d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1234823492350235123525001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Mar 9 2023 07:09am
China gettin triggered, "China’s Xi calls for ‘more quickly elevating’ armed forces" and "2025 made in china" economic domination project.
https://apnews.com/article/china-us-military-taiwan-xi-jinping-14f9c3d8fef26779f017d927aa352eeb

Thus they are losing alot of workforce because of their women don't want to make children at all, their urban employee pop is stagnating and their rural workers force is crushing down.
I am not certain for future, but one possibility in 2025 is that Russia 'won't exist' anymore and China will lose power. Yet these ccp vampires will stay in charge at any price like in NK anyway.

This post was edited by Meanwhile on Mar 9 2023 07:18am
Member
Posts: 16,411
Joined: Apr 9 2007
Gold: 12,059.17
Mar 9 2023 07:17am
Quote (ferdia @ 9 Mar 2023 14:07)


Nowhere in there did he say that Putin is a good man and I agree completely with what he said there. YOU dont, and you are entitled to your belief but it is wrong to say that he said something that he did not say.


He didnt say, but he implied it.
Because if we let Putin do whatever he wants in Ukraine, the only scenario in which Ukraine survives is that Putin doesnt have bad intentions.
Its all logic.
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Mar 9 2023 07:24am
Quote (Ironfister @ 9 Mar 2023 14:17)
He didnt say, but he implied it.
Because if we let Putin do whatever he wants in Ukraine, the only scenario in which Ukraine survives is that Putin doesnt have bad intentions.
Its all logic.


Yes... More likely agree:

Constantly doing time travel, "Nato's fault", and then blaming that the west is bad because it didn't let Putin to make another Holomodor ... Yep it's at least supporting Putin and his regime; no doubt.

It's just another sub-variant ( along with the "negotiations" one) of the usual anti-all speech; criticizing everyone, spitting on the west/democracies, and then getting silenced when asked "ok, all bad; what is your solution then, in practice, step by step ?".

This post was edited by Meanwhile on Mar 9 2023 07:27am
Member
Posts: 54,124
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Mar 9 2023 07:25am
Quote (Goomshill @ 9 Mar 2023 10:23)
Putin had no reason to invade Ukraine while Ukraine was already under Russia's sphere of influence. Its that simple
NATO attempted to seize it by force and broke it in half, Russia took back its half by force and devastated the other half

As long as Ukraine was aligned with Russia, headed by a majority pro-Russian government, then it didn't matter what nebulous degree of sovereignty and self-determination they had- they served Russia's interests. They held the status quo ante, they didn't need to aggressively build a empire nor is Russia seizing back a sphere of influence we tried to take from them in an ongoing war, some grand irredentism.

Oh please, Ukraine was already slipping increasingly out of Russia's sphere of influence by its own volition for over a decade before the Euromaidan even happened. Anyone remember the Orange Revolution of 2004 or the failed assassination attempt against pro-Western presidential candidate Viktor Yushchenko?

Likewise - and we've argued over this point many times - the Euromaidan revolution was defintely not entirely astrotured and CIA-led or whatever. How do we know? Well, when Russia invaded in February 2022, it would have been far easier to just roll over and let it happen, like Crimea did back in 2014, than to fight back. Yet fighting back is what most of Ukraine did. Even regions like Kharkiv or Odessia which had voted for the pro-Russian candidate in the 2010 presidential election that you love to cite. How can you have watched the lengths to which Ukraine's people are willing to go to defend their freedom in the face of a brutal invasion, but still cling to the notion that the pro-Western and pro-freedom sentiment at the core of the Euromaidan movement was a mirage or illegitimate or artificial?

-----------

In hindsight, the best course of action would have been to voluntarily do what will be the outcome of this war anyway: split up the country. Ukraine should have gone for an amicable divorce between its pro-Western and pro-Russian provinces back in 2014, similar to the way Czechoslovakia was split up into Czechia and Slovakia.

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Mar 9 2023 07:26am
Member
Posts: 56,398
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 585,113.49
Mar 9 2023 07:26am
Quote (Ironfister @ Mar 9 2023 01:17pm)
He didnt say, but he implied it.
Because if we let Putin do whatever he wants in Ukraine, the only scenario in which Ukraine survives is that Putin doesnt have bad intentions.
Its all logic.



Lets play a game:

Ironfister: ...20% korean components then Korean government shouldnt have the right to ban the export of the finał product.That's just common sense.
Ferdia: No its not common sense. Any country can cease exporting components to whoever it does not like. Because it is a soverign state. You do not appear to understand this concept.

Ironfister: Russia is a medium country
Ferdia: Its the largest country on the planet. You dont know this. You either misspoke, are not knowledgeable, are an idiot, or a combination of all of these.

The above are examples of logical counter arguments by me.

Ironfister - This:

Quote (Djunior @ Mar 9 2023 08:52am)
Cut the crap dude. If EU / US / NATO didn't welcome Ukrainian / Georgian membership in 2008 and didn't stage a coup in 2014 (Euromaidan) proving they were serious, we wouldn't be here today and Ukraine would still be an independent nation. Russia would still be able to lease their naval base (like they did), all would be good. People like you hate Russia, push for further NATO expansion and you've found out what happens if you push it too far.


