d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Russia / Ukraine
Prev1123912401241124212435001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Sep 21 2022 10:01am
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Sep 21 2022 11:08am)
With Putin picking up failure after failure recently, and with the rumors about his bad health, I'd be very surprised if there were no succession plans in place by now. It would, however, be a huge mistake to assume that his successor would be a drunken buffoon like Yeltsin or a pro-Western guy like Nawalny. Chances are high that Putin's successor would be an even more hawkish ultra-nationalist.


I think it would have to be someone already within his inner circle. But as far as coups go, I think that's wishful thinking. I read an interview some time back from a Russian billionaire responding to the "pressure billionaires to pressure Putin" campaign. His response was that the billionaires were already toothless, and anyone storming into the Kremlin to tell Putin "knock it off" was as good as dead.
Member
Posts: 54,177
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Sep 21 2022 10:19am
Quote (bogie160 @ 21 Sep 2022 18:01)
I think it would have to be someone already within his inner circle. But as far as coups go, I think that's wishful thinking. I read an interview some time back from a Russian billionaire responding to the "pressure billionaires to pressure Putin" campaign. His response was that the billionaires were already toothless, and anyone storming into the Kremlin to tell Putin "knock it off" was as good as dead.


Yes, I wasn't thinking of a coup by outsiders. Putin put the oligarchs in their place back in the early 2000s when he made an example out of Khodorkovsky and sent him to gulag for 8 years:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mikhail_Khodorkovsky

The oligarchs have been Putin's docile lapdogs ever since.
Member
Posts: 765
Joined: Aug 25 2022
Gold: 2,602.00
Warn: 10%
Sep 21 2022 10:51am
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Sep 21 2022 07:59am)
Since he came to power more than 20 years ago, Putin has always stated that he considers the dissolution of the Soviet Union as the greatest catastrophe of the 20th century and wants to undo it. He has also always been stating that he strives for an "Eurasion Union from Lisbon to Wladivostok", with the subtext clearly being that this union should be dominated by Russia the same way the former Soviet Union was.

What was done to Russia with the dissolution of the USSR was undeniably a huge tragedy. It was the greatest 'peacetime' fall in life expectancy to ever occur. It immiserating millions of people. There are videos of kids recounting how they prostitute themselves for bread, in the 1990s. That doesn't mean Putin wants to restore the USSR, it only means he wants to restore the economic and military power of Russia itself so that it has the tools of sovereignty in a world where America still, maniacally, seeks the destruction of Russia.

As for your second sentence, lol. All that shows is that rather than being some unhinged lunatic focused on the destruction of Europe, Putin wanted to integrate within the EU framework as an equal partner. With a large population and industrial base, why not?

Honestly, this whole schtick of reading everything Putin says in the worst possible light is a big reason why this war is happening.

Quote (Black XistenZ @ Sep 21 2022 07:59am)
Russia having secured Crimea and its naval base in Sewastopol was the status quo before the outbreak of this recent war. If that had truly been Putin's main goal, he had already achieved it and didn't need to invade the rest of Ukraine. Without the invasion, there wouldn't have been massive weapon sales from the West to Ukraine, and without Western weapons, Ukraine would never ever have had the power or resources to take back Crimea or Donbass from Russia...

He's said what the goals were, and the past 8 years of working with the coup regime to keep Ukraine in one piece via the Minsk accords attests to him actually believing those goals.

Putin's fault here is that he thinks there is negotiating with the West, when there really isn't. He should have known that in the 1990s, and it's taken him 30 years to learn this lesson, if he has even learned it.

The West's entire decision making apparatus is based on stipends from weapons manufacturers. Every think tank is funded by Western arms companies, every general who retires goes to a Raytheon or GD board seat, every person who appears on a talk show is paid by Boeing, every military affairs staffer for every major politician came from or is going to a cushy consulting gig with Lockheed Martin. There's no negotiating with this endless pit of vipers.
Member
Posts: 54,177
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Sep 21 2022 11:14am
Quote (kusotarre1 @ 21 Sep 2022 18:51)
What was done to Russia with the dissolution of the USSR was undeniably a huge tragedy. It was the greatest 'peacetime' fall in life expectancy to ever occur. It immiserating millions of people. There are videos of kids recounting how they prostitute themselves for bread, in the 1990s. That doesn't mean Putin wants to restore the USSR, it only means he wants to restore the economic and military power of Russia itself so that it has the tools of sovereignty in a world where America still, maniacally, seeks the destruction of Russia.

As for your second sentence, lol. All that shows is that rather than being some unhinged lunatic focused on the destruction of Europe, Putin wanted to integrate within the EU framework as an equal partner. With a large population and industrial base, why not?

Honestly, this whole schtick of reading everything Putin says in the worst possible light is a big reason why this war is happening.


He's said what the goals were, and the past 8 years of working with the coup regime to keep Ukraine in one piece via the Minsk accords attests to him actually believing those goals.

Putin's fault here is that he thinks there is negotiating with the West, when there really isn't. He should have known that in the 1990s, and it's taken him 30 years to learn this lesson, if he has even learned it.

The West's entire decision making apparatus is based on stipends from weapons manufacturers. Every think tank is funded by Western arms companies, every general who retires goes to a Raytheon or GD board seat, every person who appears on a talk show is paid by Boeing, every military affairs staffer for every major politician came from or is going to a cushy consulting gig with Lockheed Martin. There's no negotiating with this endless pit of vipers.

tldr: poor, benevolent, misunderstood Putin; evil, greedy, bloodthirsty West.

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Sep 21 2022 11:14am
Member
Posts: 1,240
Joined: May 4 2006
Gold: 683.00
Sep 21 2022 11:59am
Putin is a fucking dog and deserves a dog's death. Anyone trying to rationalize and humanize Putin doesn't even deserve a dog's death.
Member
Posts: 765
Joined: Aug 25 2022
Gold: 2,602.00
Warn: 10%
Sep 21 2022 12:04pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Sep 21 2022 10:14am)
tldr: poor, benevolent, misunderstood Putin; evil, greedy, bloodthirsty West.

You everyday here argue for the evil nature of Putin, but in my lifetime America has done things far worse than any of Putin's crimes multiplied by a thousand.

We're all, in the West, living in an insane discourse where America's crimes as the imperial hegemon are just natural and barely mentioned. Or, in cases like this where we have our focus on an Official Enemy like Russia, everyone goes a step further and denies that America has done anything wrong at all in that part of the world.

Quote (claw_outcast @ Sep 21 2022 10:59am)
Putin is a fucking dog and deserves a dog's death. Anyone trying to rationalize and humanize Putin doesn't even deserve a dog's death.

Not even human, and certainly not acting based on reality.

Reminder that America's president is a longtime friend of segregationists, one of the ultimate war hawks in the senate for decades, and is currently addled with what seems to be fairly advanced Alzheimers.


This post was edited by kusotarre1 on Sep 21 2022 12:07pm
Member
Posts: 52,226
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,902.00
Sep 21 2022 01:38pm
Quote (bogie160 @ Sep 21 2022 06:58am)
Hence the big "if", but it sounds like they're going to go ahead and try regardless. There's no way out for Putin that doesn't involve mobilization.

It sounds like partial mobilization is a go, 300k to start.


They won't see the front lines this year. The NCO corps and the officer corps has been decimated, comparatively speaking, meaning these new recruits will be sorely lacking leadership. It may be too little, too late.

Quote (ofthevoid @ Sep 21 2022 08:21am)
Hawks all over the globe rejoicing. Thundercock will get what he wants, more dead Russians and Ukrainians which obviously will leave Russia in a worse state.


Why would people rejoice? If Russia doesn't conscript, they lose faster. The sooner Russia is booted out of Ukraine, the better. The people rejoicing this levy are Putin bootlickers.

Quote (chopstickz777 @ Sep 21 2022 10:13am)
Unlike Ukraine we see Russia distributing humanitarian aid and providing basic services to all civilians, the vast majority of whom are thankful for Russian assistance and hold the Russians in higher regard than their own nation's military, which makes sense since the Ukrainian army has been shelling them and trying to kill them for years after having been labeled subhuman scum that needs to get wiped out by the fascists over in Kiev. But I guess you missed that part, which isn't surprising - you aren't all that bright and you miss quite a few things. But you continue to spread nonsensical low-IQ propaganda straight outta WaPo, ironically. When will you finally rub your two brain cells together and realize the MSM is lying to you? Fucking facepalm dude.

Most of those who don't want to live under Russian rule have already left for Western Ukraine or Europe, the few that remain and who turn collaborators with the UkroNazis will simply be arrested by the FSB. But they are a small minority.

There are no rape or torture dungeons, although ironically it is actually the Ukrainian SBU who does those.. aimed at their own nation's citizens who "dissent", no less. But hey, apparently you don't actually care about Ukrainian civilians, but only about hating Russia. The same goes for most westerners.



Yes I'm aware of how the Eurolemmings have gone full Russophobe. That is why they are embracing the modern incarnation of the Nazi movement in Ukraine. Europe has re-embraced fascism and is openly supporting neonazi filth in Ukraine while at the same time working on enslaving their own people at home.

Europe is a joke and should be utterly ashamed of itself. They are a disgrace to their ancestors who fought in ww2 and a total fucking disgrace to every single politician that embraced peace in the post-ww2 aftermath. They have spit on their own legacy and are now once again destroying themselves just to try and finally destroy Russia, just like what they did with Napoleon's "Grand Armee" and with Hitler's Third Reich. Now they are doing it again through a proxy war in Ukraine, by once again providing support for Nazis. Europe has learned nothing from its own past and is now in the process of repeating it. Of course, it helps that every single Eurolemming government is totally subservient to the WEF, with the sole exception of Hungary apparently.

But none of that will stop the Poles or Romanians from grabbing UkroNazi territory once Ukraine disintegrates. They are inherently greedy, scheming, petty people. They will grab land. And Ukraine's disintegration by the way is a 100% guarantee. All that will be left of Ukraine when this is done is a tiny, mini-Banderastan comprised of Lviv and some of the areas around it where the UkroNazi ideology has taken a very strong hold. Russia will not want this area. They will however, take the entire east and southern coastal areas. They will get Odessa and they will make that land bridge to Transnistria. Ukraine signed its own death warrant when it refused to negotiate after Brandon and Boris Johnson gave them the order not to.

Russia won't care that some of these areas they take might end up sharing a border with Poland and Romania. The land that was formerly Ukraine will nevertheless serve as an additional buffer between the Russian mainland and NATO. Along with giving them a whole other host of benefits. But I digress, you're smart enough to understand hopefully.


That's as far as I got before my eyes glazed over. No one should have to plough through that many lies and think there's an honest discussion afoot. Huylo gonna huylo.
Member
Posts: 9,155
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Sep 21 2022 01:41pm
Putin's Cry Wolf rehtoric in response to failed special ops aggression is a pathetic posture. Hopefully strength of the Russian people will prevail over the little man.
Member
Posts: 52,226
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,902.00
Sep 21 2022 01:50pm
Quote (RedFromWinter @ Sep 21 2022 02:41pm)
Putin's Cry Wolf rehtoric in response to failed special ops aggression is a pathetic posture. Hopefully strength of the Russian people will prevail over the little man.


By and large, the Russian people support him:

https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1516162437455654913.html
Member
Posts: 3,771
Joined: Sep 29 2021
Gold: 14,158.00
Sep 21 2022 01:57pm
Quote (ferdia @ Sep 21 2022 09:48am)
you didnt miss anything.


You miss everything lol.

I have no respect for people who don't want to hear the truth and just tune out and plug their ears when that cold hard truth is dealt out to them.

Screw the UkroNazis. I'll tell you what's gonna happen. Russia is going to win the war and annex half of Ukraine - this is inevitable. The west will have wasted hundreds of billions on military equipment that all got blown up.

Ukraine ceases to exist. And on top of that, the people behind the 2014 coup - Barack Obama and Victoria Nuland - are going to be recognized as warcriminals responsible for the deaths of hundreds of thousands of innocent people and responsible for the war in Ukraine.

And they are going to go to prison for it.

It's coming. And when it does, the world will rejoice while all the idiot propaganda swallowers will be stuck holding their dicks in their hands in the end. Wondering what the hell happened - how everything turned out to be the opposite in reality compared to what was in their idiot brains.

Have fun with that ; )
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1123912401241124212435001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll