d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1168116821683168416855001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 52,226
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,902.00
Nov 16 2022 01:04pm
Quote (DizzyBusiness @ Nov 16 2022 01:02pm)
How dare people disturb this venerable institution of reason and debate with stupidity!

I apologize profusely, please continue your reasonable discussion on the antinuclear properties of the Ukrainian army.


Member
Posts: 4,147
Joined: Jun 30 2022
Gold: 6.42
Warn: 10%
Nov 16 2022 01:05pm
Quote (Santara @ Nov 16 2022 03:04pm)


Yeah, I'm making fun of you
Member
Posts: 92,984
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Nov 16 2022 01:06pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Nov 16 2022 01:41pm)
But how do you get the country which just used a nuclear first strike to stop if you give them what they want and back off? How do you disincentivize this behavior if there is no punishment and the nuclear first strike effectively leads to them having free reign on the battlefield?

The only non-military solution that I see would be if the entire rest of the world comes together to slap total economic sanctions on them - but what do you do if the Chinese don't play along and take the bite out of the sanctions?


thank your lucky stars china was that dumb and boycott them too.
Member
Posts: 893
Joined: Sep 7 2022
Gold: 3.00
Nov 16 2022 01:09pm
Member
Posts: 52,226
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,902.00
Nov 16 2022 01:10pm
Quote (DizzyBusiness @ Nov 16 2022 01:05pm)
Yeah, I'm making fun of you


...and poorly too.

Happens when you stick your nose into subject matter you know dick about
Member
Posts: 893
Joined: Sep 7 2022
Gold: 3.00
Nov 16 2022 01:11pm
New package from Sweden: About 300 million dollars worth military equipment and about 75 million humanitarian aid for the winter.
Member
Posts: 4,147
Joined: Jun 30 2022
Gold: 6.42
Warn: 10%
Nov 16 2022 01:15pm
Quote (Santara @ Nov 16 2022 03:10pm)
...and poorly too.

Happens when you stick your nose into subject matter you know dick about


Do you often find that the people who make fun of you value your opinion on how well they are doing?
Member
Posts: 28,880
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Nov 16 2022 01:27pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Nov 16 2022 01:41pm)
But how do you get the country which just used a nuclear first strike to stop if you give them what they want and back off? How do you disincentivize this behavior if there is no punishment and the nuclear first strike effectively leads to them having free reign on the battlefield?

The only non-military solution that I see would be if the entire rest of the world comes together to slap total economic sanctions on them - but what do you do if the Chinese don't play along and take the bite out of the sanctions?


We get them to stop by compromise. We compromise so it never gets to the point to even have the initial nuke dropped, so that way humanity wins. When the wests official stance that all of Ukraine including Crimea needs to be returned for peace talks to happen, it's a non-starter and just shows how little we care about getting peace. We want to give Russia the Germany WW1 treatment and are acting all surprised why it's not sticking.

Quote (Santara @ Nov 16 2022 01:52pm)
Could you be any more naïve?

If the world fails to forcefully react to nuclear provocation, it invites more nuclear provocation. The immediate thought isn't "hey, let's stop helping Ukraine defend itself," it's "we have to make sure they never try this shit again."


Could you?

This same logic was used to justify Iraq, Afghanistan and dozens of other of interventions. Replaces nuke with WMD, Assad chemical weapons, fill in the blank. What has forceful responses begotten us in the last 30 years? I guess in 2022 some libertarian purist doctrines like being anti-war get thrown out the window because this time its different right?

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Nov 16 2022 01:27pm
Member
Posts: 54,151
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Nov 16 2022 01:35pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ 16 Nov 2022 20:27)
We get them to stop by compromise. We compromise so it never gets to the point to even have the initial nuke dropped, so that way humanity wins. When the wests official stance that all of Ukraine including Crimea needs to be returned for peace talks to happen, it's a non-starter and just shows how little we care about getting peace. We want to give Russia the Germany WW1 treatment and are acting all surprised why it's not sticking.


So your response to a nuclear first strike is to "compromise", i.e. the aggressor is rewarded for an offensive use of nuclear weapons by an improved negotiating position, while the victim of his aggression is being forced into more concessions?

By the way, I agree with your assessment on Crimea; Russia will not return it. I do, however, believe that the West and even Ukraine know this. Letting Russia keep Crimea is the obvious concession we can make in an eventual peace treaty that allows them to save face. This bargaining will of course only work if we don't show our hands prematurely. It's obvious that we/Ukraine cannot signal readiness to compromise on this point just yet.

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Nov 16 2022 01:37pm
Member
Posts: 28,880
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Nov 16 2022 01:46pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Nov 16 2022 02:35pm)
So your response to a nuclear first strike is to "compromise", i.e. the aggressor is rewarded for an offensive use of nuclear weapons by an improved negotiating position, while the victim of his aggression is being forced into more concessions?

By the way, I agree with your assessment on Crimea; Russia will not return it. I do, however, believe that the West and even Ukraine know this. Letting Russia keep Crimea is the obvious concession we can make in an eventual peace treaty that allows them to save face. This bargaining will of course only work if we don't show our hands prematurely. It's obvious that we/Ukraine cannot signal readiness to compromise on this point just yet.


Compromise before its gets to that point. I don't really care about the optics of who wins tbh. If Donetsk and Luhansk, regions who have always been pro-east end up with a Russian flag or Ukrainian flag over them it impacts me naught whatsoever and it doesn't impact 99% of all humanity not you in Germany and honestly barely anyone in western Ukraine.

But to continue a war which at this point is involving hundreds of thousands with massive amounts of arms proliferation, with talks of potential nukes, etc... Like wtf? We're losing track of what's important. No one in the US or EU will be losing sleep if one of those regions is Russia's, most Russians wont be losing sleep if they remain Ukraine, so why tf are we spiraling into a bigger and bigger war with calls to continue to do so?

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Nov 16 2022 01:47pm
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1168116821683168416855001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll