Quote (Santara @ Nov 9 2022 12:53pm)
Sure they do. Yesterday, Russia fired about 20,000 to Ukraine's 7,000 rounds. But artillery aren't the only weapons, and to take ground, you must expose troops to fire to cover that ground. Russia has been hurling human waves at the Bakhmut front, hurled huge numbers of troops at Sievierodonetsk, and lost large numbers in the early stages in mad dashes for land grabs. Tell me how it is that Russian soldiers, who enjoy a significant advantage in artillery, consistently refuse to join attacks on Ukrainian lines, if artillery is deciding the war. Well, I'm here to help! There's all the difference in the world between lobbing shells at troops hunkered down in bunkers, and lobbing shells at above-ground attack formations.
Russians haven't been "hurling soldiers" at anything. When they do, and take losses, what do you see? A complete meltdown on the Russian side of the commentariat and endless streams of jizz from the Ukrainian side, like we recently saw in Pavlovka. Conversely, Those sorts of losses are so normal for the Ukrainian side that it barely gets any sort of notification.
Russians are just doing what they always do: bomb until the enemy line is depleted, then move in. Danger? Withdraw while bombing the enemy.
And that's the critical factor, even more-so than the artillery disadvantage - faced with strong enemy advances Russians withdraw, Ukrainians cling. Today it was a big one with Kherson, before that it was Lyman.
Quote (Santara @ Nov 9 2022 12:53pm)
Are more Ukrainians likely being killed in the war overall? I think so. At a 5-1 ratio (your last assessment was 10-1)? Unlikely.
Earlier I said "perhaps" 10:1, now I'm saying "minimum" 5:1. Things have changed, the Russians are more on the offensive now and, unlike some here, I am open to the idea that things can get worse for the side I'm cheering on.
And so are you, it seems, since you've switched from saying a lopsided Russian advantage is delusional or ridiculous or whatever particular word to a mere "unlikely". Glad you're coming around.
Quote (Norlander @ Nov 9 2022 01:38pm)
I never tried a moose (dunno, I just can't kill a God's creature that tries to make friends and is so open to humans), but tried a deer. Couldn't say they are tasty. Prefer beef.
Moose is good, elk is the true king of game meat.
This post was edited by kusotarre1 on Nov 9 2022 04:00pm