d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1221622172218221922205001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 765
Joined: Aug 25 2022
Gold: 2,602.00
Warn: 10%
Feb 20 2023 12:39pm
Quote (ferdia @ Feb 20 2023 10:35am)
feel free to reference sources to support this position

A source for what? Forced conscription? There are hundreds of videos of men fighting back as they are shoved into vans.
Member
Posts: 56,400
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 585,553.49
Feb 20 2023 12:40pm
Quote (kusotarre1 @ Feb 20 2023 06:39pm)
A source for what? Forced conscription? There are hundreds of videos of men fighting back as they are shoved into vans.


is there no reporting on it at all? thats a story all unto its own. As I understand it Ukraine is in a state of Martial Law. i trust you understand the implications of this.

This post was edited by ferdia on Feb 20 2023 12:41pm
Member
Posts: 765
Joined: Aug 25 2022
Gold: 2,602.00
Warn: 10%
Feb 20 2023 12:43pm
Quote (ferdia @ Feb 20 2023 10:40am)
is there no reporting on it at all? thats a story all unto its own. As I understand it Ukraine is in a state of Martial Law. i trust you understand the implications of this.

I don't think I've read a single story mentioning such videos.
Member
Posts: 56,400
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 585,553.49
Feb 20 2023 12:44pm
Quote (kusotarre1 @ Feb 20 2023 06:43pm)
I don't think I've read a single story mentioning such videos.


a damning verdict of western reporting.

feel free to google: Al Jazeera " Western media and the war on truth in Ukraine"

a snippet from the article:

"What is shocking is how the “free press” in the “free world”, which to its credit has helped reveal much of the official deception in the past as in the “Pentagon Papers” and the “Afghan Papers”, is adamant about echoing and amplifying the official line as if it were complicit in the war.

Watching journalists and pundits in respected American and British journals exhaust the synonyms of fascist, evil and dangerous to describe Russia’s Putin, with little or no attempt at balance or objectivity, one is inclined to believe that Western media has largely been enlisted in NATO’s crusade against Putin’s Russia until victory. But what does “victory” entail here: liberating all of Ukraine? Or weakening Russia to the extent it no longer threatens other European countries?"

This post was edited by ferdia on Feb 20 2023 12:49pm
Member
Posts: 765
Joined: Aug 25 2022
Gold: 2,602.00
Warn: 10%
Feb 20 2023 12:47pm
Quote (ferdia @ Feb 20 2023 10:44am)
a damning verdict of western reporting.

Indeed. Unparalleled media lockstep on what does and does not get reported.

If you want to see them, this channel is probably the best for it, just search for keywords you can think of: https://t.me/UkraineHumanRightsAbuses/
Member
Posts: 56,400
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 585,553.49
Feb 20 2023 12:49pm
no need no need!
Member
Posts: 33,771
Joined: May 9 2009
Gold: 3.33
Feb 20 2023 12:56pm
A more detailed view of how this Russian offensive is playing out. Spoiler: it's not going very well.

https://twitter.com/KofmanMichael/status/1627309427907854336
Member
Posts: 765
Joined: Aug 25 2022
Gold: 2,602.00
Warn: 10%
Feb 20 2023 01:05pm
Quote (ferdia @ Feb 20 2023 10:44am)
feel free to google: Al Jazeera " Western media and the war on truth in Ukraine"

I just read this, and have to say I despise this kind of wishy-washy, both-sides-are-bad attitude, as well as all the silly, tired tropes that fill the article.

Yeah, Westerners need to understand how fucked their media is, but that's not enough. A big part of propaganda is just making sure that the Enemy is as bad as you are, and preferably worse. I find that's rarely the case, living in the West.

We were just discussing casualties. We have Russia's enemies (the BBC) confirming Russia's own statements of casualties. Meanwhile, Ukraine is refusing to release any kind of realistic numbers. There are protests in Ukraine by the wives of soldiers who have been listed as "missing" for 6 months!

So is Russia equal to Ukraine or the West in this regard, or is Russia in fact being more truthful? I think obviously the latter.

We also just discussed that Russia allows hostile foreign press to operate in it's borders, and even routinely accept interviews where they are asked confrontational, unscripted questions with plenty of pressing and follow up. How many times has Lavrov appeared on the BBC to make Russia's case? It's impossible, though, to imagine Biden sitting down with RT, or Zelensky getting grilled on 60 minutes. So is Russia's media policy as bad as the West's, or is it in fact better than the West's? Again, I think it's obviously the latter.

