Quote (ferdia @ 9 Mar 2023 10:47)
From a historical, cultural, economic and social perspective, the Polish position is virtually impossible to argue against. The west has been very very good to Poland and Poland remembers.
However, your understanding of what we are saying here in this topic is woefully inadequate, and is to my mind as a direct result of the above. It is for this reason that I won't refute or try to correct what you are saying. However if you want me to refute you, just ask, and I will.
It doesnt matter if I'm polish or not. You are welcome to discuss.
Russia is a medium country, that is very bad.
It struggles to conquer Ukraine. So they are a limited threat ATM.
Because of their limited size, limited potential, they are limited risk.
Hovewer if we let them grow, if we let them eat countries around them, if we let them gather 3mln people army, the west world will be in a very serious trouble. Because the west in no way can build such a huge army in a short time.
The west will be on Putin's mercy.
Will the France launch their nukes if Russia attacks Germany conventionally?
Will the USA launch their nukes to defend Germany from Russian tanks?
I don't think so. Nobody wants to start nuclear war, the nuclear apocalypse unless their own security is at serious risk.
There are nuclear weapons in Germany, but they are controlled by USA troops, not by Germany. So Germany are at big risk.
Only UK and France are relatively secure, because they have their own nukes.
But I'm not sure if they have so many of them to actually scare Russians in the event of real war.
So helping Ukraine to defend is actually the best thing NATO/west can possibly do.