Relates to EU / US / Nato policy over the last 2 decades whereby the west has ever expanded eastwards, and yes, that the coup in 2014 was US backed. This is factual information with the caveat that its complex and Black XistenZ has expounded more about it (which i broadly agree with). It is not the basis upon which you can logically deduce that anyone with this view is Pro Russian or that anyone thinks Putin is a good man. Call us contrarians or fairies. use the right words and terminology because if you dont we will just poke holes in the flawed arguments.

This post was edited by ferdia on Mar 9 2023 07:30am
Member
Posts: 54,124
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Mar 9 2023 07:37am
Quote (Meanwhile @ 9 Mar 2023 14:09)
China gettin triggered, "China’s Xi calls for ‘more quickly elevating’ armed forces" and "2025 made in china" economic domination project.
https://apnews.com/article/china-us-military-taiwan-xi-jinping-14f9c3d8fef26779f017d927aa352eeb

Thus they are losing alot of workforce because of their women don't want to make children at all, their urban employee pop is stagnating and their rural workers force is crushing down.
I am not certain for future, but one possibility in 2025 is that Russia 'won't exist' anymore and China will lose power. Yet these ccp vampires will stay in charge at any price like in NK anyway.

How exactly will Russia "not exist anymore" in 2025? At worst, some of the ethnic minority provinces like Chechnya or Dagestan break away. Russia's heartland will stay intact though and they still easily have enough nukes to deter any kind of large-scale military operation against them, be it by NATO, China or anyone else.

For the Russian state to dissolve, you'd need an unfathomable economic collapse, followed by revolutions and chaos. You'd need an economic crisis so bad that people start literally starving in the streets, and that's just not gonna happen in a country with as much farmland and as many natural resources which are in high demand on the world markets. Sure, a bad economic crisis is well within the realm of possibility. But not one so cataclysmic that the economic and social core of the country starts to disintegrate.

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Mar 9 2023 07:38am
Member
Posts: 4,147
Joined: Jun 30 2022
Gold: 6.42
Warn: 10%
Mar 9 2023 07:41am
Ukrainians soldiers listening to a Polish song about drugs sung by a cactus. Enjoy!


Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Mar 9 2023 07:41am
Quote (Black XistenZ @ 9 Mar 2023 14:37)
How exactly will Russia "not exist anymore" in 2025? At worst, some of the ethnic minority provinces like Chechnya or Dagestan break away. Russia's heartland will stay intact though and they still easily have enough nukes to deter any kind of large-scale military operation against them, be it by NATO, China or anyone else.

For the Russian state to dissolve, you'd need an unfathomable economic collapse, followed by revolutions and chaos. You'd need an economic crisis so bad that people start literally starving in the streets, and that's just not gonna happen in a country with as much farmland and as many natural resources which are in high demand on the world markets. Sure, a bad economic crisis is well within the realm of possibility. But not one so cataclysmic that the economic and social core of the country starts to disintegrate.


Russian federation, fixed. It's one optimist output.
Member
Posts: 15,955
Joined: Jun 27 2010
Gold: 102,354.50
Mar 9 2023 07:42am
Quote (Ironfister @ Mar 9 2023 02:17pm)
He didnt say, but he implied it.
Because if we let Putin do whatever he wants in Ukraine, the only scenario in which Ukraine survives is that Putin doesnt have bad intentions.
Its all logic.


Now you're moving the goalposts. I didn't say Putin is a good man

By the way, Russia used to lease the Sevastopol naval base from Ukraine so they payed Ukraine to use it. No one was using force. Do you understand that or not?

Quote (Meanwhile @ Mar 9 2023 02:24pm)
Yes... More likely agree:

Constantly doing time travel, "Nato's fault", and then blaming that the west is bad because it didn't let Putin to make another Holomodor ... Yep it's at least supporting Putin and his regime; no doubt.

It's just another sub-variant ( along with the "negotiations" one) of the usual anti-all speech; criticizing everyone, spitting on the west/democracies, and then getting silenced when asked "ok, all bad; what is your solution then, in practice, step by step ?".


This has been pointed out numerous times. Can you read?

--> NATO / EU / US should not push NATO further East, the Russian have made it very clear multiple times that it's a provocation.

--> The only option is to negotiate and sign a treaty that provides mutual security guarantees, no more false promises that are stepped on further down the line (we fooled them, lol)
Member
Posts: 54,124
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Mar 9 2023 07:45am
Quote (Meanwhile @ 9 Mar 2023 14:41)
Russian federation, fixed. It's one optimist output.

Even that is unrealistic, for the reasons I lined out. Russia's heartland is ethnically and culturally homogeneous, it's not gonna break apart over ethnic strife or fierce ideological differences. They are immune from invasion due to their nukes. And they are immune from complete economic collapse due to their revenue from the sale of various natural resources.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1234823492350235123525001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll