d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1270727082709271027115001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 56,389
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 579,208.49
May 16 2023 01:43pm
During the Cuban Missile Crisis Kennedy was told that the US had nuclear weapons in Turkey, aimed at Russia. As part of a resolution to the incident, the US agreed to take those nuclear missiles out of Turkey, which they did. When things settled down, the US put nuclear weapons back into Turkey, but Russia did not put nuclear weapons back into Cuba. This is an example of double standards. Add-On : The US has also walked away from several nuclear treaties in recent years which is naturally destabilizing. This is a hard fact.

Here is another example: The US went mental over Georgia for trying to have the same laws which exist within the US, namely "all foreign organizations, whether GO or NGO, if part state owned 20% or more, must declare. This is double standards - its OK for the US to have such a law at home but its not OK for Georgia to have that law.

Here is another example: China is dealing/trading/building with South American countries more and more. One could use the term "grooming". This is going to be a flash point at some point in the future noting this will indeed fall into the realm of "US Interests". If one is of the view that the US will sleepwalk into a major issue re: South America, I would tend to agree. I would also say that Russia did not sleep walk into the issue with the US and EU grooming Ukraine (accepted they were groomed willingly), instead Russia protested quiet loudly for over a decade, to no avail. The US simply ignored Russia as irrelevant and now they are literally kids in the kitchen playing with the oven.

So in terms of why Ukraine and not Finland, its like saying, Why Mexico and not Canada, or why Turkey and not Cuba. Russia does not give two tosses about Finland, but it was very clear for a long time, that Ukraine was its red line. Now, YOU dont need to agree with the reasons why Russia says Ukraine is its red line and Finland is not, but the US should factor that in before it does things, which, it didnt, and here we are.

This post was edited by ferdia on May 16 2023 01:46pm
Member
Posts: 20,044
Joined: Apr 13 2016
Gold: 32,397.50
May 16 2023 01:45pm
Quote (Djunior @ May 16 2023 08:41pm)
Do YOU remember what you're not allowed to post? I can report you at least a dozen times, go ahead if you want to try that childish crap again. Got your shit bookmarked.

You're trash posting non stop and crying at about all users you don't agree with here in PARD. You're a sad little child SMH


Constant ad hominem and zero content. Thats why nobody takes you seriously.

Quote (Norlander @ May 16 2023 08:40pm)
This is how this war should end


Unfortunately no end in sight. Realistically this war becomes a frozen conflict, generational war and certainly leads to brutal insurgency against the RF; And by consequence increased repression.
Member
Posts: 20,044
Joined: Apr 13 2016
Gold: 32,397.50
May 16 2023 01:46pm
Quote (ferdia @ May 16 2023 08:43pm)
During the Cuban Missile Crisis Kennedy was told that the US had nuclear weapons in Turkey, aimed at Russia. As part of a resolution to the incident, the US agreed to take those nuclear missiles out of Turkey, which they did. When things settled down, the US put nuclear weapons back into Turkey, but Russia did not put nuclear weapons back into Cuba. This is an example of double standards. Add-On : The US has also walked away from several nuclear treaties in recent years which is naturally destabilizing. This is a hard fact.

Here is another example: The US went mental over Georgia for trying to have the same laws which exist within the US, namely "all foreign organizations, whether GO or NGO, if part state owned 20% or more, must declare. This is double standards - its OK for the US to have such a law at home but its not OK for Georgia to have that law. When pushed on Georgia, Russia pushed back.

Here is another example: China is dealing/trading/building with South American countries more and more. One could use the term "grooming". This is going to be a flash point at some point in the future noting this will indeed fall into the realm of "US Interests". If one is of the view that the US will sleepwalk into a major issue re: South America, I would tend to agree. I would also say that Russia did not sleep walk into the issue with the US and EU grooming Ukraine (accepted they were groomed willingly), instead Russia protested quiet loudly for over a decade, to no avail.

So in terms of why Ukraine and not Finland, its like saying, Why Mexico and not Canada, or why Turkey and not Cuba. Russia does not give two tosses about Finland, but it was very clear for a long time, that Ukraine was its red line. Now, YOU dont need to agree with the reasons why Russia says Ukraine is its red line and Finland is not, but the US should factor that in before it does things, which, it didnt, and here we are.


You can't tangibly explain WHY it is Russia's red line. "it just is" is enough for you? I mean talk about setting the bar low.
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
May 16 2023 01:48pm
Quote (Norlander @ 16 May 2023 21:40)
This is how this war should end


I can understand that you want it to stop. Imho the end of the day for Russia is very unexpected (i means the predictions), we have seen so much surprises during this war.


Quote (Djunior @ 16 May 2023 21:41)
Do YOU remember what you're not allowed to post? I can report you at least a dozen times, go ahead if you want to try that childish crap again. Got your shit bookmarked.

You're trash posting non stop and crying at about all users you don't agree with here in PARD. You're a sad little child SMH


Quote (Djunior @ 13 May 2023 21:59)
LMAO you're by far the worst trash poster in this entire topic


Quote (Djunior @ 11 May 2023 14:21)
Norlander responded to your post using the exact same logic.
Your trash post here is completely unrelated. Please report this so the mod can see what a terrible PARD poster you are SMH


Quote (Djunior @ 10 May 2023 21:05)
I asked you what you meant and you don't even have a reply (as per usual)
Pathetic trash poster


If you say so, it must be true. In waiting; you are the one at fault since the very beginning.

This post was edited by Meanwhile on May 16 2023 01:55pm
Member
Posts: 15,949
Joined: Jun 27 2010
Gold: 102,354.50
May 16 2023 02:17pm
Quote (Prox1m1ty @ May 16 2023 09:45pm)
Constant ad hominem and zero content. Thats why nobody takes you seriously.


I'm posting facts and can back my post up with sources. You're just going REEEEEE all day long like a broken record



Quote (Meanwhile @ May 16 2023 09:48pm)

If you say so, it must be true. In waiting; you are the one at fault since the very beginning.


Your post history is like a sewer, lol

Want some examples?

Quote (Meanwhile @ Dec 10 2022 02:32pm)
Sounds like Putin and the fucked dogs supporting his regime are happy of this


Quote (Meanwhile @ Nov 21 2022 05:01pm)
On a side note this is courageous men and not fuckoffs doing conspiracists theories behind their screens


Quote (Meanwhile @ Dec 21 2022 10:17pm)
Putin's fucked crabs will probably prefer to watch Ukraine being blindly massacred.


You're easily PARD's worst contributor. You fully deserve to be called a trash poster

Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
May 16 2023 02:19pm
Quote (Djunior @ 16 May 2023 22:17)
I'm posting facts and can back my post up with sources. You're just going REEEEEE all day long like a broken record
Your post history is like a sewer, lol
Want some examples?
You're easily PARD's worst contributor. You fully deserve to be called a trash poster


Dec 10 2022
Nov 21 2022
Dec 21 2022

Wow you are digging it hard. You are realizing how obsessed you are ?
Member
Posts: 15,949
Joined: Jun 27 2010
Gold: 102,354.50
May 16 2023 02:22pm
Quote (Meanwhile @ May 16 2023 10:19pm)
Dec 10 2022
Nov 21 2022
Dec 21 2022

Wow you are digging it hard. You are realizing how obsessed you are ?


Trash deflection won't save you --> You produce my quotes that are from way earlier.

You're full of shit
Member
Posts: 45,718
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
May 16 2023 02:24pm
Quote (Djunior @ 17 May 2023 04:22)
Trash deflection won't save you --> You produce my quotes that are from way earlier.

You're full of shit


read this thread a few pages ;)

https://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=100387152&f=119
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
May 16 2023 02:25pm
if i have to bet on Russia's evolution: Putin gone, a bit of chaos and protests, then elections, complete peace, and joining the West. That's my optimistic bet.
Member
Posts: 28,877
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
May 16 2023 02:25pm
Quote (Prox1m1ty @ May 16 2023 03:40pm)
There is no moralism in my reasoning, stop strawmanning.

The realpolitik as I see it is that the main threat to Russian regime was Ukrainian democracy, combined with Russias own shitshow strategy of its black sea navy/naval base; That essentially involved bribing Ukraine's government to allow the Russian fleet in Sevastopol and hoping that Ukrainians would be fine pivoting away from closer ties to Europe and becoming the next Belarus.

The USSR and RF mismanagement of the administration of Crimea and its own terrible strategy for its Black Sea fleet led to this war becoming existential and inevitable for Russia.

If you think the US caused this primarily, there is no convincing you otherwise. But it blatantly is fallacious logic.
As I said before the US only takes notice of Russia when it has to. The Russian regime requires an adversarial relationship with the US for domestic leverage, and to validate its own ambition to be anything more than a nuclear equipped gas station masquerading as a global superpower.


Historical status quo was always that Ukraine was similar to Belarus is to Russia. We saw a bridgehead to upset that and undermine Russia, our historical geopolitical enemy and we took that opportunity with the coup, in similar ways we've done so in the past with dozens of coups against it's former form the USSR. You can continue to deny historical continuity and precedent but that's what it is, documented in many cases all across the globe in the last 70 years.

Idk what USSR mismanagement you're talking about, Crimea for the last few hundred years was a main Russian empire port. If you think some guy signing away Crimea in the 1950's when it didn't matter at all would cement that it's part of Ukraine even though prior it was Russian and even currently has an overwhelmingly Russian population, that's a really dumb assertion, it's even dumber to somehow think this simple signature is to be held to the highest legal standards of 'claim'. Not democracy, not ethnic make up, but some commie signing it away with a stroke of a pen (funny how funny we have no problem with that in the west when it suits are interest).

The Russian regime doesn't have to work very hard to convince it's people of this when NATO continues to inch closer and closer and envelop every nation next to Russia under it's 'defensive' military alliance. You'd think we wouldn't be so intimidated by a gas station as to continue to collect countries into an alliance against them like Pokemon cards, but here we are.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1270727082709271027115001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll