Quote (fender @ Sep 22 2022 05:24pm)
i'm just ignoring your desperate attempts to make this personal and focus on the hypothetical:
ok, no reparations, regardless of who started the war and who targeted civilian infrastructure in whose country then. understood. second part: who gets the regions in question, who gets crimea? again, regardless of real life feasibility, just according to what you, ferdia, think would be fair?
You made it personal here:
Quote (fender @ Sep 22 2022 04:37pm)
i had hoped you were intelligent enough to recognise this is a hypothetical. of course you can't make both sides happy at this point, i thought that was understood. my goal here is not to craft a realistic peace plan and send you, ferdia, as a negotiator to implement it, i was just curious what you PERSONALLY would consider as fair. i wrote the line about "both parties would be totally ok with it" in order to signal that i don't want you to hide behind feasibility concerns as an excuse. would be great if you could answer this, but a refusal to do so is an answer in itself as well to be fair...
concerning your "peace treaty": that's literally what russia is trying to sell as a compromise and in REALITY it means:
and here:
Quote (fender @ Sep 22 2022 04:51pm)
you gave me your "view" within the perimeters that YOU chose to accept, because it allows you to hide behind what you believe is "realistically" possible, since you apparently don't want to tell me what YOU think would be fair, regardless of feasibility. so by all means, pretend to not understand what i'm asking to repeatedly post russia's idea of a compromise, but don't think i don't realise what you're doing. again, it speaks for itself, even though it's not a direct answer...
(note that you bolded those phrases not me, ergo you made it personal first.)
in answer to your second point:
fairness has nothing to do with it. The word "fairness" should be removed from the question. I also dont understand why you are a dog with a bone on these points ?
"fairness" would mean undoubtedly that eastern ukraine become independent. Thats what ukraine gets for bombing the shit out of its own people for a decade and not entertaining a settlement when it could have.
crimea, leaving fairness at the door, should remain part of Russia for regional stability.
please remove fairness if you are responding to this post.
This post was edited by ferdia on Sep 22 2022 10:31am