Quote (fender @ Mar 15 2022 03:46pm)
what exactly made it impossible for russia to withdraw their troops and not start a war? why do you insist that was not an option?
I believe I already provided a view to this previously, perhaps you should read the topic from the start, and watch that video. If you are incapable of doing this, I will however repeat the rationale, on request.
In no order:
Quote (ferdia @ Jan 25 2022 09:32am)
Any Topic's about the Russia / Ukraine issue ?
In summary ~ the EU wants Ukraine as a trade partner and Ally
Russia sees this as a Red line similar to the US-Cuban Missile Crisis
In this instance however the EU and US are not backing down
Therefore invasion by Russia into Ukraine is inevitable
i.e. A perfect example of US-EU politicians complete failure at diplomacy
The only winner here is China which appears to be the only super power with a credible long term plan
here is another:
Quote (ferdia @ Jan 25 2022 12:16pm)
... I would argue that Ukraine is in Russia's sphere of influence and they do not want to lose this influence or reduce the "map" of influence. Putin's mindset is to protect what he has (he is not expansionist, unlike the EU). To be clear, I am EU, I understand the logic, we want another big trade partner, nato etc. but we (EU) should have taken the long view on this and been more friendly with Russia before simply diving into making Ukraine switch sides. Very few western bodies take the long view on alot of things (Why China will be long term successful if they continue to do what they do - taking the long view).
here is another:
Quote (ferdia @ Mar 8 2022 12:52pm)
...Russia is in no way liberating Ukraine. if you are reading that somewhere its just propaganda. Russia has invaded its neighbour due to its (security) concerns...
and another:
Quote (ferdia @ Jan 25 2022 03:53pm)
It's a failure because their policies led to this and they are not backing down. Look I get the view "but let Ukraine decide for themselves" but the reality is that a Trade Deal and Joining Nato for Ukraine would weaken Russia and expose Russia and Putin has spent his entire political life trying to reverse what had happened before him (i am not arguing whether this is right or wrong, i merely provide context). Why was America up in arms re: Cuban missile crises ? because if allowed to happen it would weaken America and expose America and they did not want that.
This post was edited by ferdia on Mar 15 2022 09:58am