And then the other main thing I hate is this 'autocracies versus democracies' narrative. Russia is at least as democratic as the USA or Britain. They have elections, Putin has broad public support and legitimacy. Westerners may not like this, but that's just a fact. Putin is more popular to Russians than any Western leader is in their home countries. It's hard to take seriously talk about democratic principles when the US congress usually has an approval rating in the single digits, and no American ever gets a single major thing they ever want. Ditto for Canada, the UK, France, Germany, etc.
Member
Posts: 78,723
Joined: Nov 30 2008
Gold: 493.00
Feb 20 2023 01:10pm
Quote (kusotarre1 @ Feb 20 2023 02:05pm)
I just read this, and have to say I despise this kind of wishy-washy, both-sides-are-bad attitude, as well as all the silly, tired tropes that fill the article.

Yeah, Westerners need to understand how fucked their media is, but that's not enough. A big part of propaganda is just making sure that the Enemy is as bad as you are, and preferably worse. I find that's rarely the case, living in the West.

We were just discussing casualties. We have Russia's enemies (the BBC) confirming Russia's own statements of casualties. Meanwhile, Ukraine is refusing to release any kind of realistic numbers. There are protests in Ukraine by the wives of soldiers who have been listed as "missing" for 6 months!

So is Russia equal to Ukraine or the West in this regard, or is Russia in fact being more truthful? I think obviously the latter.

We also just discussed that Russia allows hostile foreign press to operate in it's borders, and even routinely accept interviews where they are asked confrontational, unscripted questions with plenty of pressing and follow up. How many times has Lavrov appeared on the BBC to make Russia's case? It's impossible, though, to imagine Biden sitting down with RT, or Zelensky getting grilled on 60 minutes. So is Russia's media policy as bad as the West's, or is it in fact better than the West's? Again, I think it's obviously the latter.

And then the other main thing I hate is this 'autocracies versus democracies' narrative.Russia is at least as democratic as the USA or Britain. They have elections, Putin has broad public support and legitimacy. Westerners may not like this, but that's just a fact. Putin is more popular to Russians than any Western leader is in their home countries. It's hard to take seriously talk about democratic principles when the US congress usually has an approval rating in the single digits, and no American ever gets a single major thing they ever want. Ditto for Canada, the UK, France, Germany, etc.


exhibit A in how consuming ccp/kremlin propaganda for 30 years rots your brain

i'm sure navalny and the tens of thousands of russians who were arrested recently for talking about the war disagree with the garbage you write

This post was edited by duffman316 on Feb 20 2023 01:10pm
Member
Posts: 765
Joined: Aug 25 2022
Gold: 2,602.00
Warn: 10%
Feb 20 2023 01:14pm
Quote (dro94 @ Feb 20 2023 10:56am)
A more detailed view of how this Russian offensive is playing out. Spoiler: it's not going very well.

https://twitter.com/KofmanMichael/status/1627309427907854336

That's a joke thread from a guy who got one thing right early on, and then has produced nothing but cope and wrong predictions. Which he again does here, the same dumb thing he's said a hundred times before:

Quote
Russian forces are expending artillery ammunition in this offensive which they will miss in the spring. The coming months will reveal the real situation in RU artillery ammo availability, which I expect is quite problematic, forcing them to ration. 14/

Just like they ran out of missiles, drones, tanks and shells every single month since March, they will definitely run out this summer.

At some point, some of you people are going to need to realize that Russia actually has factories that make things. Hard to imagine when you live in the hollow husk of an industrial nation like America, I know.

Quote
Instead, Gerasimov is exhausting the Russian armed forces with a feckless series of offensive operations, which may yield some gains, like Bakhmut, but unlikely to change the strategic picture.

We've now reached the stage where Bakhmut, which is enormously strategically important as everyone said right up until about December, is being written off as "some gains", lol. I forget what stage of loss that is.

Quote
UA is better served absorbing the RU attack & exhausting RU offensive potential, then taking the initiative later this spring. Having expended ammunition, better troops, and equipment it could leave RU defense overall weaker.


Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1221622172218221922205001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll