d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1310931103111311231134535Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 14,755
Joined: Jun 27 2010
Gold: 100,701.50
Jul 3 2023 12:48pm
Quote (babun1024 @ Jul 3 2023 08:38pm)
That's old news.I posted the news a week ago. New is that, when Ukraine to close, Russia started a counter-attack and destroyed important Ukrainian positions in north east. Ukraine, meanwhile, is throwing everything again at Orikhov. An Austrian military analyst said that the first phase of the counter offense has failed:
https://www.focus.de/politik/ausland/ukraine-krise/oesterreichischer-militaeroberst-die-erste-phase-der-offensive-ist-gescheitert-nun-aendert-kiew-die-strategie_id_198114383.html
Ukraine haven't reached any breakthrough or a weak spot so far during their probing while losing lots of personell and resources.


Not old news, Date 2nd July

It's an analysis of why the Ukrainian counteroffensive is so slow therefor also included stuff that happened at the start of the counteroffensive
Member
Posts: 37,951
Joined: Nov 16 2005
Gold: 13.37
Jul 3 2023 12:51pm
Today, a drone attacked the building of the SBU in Sumy, - Zelensky.

He stressed that Ukraine does not yet have enough air defense to protect the entire territory.

“The enemy is taking advantage of this - as today, inflicting another terrorist attack on Sumy with an Iranian drone. In particular, on residential buildings and the building of the Security Service of Ukraine. There are wounded and dead. We will do our best to make our air defense stronger.”
Member
Posts: 26,584
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 19,900.00
Jul 3 2023 12:55pm
Quote (babun1024 @ Jul 3 2023 02:38pm)
That's old news.I posted the news a week ago. New is that, when Ukraine to close, Russia started a counter-attack and destroyed important Ukrainian positions in north east. Ukraine, meanwhile, is throwing everything again at Orikhov. An Austrian military analyst said that the first phase of the counter offense has failed:
https://www.focus.de/politik/ausland/ukraine-krise/oesterreichischer-militaeroberst-die-erste-phase-der-offensive-ist-gescheitert-nun-aendert-kiew-die-strategie_id_198114383.html
Ukraine haven't reached any breakthrough or a weak spot so far during their probing while losing lots of personell and resources.


War should end, and honestly, it's the western countries responsibility to push for peace here. People are dying needlessly for little territorial gains. Ukraine even with western military support is not going to push Russia back out of the east.

Why couldn't we have skipped the whole 6 figures in deaths part and hundreds of billions wasted when we are going to end up at probably the same point. Russia will keep Crimea and most of the Donbass. I think some territory in Kherson and Zap can probably be negotiated back through peaceful channels. Young men should be working, building families, growing old and fat, not be dying for ambitions of men that give no shits about them.

Member
Posts: 37,951
Joined: Nov 16 2005
Gold: 13.37
Jul 3 2023 01:05pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ 3 Jul 2023 21:55)
War should end, and honestly, it's the western countries responsibility to push for peace here. People are dying needlessly for little territorial gains. Ukraine even with western military support is not going to push Russia back out of the east.

Why couldn't we have skipped the whole 6 figures in deaths part and hundreds of billions wasted when we are going to end up at probably the same point. Russia will keep Crimea and most of the Donbass. I think some territory in Kherson and Zap can probably be negotiated back through peaceful channels. Young men should be working, building families, growing old and fat, not be dying for ambitions of men that give no shits about them.


This will be the end of Zelensky's political career, instantly.
Member
Posts: 51,746
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 15,520.00
Jul 3 2023 01:14pm
Quote (Djunior @ Jul 3 2023 06:35pm)
- Minimal progress
- Ukrainian counteroffensive absorbed by layered Russian defenses
- Ukraine outgunned by Russia even with all Western help provided
- Russia is not going to run out of missiles despite sanctions
- War of attrition, Russia has prepared for years
- Minefield breaching without air superiority and artillery superiority
- The nuclear power plant

Lots of Western sources mentioned and linked (see you tube channel)

^ferdia

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-a2lOuAfYsc




Check vid ~@15:55

That 47th brigade took a beating on June 8th and lost a bunch of their best armored vehicles that were provided by the West


TLDR: nothing new here from me, except a comment at the end re: the Nuclear Power Plant. You linked me so I will say it again ~

Again, I have to reiterate I don't dwell on incidents in the moment which do not change the status quo. If an incident changes the trajectory, sure I will comment, but I ever take the long view. The current position is that Ukraine is, slowly, doing its long heralded spring offensive, with relative results.

While the US, or western "observers", want a decisive victory, or "gains" by the Ukrainian army, this "want" is departed from reality. There is such a thing as defender advantage. If Ukraine is "advancing" on fortified Russian positions, noting Russia has more artillery, you don't need to be a rocket scientist to figure out who will lose more men. This also applies when Russia advances (it must be noted that Russia may not advance further, noting its intention is not to beat Ukraine, but rather to keep what it has). Ukraine knows that if it overextends itself with an offensive its army might collapse. It is very disingenuous of the West to blame Ukraine for not making gains, when it wont give Ukraine long range weapons, or Nato forces. Understand I am not saying that the US should give long range weapons or Nuclear Missiles, or troops to Ukraine, I am saying that without a game changer the Ukrainians are being ground down.

There is no decisive event on the horizon, instead we see this war of attrition. Based on everyone's capabilities one does not need to be a brain surgeon to come to the conclusion that this war is not going to end any time soon. Ukrainian, US, and Russian, resolve, is FIRM (I refer to leadership here).

What they want:

1. Ukraine wants its territory back from Russia (the same territory it bombed for 7 years), including Crimea.

Relating to Crimea ~

US and international surveys all accept that the people of Crimea see themselves as Russian. So with all that in mind, As Ukraine moves on Crimea, Russia is likely to see that as a brighter red line then Nato in Ukraine, which means Russia will match this escalation with its own (escalated) response.

2. The United States already owns Ukraine's assets. "Aid" is not free. Ukraine has a century of debt to pay for the military weapons it has bought and continues to buy. The US has stated that they want to send Russia back into the Stone Age and to create regime change in Russia. The funny thing is they had Russia-gate in the US (which was proven to be false) but they are happy to topple other governments...This really is double standards at the international stage. (I dont subscribe to double standards as you know).

3. Russia will not countenance US ballistic missiles (or otherwise) in Ukraine and sees Nato in Ukraine as an existential threat, and all attempts at diplomacy by Russia have been rebuffed by the United States. The only realistic way for the war to end soon would be if Donald Trump or Kennedy was elected but such a scenario is departed from reality noting there are too many vested interests that hate these two people. Biden/insert_other, will continue down the road we are on.

ERGO, the war continues...

None of these points should be new to any of us.

What DOES merit conversation in the moment is the repeated dialogue about the nuclear power plant. Something will probably happen there within the next 6 months. i.e. Ukraine will bomb it and cause Chernobyl 2.0.



Relating to the video, while Russia sidestepped Turkey, via missiles in Cuba, Ukraine was ever their red line, which is why they KNOW that they are going to go to war with the US (Directly or Indirectly) but do so anyway, because this is,was and forever will be, "the brightest of red lines".

This post was edited by ferdia on Jul 3 2023 01:19pm
Member
Posts: 51,746
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 15,520.00
Jul 3 2023 01:38pm
I accept alot of people dont like Alex Jones. I hope this is not construed as me providing him a platform. I am posting this in order to give another viewpoint.
I do not condone or endorse Alex Jones, but that does not mean that I won't view some of his content and consider it.

Member
Posts: 4,592
Joined: Jan 30 2021
Gold: 751.50
Jul 3 2023 02:32pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Jul 3 2023 08:55pm)
War should end, and honestly, it's the western countries responsibility to push for peace here. People are dying needlessly for little territorial gains. Ukraine even with western military support is not going to push Russia back out of the east.

Why couldn't we have skipped the whole 6 figures in deaths part and hundreds of billions wasted when we are going to end up at probably the same point. Russia will keep Crimea and most of the Donbass. I think some territory in Kherson and Zap can probably be negotiated back through peaceful channels. Young men should be working, building families, growing old and fat, not be dying for ambitions of men that give no shits about them.


the war is only about bleeding russia at this point, ukraine is the sacrificial lamb and the nazis are willing to fight to the last man

the regular guys are not supposed to find out how ultra nationalists and washington pushed ukraine into the war

in terms of territory its just about how much there will be left for the west, blackrock and friends to "help" rebuild

some of the most fertile land in the world is waiting for the monsanto's and their friends to make a buck

Quote (ferdia @ Jul 3 2023 09:38pm)
I accept alot of people dont like Alex Jones. I hope this is not construed as me providing him a platform. I am posting this in order to give another viewpoint.
I do not condone or endorse Alex Jones, but that does not mean that I won't view some of his content and consider it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8TkbgUfNziM


i mean its obvious for any non npc with a brain that not any "poooootin out" scenario would be a good one

Quote (ferdia @ Jul 3 2023 09:14pm)
TLDR: nothing new here from me, except a comment at the end re: the Nuclear Power Plant. You linked me so I will say it again ~

Again, I have to reiterate I don't dwell on incidents in the moment which do not change the status quo. If an incident changes the trajectory, sure I will comment, but I ever take the long view. The current position is that Ukraine is, slowly, doing its long heralded spring offensive, with relative results.

While the US, or western "observers", want a decisive victory, or "gains" by the Ukrainian army, this "want" is departed from reality. There is such a thing as defender advantage. If Ukraine is "advancing" on fortified Russian positions, noting Russia has more artillery, you don't need to be a rocket scientist to figure out who will lose more men. This also applies when Russia advances (it must be noted that Russia may not advance further, noting its intention is not to beat Ukraine, but rather to keep what it has). Ukraine knows that if it overextends itself with an offensive its army might collapse. It is very disingenuous of the West to blame Ukraine for not making gains, when it wont give Ukraine long range weapons, or Nato forces. Understand I am not saying that the US should give long range weapons or Nuclear Missiles, or troops to Ukraine, I am saying that without a game changer the Ukrainians are being ground down.

There is no decisive event on the horizon, instead we see this war of attrition. Based on everyone's capabilities one does not need to be a brain surgeon to come to the conclusion that this war is not going to end any time soon. Ukrainian, US, and Russian, resolve, is FIRM (I refer to leadership here).

What they want:

1. Ukraine wants its territory back from Russia (the same territory it bombed for 7 years), including Crimea.

Relating to Crimea ~

US and international surveys all accept that the people of Crimea see themselves as Russian. So with all that in mind, As Ukraine moves on Crimea, Russia is likely to see that as a brighter red line then Nato in Ukraine, which means Russia will match this escalation with its own (escalated) response.

2. The United States already owns Ukraine's assets. "Aid" is not free. Ukraine has a century of debt to pay for the military weapons it has bought and continues to buy. The US has stated that they want to send Russia back into the Stone Age and to create regime change in Russia. The funny thing is they had Russia-gate in the US (which was proven to be false) but they are happy to topple other governments...This really is double standards at the international stage. (I dont subscribe to double standards as you know).

3. Russia will not countenance US ballistic missiles (or otherwise) in Ukraine and sees Nato in Ukraine as an existential threat, and all attempts at diplomacy by Russia have been rebuffed by the United States. The only realistic way for the war to end soon would be if Donald Trump or Kennedy was elected but such a scenario is departed from reality noting there are too many vested interests that hate these two people. Biden/insert_other, will continue down the road we are on.

ERGO, the war continues...

None of these points should be new to any of us.

What DOES merit conversation in the moment is the repeated dialogue about the nuclear power plant. Something will probably happen there within the next 6 months. i.e. Ukraine will bomb it and cause Chernobyl 2.0.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lA9_BWwP0p0

Relating to the video, while Russia sidestepped Turkey, via missiles in Cuba, Ukraine was ever their red line, which is why they KNOW that they are going to go to war with the US (Directly or Indirectly) but do so anyway, because this is,was and forever will be, "the brightest of red lines".


ukraine does not have the men for a war of attrition, surely the bandera supporting nazis will have to make a move soon
Member
Posts: 16,961
Joined: Feb 24 2018
Gold: 7,398.00
Jul 3 2023 03:10pm
Russia probably got chips from China because they're mass producing tanks and other military equipment again. They could even afford exporting weapons and vehicles to Africa.
US+allies have to considerably ramp up the amount of tanks and ammunition delivered to Ukraine otherwise they're going to be outgunned.
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jul 3 2023 04:09pm
the mental gymnastics required to make the west responsible for "ending the war", when pootin could just easily foil the devious US plans to wage another forever war by simply withdrawing from ukrainian territory.
how simple it would be for him to stop this senseless war, this unnecessary bloodshed, that "the west" somehow masterminded him into starting by invading a sovereign country.

why does he not realise that? why does he insist on remaining in ukraine? it's ALMOST like the war profiteers in the west can only play their game as long as pootin doesn't withdraw.

kremlin bots are so funny with their moronic "logic"...
Member
Posts: 51,746
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 15,520.00
Jul 3 2023 04:22pm


Ultimately it looks like Nato will have to be more involved and I expect some escalation in some shape or form, next year.

This post was edited by ferdia on Jul 3 2023 04:24pm
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1310931103111311231134535Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll