d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1167016711672167316745001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 54,164
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Nov 15 2022 07:52pm
Quote (Mondain @ 16 Nov 2022 02:42)
Japan also refused to give up. Their cultural code forbid defeat. It took 2 nukes for japan to step back and review the direction of their country.

Their only options were between surrender or having more of their cities nuked. There was no one stopping the US from doing it again and again, until Japan gives in.
Russia would (presumably) have NATO all over their ass as soon as they used a nuclear first strike. (And become extremely isolated on the world stage.)
Member
Posts: 28,884
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Nov 15 2022 07:52pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Nov 15 2022 08:40pm)
Japan at the end of WW2 had no more allies and was hopelessly outmatched in terms of conventional forces. They had no counter whatsoever against the American nukes. Their total defeat was only a matter of time, with or without nukes. Ukraine, on the other hand, has allies which are far more powerful than Russia and would presumably intervene if Russia used a nuclear first strike.


You make that point as if Ukraine or honestly any other country today has a counter to nukes. Japan, and island was actually in a better shape to defend than currently Ukraine with a literal ocean acting as a natural barrier.

The bold to me is so ridiculous that I don't even know how a rational person grounded in reality can think this. What would NATO or US or Germany or whomever do to intervene at that point? Declare war on Russia, nuke Russia? You understand that there is no scenario in which Russia is destroyed and western countries that destroyed it remain in tact. We do not have the means to stop their Sarmat, we do not have the means to track and destroy all of the nuclear armed submarines that are armed with dozens of nukes. Any intervention you might think of would mean that you are putting that target on yourself now.

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Nov 15 2022 07:53pm
Member
Posts: 893
Joined: Sep 7 2022
Gold: 3.00
Nov 15 2022 07:57pm
Quote (DizzyBusiness @ Nov 15 2022 09:13pm)
I can't imagine a situation where Russia would be desperate enough to use one at this point. If Russia was at that level of desperation why wouldn't they just flatten every inch of Ukraine with non nuclear weapons first?

People have been led to believe that what we've seen is Russia waging total war, probably so they can get behind the idea that Ukraine can "win" instead of just settling more or less favorably when this ends. Propaganda is a hell of a drug.


Lol @ wishful thinking that Russia has some modern top conventional weaponry stashed away it can use and end the war right away, little bud Putin withdrew from Kherson due to numerous mutinies/protests already taking place within ranks of Russian military unable supply that front any longer.
Putins objective is to keep hold on power, not get a military coup/revolution. We are not in 17th century where you can just mobilize 50% of population and send them to campaigns your soldiers don't see point of, even then it usually led to leader being overthrown by the elites and disgruntled army. Look how world war 1 played out for Russian Empire and what it led to.
Member
Posts: 28,884
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Nov 15 2022 08:14pm
So back to reality. I posted about this a few days ago and think it's a pretty big deal that shows how our western influence has really taken a step back worldwide. Algeria, worlds 5th largest gas producer and Africa's largest wants in on BRICS. Not only that but their president is going to Russia to talk about it and announce a "new strategic document" whatever that might mean. So seems like take was actually right. My guess is he's going to Russia so they can discuss potential ways to basically form a gas supply monopoly. This seems like really bad news for Europe.


Quote
Following the application submission, Algerian President Abdelmadjid Tebboune is expected to inform Moscow of a suitable schedule to pay a visit and meet with Russian President Vladimir Putin.

The Russian minister indicated that given "the rapidly developing friendly ties" between Russia and Algeria, the two countries plan to sign "a new inter-state strategic document, which will reflect the new quality of our relations."

It is worth mentioning that Russian President Vladimir Putin said in 2020 that he hoped Tebboune would visit Russia. Algeria is among Russia’s three major trade partners in the African continent.

Algeria abstained from voting on the UN Resolution condemning Russia's special military operation in Ukraine.

After the United States, Russia, Iran, and Canada, Algeria is the world's fifth-largest gas producer. With an average of 982,000 barrels of oil produced daily as of February, the courtly is also among the top-20 crude oil producers. Sonatrach, Algeria's state-owned oil firm, produces, refines, transports, and sells petroleum products. It is the largest company not only in Algeria but also on the African continent.

Algeria is currently being explored by the European Union as a potential gas supplier alternative to Russia.



https://english.almayadeen.net/news/politics/algeria:-tebbounes-visit-to-moscow-to-mark-start-of-new-stag

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Nov 15 2022 08:16pm
Member
Posts: 3,736
Joined: Aug 9 2007
Gold: 3,328.00
Nov 15 2022 08:19pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Nov 16 2022 02:14am)
So back to reality. I posted about this a few days ago and think it's a pretty big deal that shows how our western influence has really taken a step back worldwide. Algeria, worlds 5th largest gas producer and Africa's largest wants in on BRICS. Not only that but their president is going to Russia to talk about it and announce a "new strategic document" whatever that might mean. So seems like ^Goomshill take was actually right. My guess is he's going to Russia so they can discuss potential ways to basically form a gas supply monopoly. This seems like really bad news for Europe.





https://english.almayadeen.net/news/politics/algeria:-tebbounes-visit-to-moscow-to-mark-start-of-new-stag


I don't quite understand what you are suggesting. Are you suggesting that the concept of the United Nations is non existent.
Member
Posts: 4,147
Joined: Jun 30 2022
Gold: 6.42
Warn: 10%
Nov 15 2022 08:19pm
Quote (Palasan @ Nov 15 2022 09:57pm)
Lol @ wishful thinking that Russia has some modern top conventional weaponry stashed away it can use and end the war right away, little bud Putin withdrew from Kherson due to numerous mutinies/protests already taking place within ranks of Russian military unable supply that front any longer.
Putins objective is to keep hold on power, not get a military coup/revolution. We are not in 17th century where you can just mobilize 50% of population and send them to campaigns your soldiers don't see point of, even then it usually led to leader being overthrown by the elites and disgruntled army. Look how world war 1 played out for Russian Empire and what it led to.


I'm shocked we don't agree on this, and I never mentioned anything about some secret modern weapons lol

Member
Posts: 893
Joined: Sep 7 2022
Gold: 3.00
Nov 15 2022 08:21pm
Vladimir Putin Stashes Billions In Central Africa In Preparation To Flee Moscow In Case Of Emergency 'Evacuation'


Russian President Vladimir Putin has stashed billions in the Central African Republic in preparation for an "evacuation" in the case of an "emergency situation" in Moscow due to overwhelming disapproval of the war in Ukraine

This is the latest move by the increasingly paranoid head of Russia, as the country faces bankruptcy in the wake of his deteriorating health.

Earlier this month, it was revealed that Putin would not attend the G20 Summit in Bali, Indonesia. While the Kremlin cited a busy schedule as the reason, sources alleged that he feared an assassination attempt as the true determining factor.

An estimated $14.8 billion in cash and gold were sent for safekeeping in Africa under the order of President Putin. The enormous amount of wealth is housed in "underground warehouses" through the oversight of Wagner, a private military company and key ally to Russia.

Wagner has assisted Russia in the invasion of Ukraine through the recruitment of tens of thousands of mercenaries and convicts to supply the front lines with desperately needed manpower.

Putin and the head of the Central Africa Republic met last Friday to discuss the transfer of assets.

Member
Posts: 893
Joined: Sep 7 2022
Gold: 3.00
Nov 15 2022 08:32pm
Quote (DizzyBusiness @ Nov 15 2022 10:19pm)
I'm shocked we don't agree on this, and I never mentioned anything about some secret modern weapons lol


Russia does not possess enough non-nuclear weapons to level country the size of Ukraine to the ground.

And secondly - Putin sold Russian people the idea that Ukrainians are being held captive by insane Nazi regime and Azov and he is coming there to liberate them. His propaganda machine is working in overdrive to cover up the mass graves being discovered all over the place where Russian occupation occurred from the eyes of Russian general public for a reason. They even went as far as claiming that streets of Bucha videos was a hoax and paid actors played the role of corpses scattered throughout the streets. Providing videos from some protest rally not even in the Ukraine as "proof"

Russia has burnt out conventionally, we have seen their conventional capability for all it is, yes they can send Ukraine into energy crisis by destroying its energy infrastructure but on the battlefield, they are still attacking head-first, the only professional army in 21st century to use this dumb casualty intensive tactic from 18-20th century.

Might as well line up their army in lines as Napoleon era armies did, hand out drums and march forward with muskets to their death at this point. Trench warfare doesn't work either in 21st century, Ukrainians are outmaneuvering them and annihilating their flanks/supply lines 24-7.
Member
Posts: 23,947
Joined: Jul 15 2008
Gold: 122,361.69
Nov 15 2022 08:56pm
Quote (Mondain @ Nov 16 2022 04:42am)
Japan also refused to give up. Their cultural code forbid defeat. It took 2 nukes for japan to step back and review the direction of their country.


japan gave up because their soldiers had low morale, if they were emotionally as strong as the ukranians they would've kept going even if they were hit with 1900 tactical nuclear weapons.

Quote (SamTheGuru @ Nov 16 2022 04:12am)
It will be interesting in a few hours....Poland are trying to control things at the moment. A lot of pressure for the head of a country.


Yes, atleast nato will send 500 tanks and 1000 artillery pieces. Maybe even article 5 and they start use heavy bombers and massive a-10 runs.

This post was edited by ownyaah on Nov 15 2022 08:57pm
Member
Posts: 22,068
Joined: Jun 14 2012
Gold: 334,725.27
Warn: 10%
Nov 15 2022 08:56pm
Quote (ownyaah @ Nov 15 2022 09:56pm)
japan gave up because their soldiers had low morale


Yeah being on the receiving end of 2 nukes is very demoralizing.

This post was edited by Mondain on Nov 15 2022 08:57pm
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1167016711672167316745001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll