d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1145314541455145614575001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 2,492
Joined: Jan 30 2022
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 10%
Oct 17 2022 10:49am
Quote (Norlander @ Oct 17 2022 07:47pm)
Test


Одного аккаунта тебе мало? :angel:
Member
Posts: 765
Joined: Aug 25 2022
Gold: 2,602.00
Warn: 10%
Oct 17 2022 10:50am
Quote (ferdia @ Oct 17 2022 09:36am)
sir, i don't understand what you are implying, can you expand please

The issue isn't demoralization, really. I'm not even sure that hardship demoralizes people. In most cases throughout history, hardship strengthens people's resolve to resist. Being attacked in general always results in people flocking to whoever their leaders are.

You're generalizing things when you say Russia is launching missiles "into the heart of Ukraine." They are launching missiles and drones into power plants, transformer stations, rail facilities, decision making centers for some parts of the Kiev regime, and things closely related to these things.

The front line of a conflict depends on the rear. It needs transport networks and energy to transport people and materiel to the front. It needs resources (human and material) to be spent advancing the war effort, not spent repairing continually accruing damage to infrastructure. It needs factories running to create more weapons and ammunition, clothing and equipment. It needs hospitals operating at sufficient capacity to return experienced but injured troops back to the front. A hundred other smaller things, all of which contribute to a war effort.

Ukraine is in a weird place here because the bulk of it's war fighting capacity is being provided externally, which excuses it from a lot of the normal rules. But not transport, not the basic functioning of a modern society.

Quote (ferdia @ Oct 17 2022 09:36am)
seperately, the current narrative is focused on russia. nobody really cares what some superpower does elsewhere in the world, whether it be torture or terrorism or war (soft or hard).

The "current narrative" in the West is always about some enemy or another. I'm old enough to remember quite well the coverage of the Iraq War, and even in March of 2003 the discussion was not about "American terrorism" anywhere but Democracy Now and Counterpunch.

Member
Posts: 765
Joined: Aug 25 2022
Gold: 2,602.00
Warn: 10%
Oct 17 2022 11:00am
Just to add:

Quote (ferdia @ Oct 17 2022 09:36am)
<The Russians> are losing the war conventionally.

Wildly overstated. Things were tense there a month ago during the first Kharkov counteroffensive, but surely you can see by now that the lines stabilized quite well.

Remains to be seen what the future holds, but I think in retrospect what we saw was the much under-manned Russian lines pulling back in a controlled manner, and inflicting much higher casualties on the Ukrainians than they received themselves. I know you (and Santara) are in denial about the scale of the disparity, but my reading of it is different. Recent Ukrainian attempts at further pushes have been failures all along the front with the exception of another small land gain near Kherson. Meanwhile, Russia has been making several successful pushes, both up north near Kreminna and in the center in Bakhmut. The situation as it stands now is that the lines had already stabilized over the last two weeks, Russian reinforcements from their mobilization are strengthening their lines, and this all coincides with devastating attacks on the Ukrainian rear, which up until last week Russia was refusing to do.

Dispute that all you wish, but I think the measurable parts that can't really be disputed (but ofc can change!) is that the lines are generally stable and Russia has stepped further into the available space for escalation. And yes, they have ways of escalating even further.
Member
Posts: 5,164
Joined: Jun 5 2020
Gold: 291.67
Warn: 10%
Oct 17 2022 11:03am
Quote (ferdia @ Oct 17 2022 06:44pm)
googling. I am not seeing anything about this yet.


found an english video for you, hes talking about same

Member
Posts: 56,468
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 578,801.52
Oct 17 2022 11:03am
Quote (kusotarre1 @ Oct 17 2022 05:50pm)
The "current narrative" in the West is always about some enemy or another. I'm old enough to remember quite well the coverage of the Iraq War, and even in March of 2003 the discussion was not about "American terrorism" anywhere but Democracy Now and Counterpunch.


i dont disagree with this but other people reading your statement might struggle with joining the dots, or as evidenced, will bandy "whataboutism" comments to the effect "so what if X country did or does this as well, the narrative right now relates to russia.

ultimately russia has been cast as the villian here (yes, like Iraq was previously). the western world from a media perspective has done very little to provide a balanced view, which is also reflected somewhat in the thread.

This post was edited by ferdia on Oct 17 2022 11:04am
Member
Posts: 2,492
Joined: Jan 30 2022
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 10%
Oct 17 2022 11:03am
Quote (kusotarre1 @ Oct 17 2022 08:00pm)
Just to add:


Wildly overstated. Things were tense there a month ago during the first Kharkov counteroffensive, but surely you can see by now that the lines stabilized quite well.

Remains to be seen what the future holds, but I think in retrospect what we saw was the much under-manned Russian lines pulling back in a controlled manner, and inflicting much higher casualties on the Ukrainians than they received themselves. I know you (and Santara) are in denial about the scale of the disparity, but my reading of it is different. Recent Ukrainian attempts at further pushes have been failures all along the front with the exception of another small land gain near Kherson. Meanwhile, Russia has been making several successful pushes, both up north near Kreminna and in the center in Bakhmut. The situation as it stands now is that the lines had already stabilized over the last two weeks, Russian reinforcements from their mobilization are strengthening their lines, and this all coincides with devastating attacks on the Ukrainian rear, which up until last week Russia was refusing to do.

Dispute that all you wish, but I think the measurable parts that can't really be disputed (but ofc can change!) is that the lines are generally stable and Russia has stepped further into the available space for escalation. And yes, they have ways of escalating even further.


Yeh what you think doesn't matter though, you just make up shit you go and make yourself look like a total fool
mr. I-can-post Ukrainians boiling Russians alive lol what a waste of cells
Member
Posts: 39,760
Joined: Nov 16 2005
Gold: 13.37
Oct 17 2022 11:04am
Quote (ferdia @ 17 Oct 2022 18:53)
Also I am going to defend Santana here:

you asked Santana


Santara, unless he plays guitar
Member
Posts: 56,468
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 578,801.52
Oct 17 2022 11:04am
Quote (Lvivz @ Oct 17 2022 06:03pm)
Yeh what you think doesn't matter though, you just make up shit you go and make yourself look like a total fool
mr. I-can-post Ukrainians boiling Russians alive lol what a waste of cells


where did he post that ?

Quote (Norlander @ Oct 17 2022 06:04pm)
Santara, unless he plays guitar


omg oops.

This post was edited by ferdia on Oct 17 2022 11:05am
Member
Posts: 2,492
Joined: Jan 30 2022
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 10%
Oct 17 2022 11:05am
Quote (Bananii @ Oct 17 2022 08:03pm)
found an english video for you, hes talking about same

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K8ftCqMbaI0


It means nuclear war ofc, go hide in your dog house as Goomshill is doing right now. Take phone with you, we will lyk when its safe to get out.
Member
Posts: 56,468
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 578,801.52
Oct 17 2022 11:05am
Lets see what comes out officially from Putin the next 24 hours.

also:

Quote (Bananii @ Oct 17 2022 06:03pm)
found an english video for you, hes talking about same

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K8ftCqMbaI0


thanks you for posting this.

This post was edited by ferdia on Oct 17 2022 11:08am
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1145314541455145614575001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll