Quote (Prox1m1ty @ Jan 20 2023 06:25pm)
I'd be very interested in what the alternative to supporting Ukraine is.
Quote (Prox1m1ty @ Jan 20 2023 06:39pm)
So ignore Ukraine's right to exist as a sovereign country? Or accept Ukraine's right to exist as a sovereign country, but only the parts the Russia doesn't want to occupy?
And what was Russia's alternative to invading Ukraine? Not invading Ukraine? Not supporting Ukraine's right to exist as a sovereign country, and abandoning the ethnic Russian majority to the ongoing NATO siege of the east? Ceding their geopolitical sphere to American aggression until they've got nothing beyond their own borders?
This kind of logic isn't circular and isn't morally relativistic, it has finite grounding. The facts are that in this conflict, America provoked an inevitable reaction, Russia responded. We pushed NATO right up to their borders and put them into a corner, we overthrew the democratic government in Ukraine to set up our own pro-NATO dictatorship, and Russia finally reached a breaking point. Then when they hit back, we turn around and accuse them of being the aggressors. We could have simply chosen to preserve status quo in Ukraine circa 2014, but Joe Biden micromanaged a color revolution instead and handpicked the new government of willing stooges to the CIA. And when Joe Biden became president and was faced with a Russian buildup on the border, and dithered and said we would
not try to intervene to stop an invasion- we could have simply followed through and let Russia reclaim control of the country. Which might have given Ukraine less sovereignty than the status quo ante we had thrown out the window, but which obviously and undeniably was a better outcome for the Ukrainian people. Who had spent centuries or millenia under the Russian sphere save for these short few years of NATO meddling, and its not like they were facing daily horrors of nu-holodomors or cossacks again, they had their shitty peaceful lives.
From some moralizing lens, the war is clearly bad. We're giving heavy weaponry to nazi insurrectionists to get as many poor people killed as we can in hopes of killing some more russians. But I've always said that what matters is the pragmatic geopolitical lens, in which our intervention is still self-destructive because we're fracturing our relationships with the unaligned world and driving them into the Russian/Chinese camps, strengthening the bonds of our two greatest rivals, tanking our own economy and still going to come out of the whole thing with Russia holding onto the only valuable parts of Ukraine while we earn nothing but a bunch of hungry mouths to feed, except this time around they're not muslims but we don't have any food anyway because Russia holds the grain now lmao
This post was edited by Goomshill on Jan 20 2023 10:48pm