d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1306330643065306630674529Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 4,145
Joined: Jun 30 2022
Gold: 4.91
Warn: 20%
Jun 24 2023 05:28pm
Quote (ownyaah @ Jun 24 2023 07:47pm)
So what we know so far, and ill be strictly honest, too much bullshit in thread:

1. This was a real attempted coup, anyone saying otherwise is lying.
2. Prigozhin expected support/backing but instead was denounced by all political parties, MOD/military seniors, governors and relevant think tankers/media (slavyangrad/rybar etc)
3. MOD was very hesitant in fighting, trying to deter the situation without casualties to either side, which explains basically zero confrontation.
4. Wagner will be dissolved and absorbed into MOD and Prigoznin will be exiled (and probably assassinated at some point). This is a significant hit to Russian activities in Africa and to an lesser extent in Ukraine because Wagner was main-stormer troops.
5. Progoznin had already made statements in preparation - such as the one where he states that Russian forces are rapidly losing ground in south Ukraine (which he expected to happen during the attempted coup, but didn´t)
6. Overall this will have a small impact on the Ukraine war. Wagner was more functional as a standalone, rather than be absorbed into MOD
7. One of the main reason this didn´t spiral out of control is because the guys at the front did incredibly well

^Norlander ^Hamsterbaby thoughts?


Lol
Member
Posts: 23,864
Joined: Jul 15 2008
Gold: 175,091.69
Warn: 10%
Jun 24 2023 05:57pm
Quote (DizzyBusiness @ Jun 25 2023 01:28am)
Lol


Just stop. Don´t be like propaganda machine like meanwhile

Likelihood coup attempt 95%, staged 5%

This post was edited by ownyaah on Jun 24 2023 05:58pm
Member
Posts: 4,145
Joined: Jun 30 2022
Gold: 4.91
Warn: 20%
Jun 24 2023 06:15pm
Quote (ownyaah @ Jun 24 2023 08:57pm)
Just stop. Don´t be like propaganda machine like meanwhile

Likelihood coup attempt 95%, staged 5%


Propaganda for who? I think the Russians put on a show, it isn't really pro-Russian to say their government lied to the world and their own people is it?

Oh, where'd you get those stats then?

It may be real, it just all seems a bit too orchestrated and smooth to me. Better to wait a few days and see what comes of it all IMO, you said a bunch of planes/helicopters got shot down? Well I will be interested to see if they release a list of who died and whether we see anything from their families, especially since Prigozhin is apparantly getting off with a slap on the wrist and trip to the faraway land of Belarus.

This post was edited by DizzyBusiness on Jun 24 2023 06:21pm
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Jun 24 2023 07:05pm
Quote (ownyaah @ 25 Jun 2023 01:57)
Just stop. Don´t be like propaganda machine like meanwhile

Likelihood coup attempt 95%, staged 5%


To correct you: it appeared it wasn't a coup but a mutiny.
Member
Posts: 4,156
Joined: Mar 20 2021
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jun 24 2023 07:14pm
Quote (Pisior @ Jun 24 2023 03:09am)
Maybe a nice Trap , to force ukrainian to fight.


:rolleyes:
Member
Posts: 4,591
Joined: Jan 30 2021
Gold: 751.50
Jun 24 2023 07:16pm
jesus christ, german media really talks about the world "holding its breath" and compared prigoschin to stauffenberg and his attempt to assassinate hitler

meanwhile

Member
Posts: 4,145
Joined: Jun 30 2022
Gold: 4.91
Warn: 20%
Jun 24 2023 07:25pm
Quote (JohnnyMcCoy @ Jun 24 2023 10:16pm)
jesus christ, german media really talks about the world "holding its breath" and compared prigoschin to stauffenberg and his attempt to assassinate hitler

meanwhile

https://abload.de/img/20230625_002240bbe8c.jpg


:rofl:
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Jun 24 2023 07:51pm
yep
Member
Posts: 48,904
Joined: Jun 18 2006
Gold: 5,011.77
Jun 24 2023 08:04pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Jun 24 2023 05:52pm)
He doesn't, it was all nonsense in my opinion. This whole ordeal played out like a Hollywood production action flick. It had the setup, the climax and the happy ending. There were carefully released videos to build up the suspense, there were various soldiers posing in gun nest positions for the right shots. Barricades, etc, but in the end i'm very skeptical of the whole thing.

People tend to forget that Putin has always played 4D chess and is ex-KGB, who i'm genuinely convinced had ordered the apartment bombings to gain public support for Chechen war. Prighozin has also played up Russian incompetence back in Bakhmut, when he was saying they weren't getting any weapons and would collapse any second, which was just trap for Ukraine to continue to funnel in reinforcements.

It's impossible for us internet sleuths to know what really happened but a theory I heard is this was way a stress test for loyalty to Putin. Basically the spies, the factions that would 'turn' would oust themselves by buying into this. Maybe this is BS, maybe it was all real but reality is Putin has strong support in Russia and they have a very strong intelligence within the SVR/GRU etc. I would say there's probably only a handful of countries probably US/Israel/China/UK that might have better intelligence services.

So with all this in mind, for 25k paid contractors to be able to somehow outsmart these intel agencies just seemed too farfetched imo.


This whole ordeal makes Russia look ridiculous and Putin look weak. It simply invites more people in government to look at Putin and think that maybe he should be replaced. And Putin giving the leader of an armed rebellion a pass is even more weak. Also, this is a guy who was very close to Putin, and a guy who spoke on video and undermined the Russian rationale for invading Ukraine.

Prighozin appears to have planned this out for months but I don't know why people aren't considering that he just has a bit of a screw loose. People who lead cult of personalities become detached from reality... do I really need to cite examples? I'm not that knowledgeable about Russia but the Wagner group is kind of a nationalist cult of personality around Prighozin, they have suffered serious losses fighting a war Putin started, so I think it's possible the guy just became unhinged, and perhaps realized recently he overstepped and took an off-ramp that Putin offered him.

We're all just guessing here... this is an extremely weird situation.
Member
Posts: 34,401
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 283.37
Jun 24 2023 08:18pm
Quote (ownyaah @ Jun 24 2023 06:47pm)
So what we know so far, and ill be strictly honest, too much bullshit in thread:

1. This was a real attempted coup, anyone saying otherwise is lying.
2. Prigozhin expected support/backing but instead was denounced by all political parties, MOD/military seniors, governors and relevant think tankers/media (slavyangrad/rybar etc)
3. MOD was very hesitant in fighting, trying to deter the situation without casualties to either side, which explains basically zero confrontation.
4. Wagner will be dissolved and absorbed into MOD and Prigoznin will be exiled (and probably assassinated at some point). This is a significant hit to Russian activities in Africa and to an lesser extent in Ukraine because Wagner was main-stormer troops.
5. Progoznin had already made statements in preparation - such as the one where he states that Russian forces are rapidly losing ground in south Ukraine (which he expected to happen during the attempted coup, but didn´t)
6. Overall this will have a small impact on the Ukraine war. Wagner was more functional as a standalone, rather than be absorbed into MOD
7. One of the main reason this didn´t spiral out of control is because the guys at the front did incredibly well

^Norlander ^Hamsterbaby thoughts?


I agree, especially with 1 and 2.

If the goal of a fabricated coup was to draw out traitors, you can't very well let the troops involved know or it defeats the point. The risk of something inadvertently escalating makes it suicidal.

Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1306330643065306630674529Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll