d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1256825692570257125725001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 45,719
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Apr 17 2023 02:45pm
Quote (Neptunus @ 18 Apr 2023 04:41)
I aint even mad. All im interested in is how these contrarian zealots are claiming to say exactly what both of you are saying, but end up sounding like Lavrov, Peskov or Zakharova. Im just genuinely curious and so far, all im getting is a repost of the NATO website link and photos/memes, broken records. But maybe theyll make me understand better.


Pay attention to , , , comments they have very realpolitik style comments.
On the other end of the so called " Russian " zealot comments you can also find a few " Western " Hawk comments in this thread, you should know who they are by now.

This post was edited by Hamsterbaby on Apr 17 2023 02:45pm
Member
Posts: 4,147
Joined: Jun 30 2022
Gold: 6.42
Warn: 10%
Apr 17 2023 02:49pm
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Apr 17 2023 04:48pm)
Will China be the new Macedonia or India is the new Macedonia . If China or Russia equates to ( Sparta ) and USA / allies equates to ( Athens ) or however you are going to place them.


The US reminds me of Athens before the Peloponnesian war, with Sparta +allies being represented by China/Russia/Global south

I don't think we can really predict who will become the new Macedonia, it really depends how this confrontation ends up happening, especially if we end up in a nuclear war. We may also see the creation of new nations or blocs like Africa or the Middle East which might change the international dynamic quite a bit. If they were to become unified in ways similar to the EU for example.

Member
Posts: 2,664
Joined: Dec 4 2011
Gold: 6.66
Apr 17 2023 02:49pm
Quote (ferdia @ Apr 17 2023 11:37pm)
I can easily refute that by pointing to the Iraq war. The current war has not reached that level yet (but it probably will at this rate). but the point i would stress is, russia did not engage in total war from the get-go vs ukraine, unlike with the US vs Iraq. This could be a point you might agree on.

TLDR: all wars being suffering. we dont need to keep score on who does war better.


Agreed, and like ive said earlier, the Ukraine war made me even more critical of the Iraq war. I was also pretty young back then when the invasion occurred, so i didnt know a lot about it but i do recall a lot of stuff about it. The issue here is that were talking about geopolitics of greater powers/superpowers, but forget to consider the geopolitics of the smaller players. Ukraine, Finland, Baltics, Georgia, all play their own geopolitical game. But no matter whose security concerns are the most justified from their own perspective, no matter the disputes, territorial inviolability is the only ideal that everyone should be able to agree upon. Not adhering to that is being the bad guy. Be it the US, Russia, China, anything.

This post was edited by Neptunus on Apr 17 2023 03:11pm
Member
Posts: 28,878
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Apr 17 2023 02:50pm
Quote (Neptunus @ Apr 17 2023 04:36pm)
You are right, and were talking about the same thing when it comes to cause and effect. Im referring to how people confuse how things are with how things should be (done).

Not only despotic regimes prey on their neighbours, but when the despotic ones do they bring a lot more suffering. Nuance indeed.


If the choice is between having a larger, stronger neighboring state domineer you, but largely let you peacefully live and having an all out war because nationalistic factions with outside help seized control and upset the status quo it's not a hard choice. Most Ukrainians would love to go back in time to 2010 to have their husbands and fathers around instead of dying.

Member
Posts: 50,829
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,846.00
Apr 17 2023 02:51pm
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Apr 17 2023 03:45pm)
Pay attention to ^Ferdia, ^Malopox, ^ofthevoid , ^ownyaah comments they have very realpolitik style comments.
On the other end of the so called " Russian " zealot comments you can also find a few " Western " Hawk comments in this thread, you should know who they are by now.


There's a less than subtle difference between those that oppose American foreign policy and our geopolitical hegemony, and those who support American hegemony and denounce the misguided policies that are weakening it.
I've said pretty early on I don't care how many fuckaluckistanis are dying, just whether it serves our national interests. And that we're repeating the Syrian War missteps except far more dangerously.
I get a chuckle when posting anonymously on other sites when I get alternatively mistaken as a bleeding heart bernie tankie and a Russian psyop kremlin run account, guess theres something to be said about horseshoes
Member
Posts: 38,137
Joined: May 28 2006
Gold: 0.00
Apr 17 2023 02:54pm
Member
Posts: 2,664
Joined: Dec 4 2011
Gold: 6.66
Apr 17 2023 02:55pm
Quote (Goomshill @ Apr 17 2023 11:51pm)
There's a less than subtle difference between those that oppose American foreign policy and our geopolitical hegemony, and those who support American hegemony and denounce the misguided policies that are weakening it.
I've said pretty early on I don't care how many fuckaluckistanis are dying, just whether it serves our national interests. And that we're repeating the Syrian War missteps except far more dangerously.
I get a chuckle when posting anonymously on other sites when I get alternatively mistaken as a bleeding heart bernie tankie and a Russian psyop kremlin run account, guess theres something to be said about horseshoes


Being a radical centrist is just a special edition of the horseshoe.
Member
Posts: 56,399
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 585,553.49
Apr 17 2023 02:55pm
Quote (Neptunus @ Apr 17 2023 09:49pm)
Agreed, and like ive said earlier, the Ukraine war made me even more critical of the Iraq war. I was also pretty young back then when the invasion occurred, so i didnt know a lot about it but i do recall a lot of stuff about it. The issue here is that were talking about geopolitics of greatee powers/superpowers, but forget to consider the geopolitics of the smaller players. Ukraine, Finland, Baltics, Georgia, all play their own geopolitical game. But no matter whose security concerns are the must justified from their own perspective, no matter the disputes, territorial inviolability is the only ideal that everyone should be able to agree upon. Not adhering to that is being the bad guy. Be it the US, Russia, China, anything.


flipping a country via political means instead of by the end of a barrel of a gun is more palatable to the world, but some countries will not be happy. There are alot of examples relating to the US, China and Russia in this regard. (I name those big 3 noting there are alot of examples from each).

USA: Rigs elections in countries 24/7 (they are good at it)
China: using the carrot to get neutral countries on their side, or the stick with taiwan.
Russia: Communism pre 2000 and rigs elections in countries (they are not good at it, communism failed and they could not keep Ukraine in their sphere).

This post was edited by ferdia on Apr 17 2023 02:58pm
Member
Posts: 2,664
Joined: Dec 4 2011
Gold: 6.66
Apr 17 2023 02:58pm
Quote (HeLiCaL @ Apr 17 2023 11:54pm)


Aggressors lie about the wars they wage. Its standard. This meme just selected USA x3 followed by Russia. You would include Afghanistan, Chechnya I and II, Georgia, Syria too, if you (or the meme's author) had any integrity.
Member
Posts: 45,719
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Apr 17 2023 02:58pm
Quote (Goomshill @ 18 Apr 2023 04:51)
There's a less than subtle difference between those that oppose American foreign policy and our geopolitical hegemony, and those who support American hegemony and denounce the misguided policies that are weakening it.
I've said pretty early on I don't care how many fuckaluckistanis are dying, just whether it serves our national interests. And that we're repeating the Syrian War missteps except far more dangerously.
I get a chuckle when posting anonymously on other sites when I get alternatively mistaken as a bleeding heart bernie tankie and a Russian psyop kremlin run account, guess theres something to be said about horseshoes


I am completely fine and happy if the poster admits this. Because this is honest and not being hypocritical. And if more people admit this, there is even a slight chance to find and negotiate a middle ground.

This post was edited by Hamsterbaby on Apr 17 2023 02:59pm
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1256825692570257125725001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll