d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1267026712672267326745001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 9,702
Joined: Mar 2 2006
Gold: 1,590.00
May 8 2023 12:44pm
Quote (Ironfister @ 8 May 2023 20:24)
You say that Germany and France opposed, but other countries like UK, Australia joined it.
Germany and France were the countries who denied Ukraine membership into NATO, because they wanted to stay friendly with Putin.
Germany only spends like 1,2% gdp on their military, while according to NATO guidelines they should spend 2%.
Germans made their economy dependant on Russian gas pipeline.
France politicans are relatively friendly to Russians, with mrs Pen getting financing from Russian banks. Mr Macron is the only exception in french politics, who is not pro-russia.
So these countries were not the backbone of NATO, they didnt think their politics correctly in a strategic scale.
They mostly played their local games, focused on short term goals of their own country, instead of thinking about the whole NATO alliance.
I dont really like Trump, but there is one thing he said right, that Germany and France were not doing enough in NATO, and relying on America for European safety too much.
This has somewhat changed with Ukraine war, and its better now, but we are talking about past here.


OK 1:0 my way it seems, you started dodging. I see you got caught and do not deny that a poor middle eastern nation got bombed for the fuck of it to entertain some bored rednecks.

You have now have tried to scrape the bottom of the barrel of arguments to make Germany and France - the founding members of the European Union - which I'm sure you are proud to be - look bad. I'm not sure why you want to do that as Germany has generously donated billions yearly to make your country improve its infrastructure and institutions over literally decades. https://cdn.statcdn.com/Infographic/images/normal/18794.jpeg. Data for 2022-2023 looks similar if you look up recent EU budgets. Dont bite the hand that feeds.

NATO block including Germany and France did join for Aghanistan which was arguably better prepared and it was clear what the goals and strategy of the alliance are. Germany and France did not want to join in on a dangerous and reckless war waged by UK/US/Australia and of all the countries - Poland.

Remember Sykes-Picot and Callouste Gulbenkian. Middle East does. https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2016/5/16/iraq-sykes-picot-and-mr-five-percent

This post was edited by Malopox on May 8 2023 12:49pm
Member
Posts: 56,413
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 578,963.53
May 8 2023 12:46pm
Quote (Malopox @ May 8 2023 07:44pm)
OK 1:0 my way it seems, you started dodging. I see you got caught and do not deny that a poor middle eastern nation got bombed for the fuck of it to entertain some bored rednecks.

You have now have tried to scrape the barrel of arguments to make Germany and France - the founding members of the European Union - which I'm sure you are proud to be - look bad. I'm not sure why you want to do that as Germany has generously donated billions yearly to make your country improve its infrastructure and institutions over literally decades. https://cdn.statcdn.com/Infographic/images/normal/18794.jpeg. Data for 2022-2023 looks similar if you look up recent EU budgets. Dont bite the hand that feeds.

NATO block including Germany and France did join for Aghanistan which was arguably better prepared and it was clear what the goals and strategy of the alliance are. Germany and France did not want to join in on a dangerous and reckless war waged by UK/US/Australia and of all the countries - Poland.

Remember Sykes-Picot and Callouste Gulbenkian. Middle East does. https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2016/5/16/iraq-sykes-picot-and-mr-five-percent


give me a few minutes XD
Member
Posts: 9,702
Joined: Mar 2 2006
Gold: 1,590.00
May 8 2023 12:48pm
BTW to all who are interested in Oil and Energy politics, Daniel Yergin has been writing some bombastic stuff - first on Crude Oil and its history which got him a Pulitzer.
https://www.amazon.com/Prize-Epic-Quest-Money-Power/dp/1439110123
You will learn exciting stuff about how Scottish forefathers of helped British secure the oil riches of Iran, who is Callouste Gulbenkian, what happened in Venezuela and how did Nobel brothers earn their billions in Azerbaijan to fund the Nobel Prize, who was trading with the Bolsheviks and what did Rockefeller do wrong. Bonus points - you will find out how Jews and the logo of Royal Dutch Shell are related!

and now on Energy Transition:
https://www.amazon.com/New-Map-Energy-Climate-Nations/dp/0143111159

This post was edited by Malopox on May 8 2023 12:57pm
Member
Posts: 56,413
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 578,963.53
May 8 2023 12:53pm
Quote (Ironfister @ May 8 2023 07:24pm)
You say that Germany and France opposed, but other countries like UK, Australia joined it.
Germany and France were the countries who denied Ukraine membership into NATO, because they wanted to stay friendly with Putin.
Germany only spends like 1,2% gdp on their military, while according to NATO guidelines they should spend 2%.
Germans made their economy dependant on Russian gas pipeline.
France politicans are relatively friendly to Russians, with mrs Pen getting financing from Russian banks. Mr Macron is the only exception in french politics, who is not pro-russia.
So these countries were not the backbone of NATO, they didnt think their politics correctly in a strategic scale.
They mostly played their local games, focused on short term goals of their own country, instead of thinking about the whole NATO alliance.
I dont really like Trump, but there is one thing he said right, that Germany and France were not doing enough in NATO, and relying on America for European safety too much.
This has somewhat changed with Ukraine war, and its better now, but we are talking about past here.


The UK, and the US, got into bed with America. this is not something new.

There were no weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. The UK and the US, conspired to blackmail/coerce several countries to vote in their favor at the UN re: Iraq. This all came to light via a UK whistleblower in GCHQ, who was charged under offenses against the secrets act. It went to court and the state, wait for it, declined to offer comment. "In May 2019 The Guardian stated the case was dropped "when the prosecution realised that evidence would emerge ... that even British government lawyers believed the invasion was unlawful".

your welcome.

TLDR: The US invaded Iraq to create regime change because they didnt like Saddam. Now, I dont like some of my neighbors but i'm not going outside to kill their kids or their dog.

This post was edited by ferdia on May 8 2023 12:58pm
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
May 8 2023 12:57pm
Quote (Ironfister @ 8 May 2023 20:24)
You say that Germany and France opposed, but other countries like UK, Australia joined it.
Germany and France were the countries who denied Ukraine membership into NATO, because they wanted to stay friendly with Putin.
Germany only spends like 1,2% gdp on their military, while according to NATO guidelines they should spend 2%.
Germans made their economy dependant on Russian gas pipeline.
France politicans are relatively friendly to Russians, with mrs Pen getting financing from Russian banks. Mr Macron is the only exception in french politics, who is not pro-russia.
So these countries were not the backbone of NATO, they didnt think their politics correctly in a strategic scale.
They mostly played their local games, focused on short term goals of their own country, instead of thinking about the whole NATO alliance.
I dont really like Trump, but there is one thing he said right, that Germany and France were not doing enough in NATO, and relying on America for European safety too much.
This has somewhat changed with Ukraine war, and its better now, but we are talking about past here.


Gz you are getting tricked in usual whataboutstism shit. Don't talk about France please you have no fucking idea of the shit you are saying that's pretty clear now.
Member
Posts: 9,702
Joined: Mar 2 2006
Gold: 1,590.00
May 8 2023 12:58pm
Quote (Meanwhile @ 8 May 2023 20:57)
Gz you are getting tricked in usual whataboutstism shit. Don't talk about France please you have no fucking idea of the shit you are saying that's pretty clear now.


No - you are supposed to be on his side pierre.
Member
Posts: 56,413
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 578,963.53
May 8 2023 01:01pm
Quote (Ironfister @ May 8 2023 07:24pm)
You say that Germany and France opposed, but other countries like UK, Australia joined it.
Germany and France were the countries who denied Ukraine membership into NATO, because they wanted to stay friendly with Putin.
Germany only spends like 1,2% gdp on their military, while according to NATO guidelines they should spend 2%.
Germans made their economy dependant on Russian gas pipeline.
France politicans are relatively friendly to Russians, with mrs Pen getting financing from Russian banks. Mr Macron is the only exception in french politics, who is not pro-russia.
So these countries were not the backbone of NATO, they didnt think their politics correctly in a strategic scale.
They mostly played their local games, focused on short term goals of their own country, instead of thinking about the whole NATO alliance.
I dont really like Trump, but there is one thing he said right, that Germany and France were not doing enough in NATO, and relying on America for European safety too much.
This has somewhat changed with Ukraine war, and its better now, but we are talking about past here.


and it is widely documented that Germany and France were opposed because they knew that Ukraine was Russia's red line. I.E. if everyone agreed for Ukraine to be in Nato back in 2008 then Russia would have invaded Ukraine on the spot, you dont get instant Nato Access, and no country in Europe would have been mental enough to guarantee Ukraine military protection during the transition into Nato phase because that would have resulted in WW3. Why are you bashing Germany and France ? they are two of the soundest actor's in all this. The UK was happy to give Finland such a guarantee last year because they knew that Russia didnt care about Finland in the first place. Notice how no one gave Ukraine such a guarantee ? Think about that for an hour or so.

This post was edited by ferdia on May 8 2023 01:03pm
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
May 8 2023 01:03pm
Quote (Malopox @ 8 May 2023 20:58)
No - you are supposed to be on his side pierre.


Get good tricking the weak, Vladimir.
Member
Posts: 9,702
Joined: Mar 2 2006
Gold: 1,590.00
May 8 2023 01:12pm
Quote (ferdia @ 8 May 2023 20:53)
The UK, and the US, got into bed with America. this is not something new.

There were no weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. The UK and the US, conspired to blackmail/coerce several countries to vote in their favor at the UN re: Iraq. This all came to light via a UK whistleblower in GCHQ, who was charged under offenses against the secrets act. It went to court and the state, wait for it, declined to offer comment. "In May 2019 The Guardian stated the case was dropped "when the prosecution realised that evidence would emerge ... that even British government lawyers believed the invasion was unlawful".

your welcome.

TLDR: The US invaded Iraq to create regime change because they didnt like Saddam. Now, I dont like some of my neighbors but i'm not going outside to kill their kids or their dog.


I think you’ve forgotten the fun part where US wanted to oust Assad and funded Timber Sycamore and then all of these fun and radicalized guys decided to create their own Islamic Caliphate in Iraq, but now with blackjack, hookers and beheadings while raping and pillaging everything in their way.

And then US had to come in again to fight the same people CIA trained to protect their old Kurdish allies with whom they ousted Saddam (btw those Kurdish allies are still on US State Terrorism list). It’s all sad beyond belief and the whole region would probably benefitted a lot of only Yankees stayed home. Oopsie, cover that one up with a fig leaf and never talk about it - too complicated:

https://theintercept.com/2019/10/26/syrian-rebels-turkey-kurds-accountability/
Member
Posts: 52,225
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,902.00
May 8 2023 03:26pm
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/for-the-first-time-a-patriot-missile-has-killed-one-of-russia-s-hypersonic-missiles/ar-AA1aTAXj

Quote
But then on Saturday, Ukrainian Air Force commander Mykola Oleshchuk finally confirmed on a Telegram post the "historic event": one of the UAF's new Patriot missiles had indeed downed the "unparalleled" Kinzhal. He noted the Kinzhal had been launched from over Russian airspace by a MiG-31K fighter, and admonished the media for reporting the incident in advance of his confirmation.

Some sources allege Ukraine’s military initially cast doubt on the kill because it didn't want Russia to know it could down Kinzhal missiles or that a Patriot battery was active in Kyiv, and was frustrated when the news leaked. However, the widespread dissemination of the image of the downed nose cone perhaps caused a change in media strategy.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1267026712672267326745001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll