d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev11431441451461474493Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 91,085
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,504.69
Mar 10 2022 03:48pm
Quote (Santara @ Mar 10 2022 04:46pm)
Lefse and lutefisk.


bland bread wont be enough to get the taste of that stuff out. im adventurous even with seafood but f that.
Member
Posts: 33,686
Joined: May 9 2009
Gold: 3.33
Mar 10 2022 04:02pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Mar 10 2022 09:46pm)
the reality of Russia in WW2 is one of harrowing tragedy, all they got was East Germany and some concessions that slightly helped bolster the soviet effort for another 40 or so years.

that doesnt change the fact that people say OFTEN in pard that the soviets won WW2, not the US/UK. the reality of them sending 1 soldier with a gun and 1 with bullets and feeding men into a meat grinder has been washed away by propaganda built on the soviets liberating concentration camps and Hitler foolishly invading in winter.


It was the Soviets that won the war really, they inflicted 80% of German casualties on the Eastern front, and diverted most German resources away from other theatres of war

If America put everything into a war against Germany, they could have overcome them, but they only sent 2m troops to Europe. The Wehrmacht had an army of 13m troops

The French were busy surrendering, and the UK had a force half the size of the Wehrmacht that was more adept in the air and navy than boots on the ground

Member
Posts: 52,044
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,933.00
Mar 10 2022 04:07pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Mar 10 2022 03:46pm)
the reality of Russia in WW2 is one of harrowing tragedy, all they got was East Germany and some concessions that slightly helped bolster the soviet effort for another 40 or so years.

that doesnt change the fact that people say OFTEN in pard that the soviets won WW2, not the US/UK. the reality of them sending 1 soldier with a gun and 1 with bullets and feeding men into a meat grinder has been washed away by propaganda built on the soviets liberating concentration camps and Hitler foolishly invading in winter.


The Soviets did the heavy lifting. They occupied the vast majority of German divisions, so the troops we did face were fighting with few reserves. Sending 2 soldiers with 1 rifle was also not the norm, they manufactured 37+ million Mosin-Nagants.
Member
Posts: 51,668
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 30,669.00
Warn: 10%
Mar 10 2022 04:12pm
your statement is so good that i will let you away with the 37+ million (noting as i understand it thats the totality they made since inception 1800's). your signature quote is also very very astute.

This post was edited by ferdia on Mar 10 2022 04:13pm
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Mar 10 2022 04:28pm
while it's true that the red army did much of the dirty work / heavy lifting, snipa is also partly right in that soviet military and political leadership had proven incredibly reckless to incompetent many times, and that without foreign (predominantly american) supplies and gear, as well as the unusually harsh winter '41 / '42, nazi germany could have achieved many of its campaign goals (despite poor timing and insufficient preparation) on the eastern front, maybe even leading to a collapse of the soviet union. the last part is obviously speculation though.

still, it's not exclusively incompetence and a general disregard for the life of the common soldier that contributed to the high losses of the soviet army. they faced the majority of the reich's elite and veteran troops, and later on particularly fierce resistance out of fear of (retaliatory) cruelties.
Member
Posts: 2,953
Joined: Dec 16 2021
Gold: 60.00
Mar 10 2022 04:29pm
russia is using weapons that vaporize human bodies wth , why isn’t these weapons in call of duty lmao but for real wtf is that

This post was edited by TerpyKind on Mar 10 2022 04:30pm
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Mar 10 2022 04:33pm
Quote (TerpyKind @ 10 Mar 2022 23:29)
russia is using weapons that vaporize human bodies wth , why isn’t these weapons in call of duty lmao but for real wtf is that


they also mined agreed upon evacuation routes, bombed a maternity ward, looted civilians, and committed a bunch of other blatant war crimes.
this is only going to get worse the longer they are met with heavy resistance and can't capture major cities. indiscriminate bombing and cruelty against innocent people will only ramp up.
Member
Posts: 52,044
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,933.00
Mar 10 2022 04:42pm
Quote (ferdia @ Mar 10 2022 04:12pm)
your statement is so good that i will let you away with the 37+ million (noting as i understand it thats the totality they made since inception 1800's). your signature quote is also very very astute.


That's fair, I was being hasty.

Quote (fender @ Mar 10 2022 04:28pm)
while it's true that the red army did much of the dirty work / heavy lifting, snipa is also partly right in that soviet military and political leadership had proven incredibly reckless to incompetent many times, and that without foreign (predominantly american) supplies and gear, as well as the unusually harsh winter '41 / '42, nazi germany could have achieved many of its campaign goals (despite poor timing and insufficient preparation) on the eastern front, maybe even leading to a collapse of the soviet union. the last part is obviously speculation though.

still, it's not exclusively incompetence and a general disregard for the life of the common soldier that contributed to the high losses of the soviet army. they faced the majority of the reich's elite and veteran troops, and later on particularly fierce resistance out of fear of (retaliatory) cruelties.


Those orders to ban retreat cut both ways, to be fair, though with the Germans, it didn't become a serious strategic problem until Stalingrad.
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Mar 10 2022 05:08pm
Quote (Santara @ 10 Mar 2022 23:42)
That's fair, I was being hasty.



Those orders to ban retreat cut both ways, to be fair, though with the Germans, it didn't become a serious strategic problem until Stalingrad.


as a fellow student of history i'm sure you're aware that soviet leadership incompetence and disregard for life extended well beyond stalin's infamous order #270. i'm referring to internal plotting and intrigues within the generals, severe command structure and communication flaws, reckless and ultimately costly operations for marginal (symbolic) gain, literally throwing men into the meat grinder...

again, this is not to say that the red army was entirely ineffective and incompetent throughout the whole war, or anything along those lines. no, they had some fantastic military equipment at their disposal, generally brave troops, and some outright brilliant military minds (marshal zhukov for example, a true genius) - i'm just saying that their blood toll was significantly higher than it could have been with better leadership.
Member
Posts: 51,668
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 30,669.00
Warn: 10%
Mar 10 2022 05:11pm
Daily headlines:

Ireland: No progress made during Russia-Ukraine talks
England: On the front line: If Kharkiv falls, Ukraine falls
Israel: Hospitals, 'false flags' and chemical weapons: Russia uses its Syria playbook - analysis
Holland: Dutch King and Queen visit Ukrainians sheltering at refugee site
Russia: Putin calls on West not to blame Russia for surge in energy prices and also Russia does not want war but will ensure independence from West, Lavrov stresses
Germany: How Vladimir Putin Brought the West Together and also Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine Is Driving Up Grain Prices
Australia: Ukraine Russia conflict live updates: ‘Desperate’ Putin fires generals over invasion fail
China: Nations urged to de-escalate Russia-Ukraine conflict
America (no not foxnews): Russia Pushes Into Smaller Cities as It Tries to Encircle Kyiv
ok fine Foxnews: Harris, Poland president insist they are 'unified' after dispute over jets for Ukraine: LIVE UPDATES
Al Jazeera: Half of Kyiv population has fled, says Ukrainian capital’s mayor and Ukraine tells IAEA it lost contact with Chernobyl: Live News (note: Russia says Belarus restored power supply at Chernobyl nuclear plant)
India: Russia confirms use of TOS-1A weapon system in Ukraine and Putin warns of soaring food prices amid sanctions

I dont see any peaceful resolution. The talks between Ukraine and Russia will not resolve anything, the two sides are way too far apart.
China's voice will probably go unheard for several months, actually, no one is going to listen to China (since they are considered baddies as well, after all your either with us or our enemy, thats the herd mind right now).

This post was edited by ferdia on Mar 10 2022 05:16pm
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev11431441451461474493Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll