do the lives of all the brown people killed by US airstrikes and sanctions just not matter? I mean for God's sake, we've literally got youtube footage of Madeline Albright justifying the mass murder of half a million Iraqi babies by sanctions. "We believe it was worth it."

Please tell me how you do it. How can you withstand the mountain of hypocrisy you're standing on? I truly do not understand how you do it.


Yes, I do know those things. I also condemn them. I also condemn US complicity in the ongoing tragedy in Yemen, the toppling of Ghadaffi, and shielding Israel at the UN from international condemnation. None of this is inconsistent with criticizing Russia for its wholly indefensible invasion of Ukraine. Maybe if they had tried to gather an international peacekeeping mission to the Donbas, I'd have considered that a credible attempt to defuse the situation.

Quote (Norlander @ Apr 3 2022 06:32pm)
And you are the "batallion" guy reading only titles. I hope you are not covering your extra chromosome with dementia.


At its peak, the Azov was maybe 2500 men. Ivan is pretending like all the tens of thousands of Ukrainian servicemen defending their country are Nazis.
Member
Posts: 46,799
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 22,159.69
Apr 3 2022 08:00pm
Quote (babun1024 @ Apr 3 2022 07:25pm)
Found the source:
https://www.npu.gov.ua/news/stoprussia/speczpriznachenczi-naczpolicziji-rozpochali-zachistku-mista-bucha/

Apparently, they were conducting a special operation to find Russian collaborateurs on April, 2nd, in Bucha.
Translation:

"Today, April 2nd, in liberated town of Bucha in Kiev region special forces of national police of Ukraine performed clearing of territory from diversionists and collaborators with Russian forces. Demolition service specialists perform search of places of crimes of Russian Forces and extract undetonated explosives and ammunition."


It could be Russians slaughtered civilians. It could be Ukrainians slaughtered civilians and blamed Russia. It could be someone cherry picked a few corpses, or even staged the corpses. I don't know. After the White Helmets of Syria, anything is possible.
Granular details like this are hard to pick out of history books after the fact with the dust settled, and impossible to figure out under the fog of war and blinded by rampant propaganda.
I'm more interested by the things we can actually confirm and the motives behind them, like why Russia was encircling Kiev and then stopped, why they're bombing Mariupol but not flattening Lviv as western weapons flood in, etc.
Member
Posts: 26,556
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 20,065.00
Apr 3 2022 08:49pm
Tangentially related but this is an interesting outcome in Hungary. It's pretty telling how much appetite Hungarians have about war if Orban garnered at least 53% as of now on his anti-war stance. Not sure if it would translate to other EU countries, time should tell though.

Quote
While Orban had earlier campaigned on divisive social and cultural issues, he dramatically shifted the tone of his campaign after Russia invaded Ukraine on February 24, and has portrayed the election since then as a choice between peace and stability or war and chaos.

While the opposition called for Hungary to support its embattled neighbour and act in lockstep with its EU and NATO partners, Orban, a longtime ally of Putin, has insisted that Hungary remain neutral and maintain its close economic ties with Moscow, including continuing to import Russian gas and oil on favourable terms.

At his final campaign rally on Friday, Orban claimed that supplying Ukraine with weapons – something that Hungary, alone among Ukraine’s EU neighbors, has refused to do – would make the country a military target, and that sanctioning Russian energy imports would cripple Hungary’s own economy.

“This isn’t our war, we have to stay out of it,” Orban said.

The president of Ukraine, Volodymyr Zelenskyy, on Saturday depicted the Hungarian leader as out of touch with the rest of Europe, which has united to condemn Putin, support sanctions against Russia and send aid including weapons to Ukraine.

“He is virtually the only one in Europe to openly support Mr Putin,” Zelenskyy said.

While speaking to supporters on Sunday, Orban singled out Zelenskyy as part of the “overwhelming force” that he said his party had struggled against in the election — “the left at home, the international left all around, the Brussels bureaucrats… the international mainstream media, and in the end, even the Ukrainian president.”


https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/4/4/hungarys-orban-hails-great-victory-after-landslide-poll-win

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Apr 3 2022 09:00pm
Member
Posts: 2,363
Joined: Oct 1 2021
Gold: 1,978.00
Apr 3 2022 10:20pm
It is hilarious/sad how the folks who

1) Think Zeleskyy is the 2nd coming of Jesus
2) want America to go to war with Russia
3) still want everyone to mask/vax up forever
4) And therefore are the world's biggest pieces of garbage (leftoids)

Will be some of the first to acknowledge that war propaganda exists, yet will endlessly and immediately guzzle (and I do mean guzzle) any possible propaganda that verifies what they wish to be true and if you ask questions you're yet again a "conspiracy theorist"

This post was edited by Nibthebarb on Apr 3 2022 10:21pm
Member
Posts: 51,708
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 15,520.00
Apr 4 2022 01:55am
Quote (chopstickz777 @ Apr 4 2022 01:02am)
Santara. Please explain it to me, because I am truly having a hard time understanding how you take up the position that you do.

You're in the US military. Therefore, you should know that a million or so people died because of the invasion of Iraq and many tens of thousands more died due to the invasion of Afghanistan. You should know that the original reasons (chemical weapons and OBL) were proven false, that there were no chemical weapons in Iraq and that OBL turned out not to be in Afghanistan.

You should know about how tens of thousands were killed during during Obama's "no fly zone" in Libya. You should know how thousands more were killed during the US airstrikes on ISIS in Syria, which were often indiscriminate.

But now you're up in arms over Ukraine? How is Russia's operation ANY worse than what the US has done multiple times over the past few decades? Do the lives of all the brown people killed by US airstrikes and sanctions just not matter? I mean for God's sake, we've literally got youtube footage of Madeline Albright justifying the mass murder of half a million Iraqi babies by sanctions. "We believe it was worth it."

Please tell me how you do it. How can you withstand the mountain of hypocrisy you're standing on? I truly do not understand how you do it.


afaik servicemen are not allowed to debate this stuff while in active duty. even if one is in the military one cannot be seen to be questioning the war effort, or questioning the narrative.

This post was edited by ferdia on Apr 4 2022 02:13am
Member
Posts: 4,591
Joined: Jan 30 2021
Gold: 751.50
Apr 4 2022 02:10am
Quote (Goomshill @ Apr 4 2022 04:00am)
It could be Russians slaughtered civilians. It could be Ukrainians slaughtered civilians and blamed Russia. It could be someone cherry picked a few corpses, or even staged the corpses. I don't know. After the White Helmets of Syria, anything is possible.
Granular details like this are hard to pick out of history books after the fact with the dust settled, and impossible to figure out under the fog of war and blinded by rampant propaganda.
I'm more interested by the things we can actually confirm and the motives behind them, like why Russia was encircling Kiev and then stopped, why they're bombing Mariupol but not flattening Lviv as western weapons flood in, etc.


there was one video on twitter from the scene in bucha (from a driving vehicle), where it looks like you could see one of the "corpses" moving in the right mirror

i will have to check it again later though

so far it looks pretty damning despite the fact that at least some people here are aware of what the ukranians do to people they call traitors

correct me if i am wrong, but i remember some mayor from that exact region talking to the media about the russian retreat, this massacre must have already taken place at that point (gotta check that as well later)


€: in other news MSNBC is lobbying for the next great war

https://twitter.com/mtracey/status/1510608636036407306?t=nvzgvOs363q1zUFeBhqQug&s=19

This post was edited by JohnnyMcCoy on Apr 4 2022 02:14am
Member
Posts: 51,708
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 15,520.00
Apr 4 2022 02:16am
Seeing all of the active dialogue here I would once again reiterate, there should be no question that war crimes are being committed. the question as i see it is the extent of same, and i would say its either "alot" or "a hell of alot". if the current discussion wants to zoom in on specific instances, have at it, but the wider view should be an acknowledgement that yes this is happening ( as it does in all wars ).

can someone give us something related to current morale Ukraine & Russia armed forces ? and how many senior officers killed on the russian side by this point ?

This post was edited by ferdia on Apr 4 2022 02:23am
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev13233243253263274527Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll