Quote (Black XistenZ @ Oct 2 2022 03:45am)
How exactly are the United States losing right now? An argument can perhaps be made that Europe is on the losing side and would have been better off throwing Ukraine to the wolves in favor of uninterrupted energy and trade flows with Russia, even after we factor in the geopolitical implications - but the US? What they get out of this war, geopolitically, is worth far more than what they've spent in Ukraine so far.
They are our NATO allies, and NATO is being undermined. We aren't all independent actors. When the EU gets thrown into economic chaos and fractured, that threatens the western alliance. Just because the US isn't getting as hammered doesn't mean we should just ignore it. I mean, we're still piling on economic impacts into the recession we already have with supply chain issues, global food prices and energy prices, but its our geopolitical hegemony that's being put through the wringer. We're even degrading our relationships with Israel, Mexico and India, all while China is on the rise.
I think the parallel is to Syria. Obama intentionally inflamed the Syrian uprising by arming the rebels to fight Russian-backed Assad in response to Russia annexing Crimea, all one big effort aimed at bleeding Russia. And it backfired, hard. They created ISIS, and within a few years we were arming the Kurds to fight alongside the Russians against the Sunnis we had just armed to fight the Shias who were alongside the Russians. Because Putin performed geopolitical jiu jitsu and let the war fester by design so Assad's barrel bombs would keep funneling refugees to the EU until it cracked, which it did with Brexit.
We should be opposing Putin by actually outplaying him, not falling into his traps.
Quote
Also, from the point of view of ordinary Russians, Putinism is definitely not serving their rational self-interest; does definitely not represent "winning". Russia has ludicrous amounts of natural resources and fertile land, relative to its comparatively small population. Russia should and could be a 30 times larger version of Norway if it was competently run, instead of being bled dry by Putin's corrupt cleptocracy.
In the time he's been in charge their quality of life has pentupled and there have been no massive purges or repressive shows of force necessary to maintain order. He even tamped down the culture of bribery and overthrew the kleptocrats.
We can't really judge societies by the utopian ideals that could exist if all natural resources were fully utilized. Pretty sure the Great Lakes could provide for a better life than most residents of Milwaukee, Chicago, Detroit & Cleveland have right now