d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1191319141915191619175001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 50,871
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,846.00
Jan 6 2023 09:31am
Quote (ofthevoid @ Jan 6 2023 09:18am)
On a macro, long term strategic level I really can't comprehend the logic. I've talked about this about half a dozen times at this point. We all know China is the true challenger to our hegemony and displacing us. So if we're operating under that assumption, the subsequent question is how can we weaken them and prevent that from happening. Splitting Russia from their camp should have been a top priority. You do that by getting Russia into the western sphere, which actually would have been symbiotic. Russia can continue to supply tons of cheap energy to the EU while we can leverage that relationship and ties to drive a wedge between them and China.

Instead we make Russia the enemy, and use the western created financial infrastructure to try and crush them. So what happens is a secondary and parallel infrastructure is being created which is dominated by China and you have so much of the world lining up to join them. Now China has a near guaranteed pipeline of cheap energy and raw natural resources because by trying to shut down Russia, we pushed them right into China's arms, guaranteeing crucial resources probably for decades to come. It literally put our decline on a fast track, with tons of energy producing giants looking east, forming stronger bonds with China and agreeing to stop using the greenback as the default international currency.

This has to be one of the bigger strategic mistakes we've seen in modern history, up there with Hitler opening up the eastern front. Maybe I'm missing something idk. Maybe the calculus was, that we'd be able to have some western installed puppets in Russia so we didn't need to respect their current powers?


And Russia and China have a natural geopolitical friction as China expands its sphere into the buffer 'stans and compete for their natural resources, which is all the more important to us as we fail to compete with them in Africa.

Honestly, if you had to come up with a coherent motive for the strategy, the most rational explanation is that China has seized enough control and influence of NATO's decision making apparatus that they are able to steer us in the path most beneficial to China: One that avoids direct confrontation that could be apocalyptic for China, but instead weakens us at every turn until China's ascendancy is natural and unstoppable. I mean, at some point we have to acknowledge that our decision making in the Hillary-onward third way neoliberal hegemony of American politics has conspicuously aligned with China's best interests, instead of being commensalist or coincidental. We sure aren't dividing Russia and China by uniting them against NATO color revolutions.
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Jan 6 2023 09:31am
Quote (ofthevoid @ 6 Jan 2023 15:55)
Ukraine rejected the ceasefire, so obviously there will be shelling. Few articles I read on this are framed weirdly. Like because Russia asked for a ceasefire it's all of the sudden strange and duplicitous that they would be shelling, even though a normal thinking person would understand that the ceasefire is
based on both sides agreeing to it, so if one didn't then wtf would you expect?

Quote (Djunior @ 6 Jan 2023 16:00)
Of course the usual suspects found something new to rage about, the Christmas cease-fire proposed by the Russians (Eastern Orthodox Christmas) while there was no cease-fire during our (Western) Christmas Celebrations! Well guess what:
You seem to think that the West has Ukraine in the bag already huh so let's cancel Ukraine's traditional Christmas and when Russia suggests a cease-fire (the appropriate date) let's lose our shit about it!



So you are clearly taking a side. But i can tell you that no one here is fooled by war criminal invaders. Ofc few anti-all are trolling medias comment section. Their arguments are simply too weak.
Russian launched full scale drones attacks / missiles /shellings the during Christmas 25 (30% of ukrainians recognize this day) and New year eve.

7 january truce is invalid. It is not serious, only manipulation attempt.

This post was edited by Meanwhile on Jan 6 2023 09:32am
Member
Posts: 15,986
Joined: Jun 27 2010
Gold: 102,354.50
Jan 6 2023 09:39am
Quote (Meanwhile @ Jan 6 2023 04:31pm)
So you are clearly taking a side. But i can tell you that no one here is fooled by war criminal invaders. Ofc few anti-all are trolling medias comment section. Their arguments are simply too weak.
Russian launched full scale drones attacks / missiles /shellings the during Christmas 25 (30% of ukrainians recognize this day) and New year eve.

7 january truce is invalid. It is not serious, only manipulation attempt.


Taking a side? I showed the traditional Ukrainian Christmas date (Julian calendar).

Changing that traditional date to the Western date (Gregorian calendar) is just another escalation.

Member
Posts: 50,871
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,846.00
Jan 6 2023 09:41am
Quote (Meanwhile @ Jan 6 2023 09:31am)
Russian launched full scale drones attacks the during Christmas 25 (30% of ukrainians recognize this day) and New year eve.


Quote (Meanwhile @ Jan 5 2023 05:36pm)
70% of Ukrainians celebrate Christmas on January 7. Yes i was a bit wrong, not much celebrated it the 25.
Still the Russian orthodox church == FSB, these monasteries working for Russian intelligence is not new. In the same way... pro-russian parties are just... terrible.


Wonderful math by the foot-sawer, 70% of Ukrainians are orthodox and therefore 30% must be catholic or protestants.

74% of Ukrainians are Russian orthodox (Xmas = Jan 7th)
8% are UGCC or other Greek Catholic denominations (Xmas = Jan 7th), mostly in regions like transcarpathia
~1% are Catholic/Protestant, the rest unaffiliated or undefined, the catholics again in carpathia
~0.4% are jewish, but I guess the azov battallion will get around to that in time
and the carpathians aren't anywhere close to the front lines, and are pretty full of russia-leaning ethnic hungarians anyway


For the entire lifetimes of everyone in the Ukrainian war right now (foreign mercenaries and american little green men operating missile batteries exempted), Christmas falls on January 7th
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Jan 6 2023 09:45am
Quote (Goomshill @ 6 Jan 2023 16:41)
Wonderful math by the foot-sawer, 70% of Ukrainians are orthodox and therefore 30% must be catholic or protestants.

74% of Ukrainians are Russian orthodox (Xmas = Jan 7th)
8% are UGCC or other Greek Catholic denominations (Xmas = Jan 7th), mostly in regions like transcarpathia
~1% are Catholic/Protestant, the rest unaffiliated or undefined, the catholics again in carpathia
~0.4% are jewish, but I guess the azov battallion will get around to that in time
and the carpathians aren't anywhere close to the front lines, and are pretty full of russia-leaning ethnic hungarians anyway


For the entire lifetimes of everyone in the Ukrainian war right now (foreign mercenaries and american little green men operating missile batteries exempted), Christmas falls on January 7th


My bad: 25% (and not 30%) of ukrainians support celebtrating Christmas december 25

https://www.bbc.com/ukrainian/news-50902051

"
Currently, 25% of respondents support the idea of moving the celebration of Christmas from January 7 to December 25, 64% are opposed, and 7% of respondents are indifferent.
Sociologists point out that in three years the number of supporters of the modernization of the Church calendar has grown from 15% to 25%, and opponents decreased from 69% to 64%.
"

This said, you will NEVER wash the war crimes with a fake truce diversion... :lol:
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jan 6 2023 10:01am
russia repeatedly invades its neighbours, including ukraine.

useful idiots: "why does the west make russia its enemy? a total strategical blunder."

these guys are so brainwashed and dumb, it's almost funny...


Quote (ofthevoid @ 6 Jan 2023 15:55)
Ukraine rejected the ceasefire, so obviously there will be shelling. Few articles I read on this are framed weirdly. Like because Russia asked for a ceasefire it's all of the sudden strange and duplicitous that they would be shelling, even though a normal thinking person would understand that the ceasefire is based on both sides agreeing to it, so if one didn't then wtf would you expect?


first of all, pootin declared a unilateral ceasefire. maybe look up what that means, since you clearly don't understand it.

also, your whole mental gymnastics routine there would only make sense if russia was defensively shelling ukrainian troops on russian soil. that's not what's happening though, russia is continuing its own war of aggression by murdering ukrainians in ukraine.
Member
Posts: 15,986
Joined: Jun 27 2010
Gold: 102,354.50
Jan 6 2023 10:42am
Quote (fender @ Jan 6 2023 05:01pm)
russia repeatedly invades its neighbours, including ukraine.

useful idiots: "why does the west make russia its enemy? a total strategical blunder."


Ahem *cough

Imagine raking up 500B in costs in a single year. Not sure if that included the 100B defense budget increase (watched it like a week ago)





Quote (fender @ Jan 6 2023 05:01pm)
these guys are so brainwashed and dumb, it's almost funny...


Look who's talking ^^
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Jan 6 2023 10:54am
The price of doing nothing is much bigger


Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jan 6 2023 11:05am
Quote (Djunior @ 6 Jan 2023 17:42)
Ahem *cough

Imagine raking up 500B in costs in a single year. Not sure if that included the 100B defense budget increase (watched it like a week ago)


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UPu1jboyQd0




Look who's talking ^^


thank you for providing further evidence that the west has in the past tried economic cooperation and cultural exchange, and that it was indeed russia's repeated military aggression which made it the enemy, and not some imaginary desire to make war with russia. germany in this case is a perfect example for making the mistake of ignoring pootin's authoritarian and expansionist inclinations, thinking economic exchange would keep them reasonable.

you're making my point for me, you're just not smart enough to realise it, lol.

This post was edited by fender on Jan 6 2023 11:08am
Member
Posts: 4,147
Joined: Jun 30 2022
Gold: 6.42
Warn: 10%
Jan 6 2023 11:07am
Quote (fender @ Jan 6 2023 12:01pm)


first of all, pootin declared a unilateral ceasefire. maybe look up what that means, since you clearly don't understand it.


No he didn't lol

"Upon consideration of the address from His Holiness Patriarch Kirill, I instruct the Defence Minister of the Russian Federation to introduce a ceasefire along the entire line of contact in Ukraine from 12.00 on January 6, 2023 to 24.00 on January 7, 2023.

As a large number of Orthodox Christians reside in the area of hostilities, we call on the Ukrainian side to declare a ceasefire to allow them to attend church services on Christmas Eve as well as on Christmas Day."

Angry and wrong, as usual fender. Very predictable.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1191319141915191619175001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll